VLC blocks downloads from Huawei devices following a slew of negative reviews

Polycount

Posts: 2,513   +549
Staff member

VideoLAN, the company behind popular cross-platform media player VLC, is none too pleased with Huawei at the moment.

According to VideoLAN, new Huawei devices are killing all background apps except the smartphone maker's own proprietary software, a policy VideoLAN calls "ridiculous."

If true, this would certainly be problematic for an app like VLC - like many audio playback apps, it relies on background functionality to play sound when another app (such as a web browser) is in focus. By killing the app, Huawei's devices could be breaking VLC's audio entirely.

If VideoLAN's frustrated tweets are to be believed, that's precisely what is occurring now. It seems Huawei device users have become so frustrated by audio breakage that they're giving the VLC app 1-star reviews, unaware that their device may be to blame.

In response to these negative and possibly ill-informed reviews, VideoLAN has decided to block some of Huawei's most recent devices from downloading VLC on the Google Play Store. It's not clear whether or not existing VLC users will be impacted by this change, however.

Whether you feel VideoLAN's decision is justified or a bit of an overreaction, users aren't too happy about it. Responding to one particularly-frustrated user, VideoLAN said the following (translated from French), referencing Huawei's decision:

If an app [plays audio], it's normal for it to be in [the] background. Blocking the normal operation of Android is totally abnormal. Otherwise, just kill all the apps, and [don't] turn on the phone, it saves even more battery!

Huawei has not responded to the matter yet, though it's not clear if VideoLAN has reached out to the company to resolve the issue. At any rate, if you own one of Huawei's newest devices, you may have to find another audio player to suit your needs.

Permalink to story.

 

Jon Tseng

Posts: 74   +45
Meh. Guess it makes sense. Shouldn't be that hard to get a copy from APKMirror if you really do want VLC tho...
 

Morphine Child

Posts: 71   +80
Idk, for occasional listening I just use built in app. Basic but it works. When I want something more powerful I use AIMP, never had any issues whatsoever.
 

Digitalzone

Posts: 132   +72
Just another reason why to want as clean as possible Android. I had only one Huawei and it was crippled too, the possibility to move apps to SD was disabled (unless root). And GUI is ugly asf.
 

regiq

Posts: 237   +113
I've never been a fan of the PC version of VLC. Hard to tweak and poor playback quality (things like deinterlacing, display refresh rate sync, audio resampling/dac sampling frequency switching). On windows MPC-HC is a lot better choice.
But on android VLC is the only app I know that plays media from a SMB share on my home network.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psycros

Badvok

Posts: 317   +162
Seems strange that only VLC is affected by this, other non-Huawei apps manage to play audio in the background just fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TempleOrion

JordLevy

Posts: 48   +15
I updated it on pc like 2 months ago and it got really really slow. vlc used to be good what happened
I use PotPlayer because VLC for some reason can't even stream a 1GB file over my network (cat6) from a NAS. PotPlayer has yet to skip a beat. I agree, something recently has made VLC lackluster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lifeispossible

Digitalzone

Posts: 132   +72
Yeah, on PC, I haven't liked VLC either. Not so good performance, glitches, lots of possible tweaks. But on Android, its the best for me. It provies folder view, library view, can play from network like SMB shared drive, has a shutdown timer...
 

EClyde

Posts: 2,304   +905
I use PotPlayer because VLC for some reason can't even stream a 1GB file over my network (cat6) from a NAS. PotPlayer has yet to skip a beat. I agree, something recently has made VLC lackluster.
I won't use Pot Player just cause it has a dumb name. Good reason, huh?
 

lazer

Posts: 347   +99
I use VLC on all of my devices and love it. Never had a problem, but then I do not have Huawei....

BTW, I never do 'auto-upgrade' - found it ends up ruining too many good programs...