also @ TechSpot: Google, NASA join forces to build quantum computing laboratory

iFixit: Retina Macbook is Apple's least repairable laptop ever

By

On June 18, 2012, 4:30 PM

Endowed with a display as impressive as it is pricey, the new "Retina" Macbook sports a number of definite improvements which Apple fans have eagerly awaited. However, as iFix it co-founder and CEO Kyle Wiens points out, there's one rather unsavory feature which could pose a unique challenge to industry professionals: the Retina MacBook is insanely hard to service.

Mr. Wiens describes the Macbook as "the least repairable laptop we’ve ever taken apart" and that definitely means something coming iFixit's co-founder, an organization that is definitely no stranger to disassembling Apple devices.

Wiens' discoveries during the teardown read like a list of abysmal horrors meant to strike fear in the hearts of terrorized service professionals: the non-upgradeable memory is soldered to the system board, the display panel is fused to the glass forming a singularly expensive display assembly while even the battery finds itself thoroughly glued to the case -- a $200 operation to replace, according to Apple.

As someone who has serviced his share of Apple products over the past decade, I feel reasonably qualified to state that Apple isn't exactly known for their service-friendly designs. Powerbooks and iBooks are particularly good examples of Apple's "form over serviceability" mantra, a dreaded philosophy which has admittedly improved over the years sans the Macbook Air and anything that runs iOS. This though, the Retina Macbook, is a quantum leap backward in terms of serviceable innards.

Wiens theorizes we may have the Air to thank for the Retina Macbook's reprehensible interior. Since the iBook was left to deservedly rot in 2006, the Air was really Apple's first deviation from a streak of reasonably repairable laptops -- the Macbook and Macbook Pro.

He reckons that the Air represented a social experiment whereby Apple publicly tested the idea of an expensive computer with zero user serviceability and pretty much no upgrade options (i.e. internal battery, soldered RAM and CPU). Consumers voted with their dollars though and Apple warmed up to the idea of rolling out a similarly non-upgradable, barely-serviceable Macbook in order to satisfy Apple's reimagined ideals of what thin and light ought to be.

Because of the new design, what may have been a simple $20 fix to replace a faulty RAM module ends up becoming a $1500 repair job. Well, about 13 months from now, anyway. If you're a Retina Macbook owner, that extended AppleCare warranty should be looking pretty good about now. 

, , , , , , , , , ,

User Comments: 28

Got something to say? Post a comment
  1. Apple is a great company and makes the best products,,, all of them talk and work together, all of them are high quality....

    Many selfish greedy people don't like it that ALL electronic products are becoming more highly integrated using less parts, weighing less and becoming smaller .. to the point, that they are more reliable, also less serviceable, and cost less ... thIs IS GREAT for the consumer.. most of the "technicians" out there are not skilled enough to deal with the micro miniaturization and would only screw up the product trying to get into it. That is why they don't like it. They can't make money on it.

    the price performance ratio of electronic products keeps coming down... creating the point where fixing a broken one does not make economic sense.. -I e. not economically repairable- but economically replaceable, and completely backed up on the cloud.

    the fewer the parts, the greater the reliability, the old paradigm able to add more memory, able to put in a bigger hard drive ... is no longer applicable.. get use to it....

    these devices come with a replacement guarantee... 1yr, 2 yr, 5yr.... figure your costs accordingly...

    and be happy.. personal computer repair men are at the end of their line of business...

    after the waranty period, think of your device as a throwaway device when an if something goes wrong with it.

    Apple makes the best systems... NO ONE DOES IT BETTER!

  2. Wow, definitely not buying the one with the Retina display now. I'm ok with my iphone and ipad being non-upgradeable but for my main work laptop? No thanks.

  3. shame how much apple stuff is overpriced you can buy a windows laptop for almost half the price thats better then any mac book

    Care to cite examples?

Recently commented stories

Post a new comment

Social Login & Guest Posting TechSpot Members
Login here or sign up for free,
it takes about a minute.
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.
TechSpot on:

Subscribe to TechSpot

Get free exclusive content, learn about new features and breaking tech news.