YouTube protected by DMCA in Viacom lawsuit, judge rules

By on April 19, 2013, 5:00 PM

A federal judge has ruled in favor of YouTube once more, shooting down claims made by Viacom that the Google-owned video service infringes on its intellectual property. Judge Stanton agreed with Google that it was protected under the "Safe Harbor" provisions of the DMCA.

At the heart of the matter was a never-ending stream of YouTube videos originating from various Viacom properties, including the "The Daily Show" and "SpongeBob SquarePants". As the parent company of Paramount Pictures, Viacom also owns numerous other content outlets like Spike, Nickelodeon, MTV and Comedy Central.

Viacom had originally sued YouTube in 2007, citing rampant, "intentional" piracy of their video content. After a three-year legal battle, the court ruled in favor of YouTube in 2010. However, troubled that the ruling would "completely destroy" copyrights, Viacom invoked its right to appeal, prompting yet another look at the intellectual property case.

"This ruling ignores the opinions of the higher courts and completely disregards the rights of creative artists," Viacom said in response to the latest ruling. "We continue to believe that a jury should weigh the facts of this case and the overwhelming evidence that YouTube willfully infringed on our rights, and we intend to appeal the decision."

On the other hand, Google said, "The court correctly rejected Viacom’s lawsuit against YouTube, reaffirming that Congress got it right when it comes to copyright on the Internet."

Not surprisingly, Viacom intends to once again appeal the decision.

Judge Stanton ruled that the burden of determining whether or not videos uploaded to YouTube are subject to copyright is an intractable task for the company -- one of the cornerstones of its defense. Viacom though, Stanton ruled, should be the one responsible for reporting unauthorized content to YouTube.

Although Viacom and YouTube have remained embroiled in legal accusations, the two have managed to find some common ground over the years. A deal was struck between the two companies, allowing YouTube to stream Paramount movies in a rental-style service. Meanwhile, YouTube deployed and continues to improve upon its anti-piracy filter.

User Comments: 2

Got something to say? Post a comment
1 person liked this | NTAPRO NTAPRO said:

Yay., now I can upload south park clips again

Seemed like I would get warned while uploading the video all those years ago xD

Cycloid Torus Cycloid Torus said:

So, how far has the anti-piracy filter come? Is this quantifiable in any way? If stuff that gets uploaded that ought not, YouTube yanks it on notice if the filter fails. Sounds like it works to me.

Personal rule, I won't upload content I do not originate to anyone, anytime, anywhere. Why would I steal it for others? However, I will sample content if it is available from any legitimate source. I use Crackle, Hulu, Internet Archive and YouTube. I understand that Viacom and others do not want to feel they are being cheated, but honestly, YouTube is my least favorite source. I do not see why Viacom / NBC/ etc are upset about the glitchy, grainy copies which may be available. If I like anything I find on YouTube then I rent it, borrow it from the library, or buy a used copy (Amazon and Ebay). It is worth noting that, being rather underemployed, I would never buy at full retail. Nope, never. Why? Because is way overpriced. Of course, your consumption habits may vary.

Load all comments...

Add New Comment

TechSpot Members
Login or sign up for free,
it takes about 30 seconds.
You may also...
Get complete access to the TechSpot community. Join thousands of technology enthusiasts that contribute and share knowledge in our forum. Get a private inbox, upload your own photo gallery and more.