Evernessince
Posts: 5,469 +6,160
I made it obviously and abundantly clear in my post that I was only referring to illegal immigration. These caps you are referring to apply to the legal immigration and granting asylum to refugees - which is entirely separate from illegal immigration.
Did you miss that or are you purposely trying to conflate "illegal" immigration with the legal process for immigration/seeking asylum?
Furthermore, the US deported a quarter million people last year alone, and there are projections from several years ago talking about a "net increase" of 500,000-700,000 illegal immigrants every year despite deportations. The total illegal immigrant population numbers anywhere from 12 to 15 million. So yes, their numbers are in the millions and the rate at which they're coming in varies from hundreds of thousands to somewhere under a million per year. https://www.ice.gov/removal-statistics/2017
Finally, in your very link, the requirements of what constitutes refugees are quite specific - and they disqualify the majority of the folks we're talking about. Fleeing poverty and random violence from private actors does not qualify them as refugees. You can't just dress up illegal immigration under the guise of refugees/asylum/etc because they don't qualify as such as under the law and government policies.
The link you provided refers to removal, not deportation. While similar one carries with it a penalty against re-entry while the other doesn't.
In addition, the numbers you cited (226K) are the total removals. The number of removals from ice arrest are in fact 127,699 in 2017 if you exclude non-criminal removals (which makes sense). Including non-criminal removals in your figure is downright misleading.
https://www.ice.gov/removal-statistics/2017#wcm-survey-target-id
This also doesn't answer the question of why no one is qualifying for asylum or refugee statues when many of these people should. Trump slashing the quota in half and straight out trying to ban countries on top of the already stringent laws isn't helping.
We can accept these people legally within our quota and deport the bad ones but the current administration isn't giving legitimate cases the chance they deserve. This situation isn't as polarize as you seem to make it and we can have a compromise that benefits everyone.
Yeah... we can keep out slavery (wait, we had that), immigrants (wait, we ARE them), crime (no wait, tons of crime here), terrorism (uhh, nope)... wait I lost my train of thought. What are we keeping out? I feel like we're only keeping IN our own racism.
I'm sure you know but the per capita crime rate is higher for natural US born citizens than it is for illegal or legal immigrants. I'm pretty sure the myth that immigrants of any kind are all bad is just a reflection of a white class fearing it might loose power.