Carnegie Mellon asks court to triple Marvell's $1.17 billion fine

By on February 13, 2013, 7:30 AM

Carnegie Mellon University has asked a Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania court to triple the $1.17 billion patent infringement fine levied against Marvell in December -- an outcome that would dwarf the record-setting $1.05 billion ruling in last August's Apple versus Samsung case.

CMU, which filed suit in 2009 over two hard drive patents used by Marvell, alleges that the chipmaker knew it was wrongfully infringing the university's intellectual property so it should pay up to three times more than the $1,169,140,271 it's already supposed to fork over.

Additionally, CMU has requested $321.8 million in pre-judgment interest for the stretch between March 2003 and January 14 (when jury's verdict was formally recognized), compensation for its legal fees, as well as a permanent injunction against the infringing Marvell parts.

The final ruling is expected to be made by US District Judge Nora Barry Fischer on May 1. Regardless of Fischer's decision, Marvell may wait for an appeal hearing before opening its purse, as the company's regulatory filings don't mention that it's saving cash for the penalty.

The patents in question (6,201,839 and 6,438,180) describe "noise predictive technology" that increases the speed by which circuits in hard drives read data from magnetic disks. During the trial, Marvell deemed those patents invalid because a Seagate patent (6,282,251) filed 14 months prior to one of CMU's holdings describes everything covered by the university's supposed innovations. Unconvinced, the jury found Marvell guilty of selling 2.34 billion chips with the technology without a license from CMU.

User Comments: 5

Got something to say? Post a comment
seefizzle said:

I wonder how many people right now are sitting on innovative products, websites, or ideas, because they know they actually can't bring them to market due to being afraid of the patent trolls. Now maybe this patent lawsuit is justified, who knows? But the vast majority of these suits are piss on yourself retarded and need to be stopped.

Ranger1st Ranger1st said:

Way to go CMU, even at higher learning institutions greed is paramount.. one more nail in the coffin of US based innovation.

gamoniac said:

R.E.M.: "Everybody sues... Everybody cries...." (except for IP lawyers)

Guest said:

Greedy motherfuckers: The Country

ikesmasher said:

You know, I was considering applying to CMU next year. oh well.

Load all comments...

Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.