Mozilla designer proposes website privacy icons

Jos

Posts: 3,073   +97
Mozilla is working on a simple a straightforward set of icons that websites can use to make their often complicated privacy policies more transparent to users. The idea is to have a visual representation of how your personal data is being handled, with icons indicating whether it is shared with advertisers or sold to third parties, for how long collected information is stored, how easy it is for law enforcement to obtain visitor records and so on.

Read the whole story
 

TomSEA

Posts: 3,235   +1,830
This is a great idea, but I think the reality of it is suspect. No web site is going to want the "we sell your information" icon on their website. They'll find some way to either block it or fraudulently put up the "we don't sell your info" icon instead.
 

gwailo247

Posts: 2,006   +18
Is there going to be an icon with a stylized burglar mask and a dollar sign "Your data may be stolen"?
 
G

Guest

@Guest1: A stylized person with a dollar sign for a head. Or something less scrupulous like two people, a back alley, and a jar of lube.

On a more constructive note, how would this exactly work? From what I understand, you'd really need something akin to a CA like VeriSign to give icons some credence, or a system like Web of Trust for a more democratic flavor. And then there's the judging process, since everyone and anyone is a lawyer on the Internet and can finagle with words as strictly and as loosely as they want in regards to what constitutes data retention, necessary information sharing to advertisers, and whatnot.

Most of the big sites would ostensibly qualify for red icons, anyway, but that won't stop people from using those sites on a daily basis. At which point people would stop caring if *any* site has a red icon or not.

In this end, this is all just a bunch of icons.
 

Benny26

Posts: 1,378   +68
Guest said:
So which information stealing/selling icon does Facebook get? :)
The yellow nuclear sign icon?...A mushroom cloud icon?..Or maybe an icon with a big red cross through it?

With the line "Your data matters to Facebook" (in the sense that we want everybody else know what that data is).
 

matrix86

Posts: 851   +39
I think Mozilla's heart is in the right place, and I applaud them, but I just don't see this working out. Too many issues to run into with it. Nice try, though, guys.
 

Gars

Posts: 262   +9
/off/ Facebook - what about a white skull with crossed bones on black background? /.off/

im with matrix86 and the other guys
nice try but useless
 

ucould2

Posts: 258   +2
benny26 said:
Guest said:
So which information stealing/selling icon does Facebook get? :)
The yellow nuclear sign icon?...A mushroom cloud icon?..Or maybe an icon with a big red cross through it?

With the line "Your data matters to Facebook" (in the sense that we want everybody else know what that data is).
"DOH" I just got on "the books"
I fell like a "clown" with a big red nose or a target on my backside