New study claims data harvesting among Android apps is "out of control"

midian182

Posts: 10,757   +142
Staff member
In brief: It’s no secret that mobile apps harvest user data and share it with other companies, but the true extent of this practice may come as a surprise. In a new study carried out by researchers from Oxford University, it’s revealed that almost 90 percent of free apps on the Google Play store share data with Alphabet.

The researchers, who analyzed 959,000 apps from the US and UK Google Play stores, said data harvesting and sharing by mobile apps was now “out of control.”

“We find that most apps contain third party tracking, and the distribution of trackers is long-tailed with several highly dominant trackers accounting for a large portion of the coverage,” reads the report.

It’s revealed that most of the apps, 88.4 percent, could share data with companies owned by Google parent Alphabet. Next came a firm that’s no stranger to data sharing controversies, Facebook (42.5 percent), followed by Twitter (33.8 percent), Verizon (26.27 percent), Microsoft (22.75 percent), and Amazon (17.91 percent).

According to The Financial Times, which first reported the research, information shared by these third-party apps can include age, gender, location, and information about a user’s other installed apps. The data "enables construction of detailed profiles about individuals, which could include inferences about shopping habits, socio-economic class or likely political opinions."

Big firms then use the data for a variety of purposes, such as credit scoring and for targeting political messages, but its main use is often ad targeting. Not surprising, given that revenue from online advertising is now over $59 billion per year.

According to the research, the average app transfers data to five tracker companies, which pass the data on to larger firms. The biggest culprits are news apps and those aimed at children, both of which tend to have the most third-party trackers associated with them.

The problem, according to project lead Reuben Binns, is due to most apps being free and relying on advertising to make money. As such, data sharing has become rampant.

Responding to the report, Google said: "Across Google and in Google Play we have clear policies and guidelines for how developers and third-party apps can handle data and we require developers to be transparent and ask for user permission. If an app violates our policies, we take action."

The tech giant also suggests that the study is misleading. "We disagree with the methodology and the findings of this study. It mischaracterises ordinary functional services like crash reporting and analytics, and how apps share data to deliver those services."

Image credit: Shutterstock / NeatBones

Permalink to story.

 
I've been Android Developer of Software Development for 8 years now and I can tell you it's beyond out of control. But you can stop them in their tracks. Make sure all software you don't want to reach out back to their developers is disabled. Go into setting apps and make them behave and play nice. No need for app to access your SMS, Contacts, pictures if you didn't want it too in the first place.
 
Yes - apps gather information about us to target ads. And no matter how many stories I read about it, I still don't care.

And some of these things meant to scare us are just dumb.... like this one...
information shared by these third-party apps can include age, gender, location, and information about a user’s other installed apps.
what things there does Google not automatically know about you? They'll know you're over 18 if you have a credit card on file for paying for apps, they obviously know your location, and they have to keep track of the apps you have installed so you can easily switch phones- it's just part of your profile.

Personally - I really like it when I get a new phone and all my stuff is automatically there.

I use Google Photos! ALL my personal phone pics are on the Google cloud - and I'm supposed to care if some other app secretly told Google my birthday?
 
Yeah, Google force-feds their will on anyone using an android. My Samsung tablet used to be great, but since Google got involved it's so slow and repetitive and you can't do ANYTHING unless you agree to turn on all their apps ....... so, where is our Anti-Trust group in DOJ these days? Oh yeah, in Trumps pocket .... how silly of me to forget!
 
I don't see this as shocking. Most Android apps are free and supported by ads. Ads are usually supplied by Google so is it really a surprise that most Android apps are sending information to Google? Plus any other companies that provide ads.
 
The platform is designed by an intelligence-asset front company to do just this, and people simply don't care at all. The other two platforms are/were as well, but Apple and Microsoft at least kept it unified to one agency. Google/Alphabet have to pipe data to all the agencies, who want different data points, so Android is just extra-sloppy.

But again - nobody cares. If they even believe it at all (even though it's right there in front of us, including on their Wikis) they don't mind, and if they KNOW they're being mined they still don't care. The functionality of the device is more important than knowing they paid for it just to be spied on.
 
Yes - apps gather information about us to target ads. And no matter how many stories I read about it, I still don't care.

And some of these things meant to scare us are just dumb.... like this one...
information shared by these third-party apps can include age, gender, location, and information about a user’s other installed apps.
what things there does Google not automatically know about you? They'll know you're over 18 if you have a credit card on file for paying for apps, they obviously know your location, and they have to keep track of the apps you have installed so you can easily switch phones- it's just part of your profile.

Personally - I really like it when I get a new phone and all my stuff is automatically there.

I use Google Photos! ALL my personal phone pics are on the Google cloud - and I'm supposed to care if some other app secretly told Google my birthday?
You don't know if apps only use your info for ads. Haven't you read what FB did with all the info it gathered from people? They ran psychological experiments on people to see how they would feel like they're some sort of lab rats. Have fun being the product.
 
I've been Android Developer of Software Development for 8 years now and I can tell you it's beyond out of control. But you can stop them in their tracks. Make sure all software you don't want to reach out back to their developers is disabled. Go into setting apps and make them behave and play nice. No need for app to access your SMS, Contacts, pictures if you didn't want it too in the first place.
What about apps that won't function without some of these permissions? Just find another one?
 
If app is free does not give right to steal data from you device without you even know about it. Having ad does not give that right.
 
Back