Editors Liked

  • The many side activities and collectibles are a joy to complete
  • Vaults are great standalone puzzles and dungeons
  • An engaging cast of memorable, larger-than-life characters (literally, in some cases)

Editors Didn't Like

  • Sense of humor is grating and at odds with the plot
  • Obvious signposting of secrets hurts the sense of discovery
  • Expect too many late nights as you promise yourself you'll only do "one more" vault