Thats against a stock 8700K, with more cores, and sometimes the 8700K is faster by 10-15 FPS. If you compare then equally, its still pretty bad, here's a snippet from one of my comments on a recent review, located here:
Having recently reviewed the Ryzen 5 1600 AF, you should know all there is to know about this nimble CPU. In short, it's an incredible value for...
www.techspot.com
Below is highlighted results is a 6/6 vs a 6/6.
Saying the ZEN2 only gets beat badly under certain circumstances, resolutions or video cards is just brand denial. Across various GPU's and resolutions, when you compare an AMD 6/6 against a Intel 6/6, or a AMD 8/16 against an Intel 8/16, the Ryzen gets whooped pretty badly.
Heres the results of an equal matchup.
Creed: Identical Performance, 8700K a few FPS faster
8700K: 75/102
3600: 77/99
B5: Difference of 11 FPS Low, 18 FPS Average, 8700K faster
8700K: 114/167
3600: 103/149
Raider: Difference of 10 FPS Low, 19 FPS Average, 8700K faster
8700K: 78/114
3600: 68/95
Division: Identical Performance
8700K: 102/159
3600: 106/158
Far Cry ND: Difference of 10 FPS Low, 7 FPS Average, 8700K faster
8700K 84/110
3600:74/103
Hitman: Difference of 12 FPS Low, 13 FPS Average, 8700K faster
8700K: 94/118
3600: 82/105
3Kngs: Difference of 3 FPS Low, 4 FPS Average, 8700K faster
8700K: 105/127
3600: 102/123
So, getting whooped pretty badly, before the 8700K is overclocked.
4K results just show that the GPU does all the work, and even then the Intel chips are still faster. 1440p there is still a 10-15 FPS difference in many games. Not hating on AMD, their stuff is impressive.
Power efficiency doesn't mean anything to a PC gamer, no one cares. 500MHz is a massive overclock and it makes a big difference across the board.
I do however agree its nice to see better hardware in gaming consoles, but the notion ZEN2 is only slower at high resolutions, or with a certain GPU, or circumstance, is just not true. When it comes to gaming, they still get beat, and pretty badly, core for core and thread for thread, when matched up evenly, and even when its outnumbered, like an 8700K against a 3800X, its still faster.