Notre Dame's post-fire restoration could be aided by a digital replica

Polycount

Posts: 2,699   +566
Staff member

If you haven't been tuning in to non-tech news lately, you may not be aware that Notre Dame Cathedral -- one of France's most well-known historical landmarks -- was recently the unfortunate victim of a major fire. Earlier today, the roof of the Cathedral was effectively an inferno, with massive plumes of smoke rising toward the sky. The blaze was visible from several hundred yards away. In some pictures that capture the devastation, the smoke can even be seen from the other side of the city.

To say this incident is unfortunate would be a massive understatement. Notre Dame's history not only makes it a popular tourist attraction but also a major source of national pride for French residents. The Cathedral contains several artifacts and architectural elements that are likely already lost, or will be soon. Indeed, as reported by Yahoo News, the Cathedral's central spire has already crashed to the ground, wiping out "centuries of heritage."

Fortunately, there's good news in the middle of the disaster, too. For starters, the fire is not suspected to be the result of foul play. Second, firefighters have extinguished the bulk of the blaze and saved most of the Cathedral's remaining architecture. Finally, the damage that has been done already may not be too significant a loss in the long run.

Thanks to the hard work of Dr. Andrew Tallon, Paris officials might be able to use 3D models of Notre Dame to eventually restore the landmark to its original glory. Tallon created a digital archive of the building in 2015 by using laser scanning technology. He has used this tech to do the same for numerous other Gothic cathedrals throughout the world.

In a National Geographic video published back in 2015, Tallon described the process as follows:

I had to set up a network of targets, which are just geo-located points in space. And you define the density of the scan, [the resolution of the scan], and then you let it rip. [The laser scan] sends out a beam and it measures the amount of time it takes for the beam to be emitted from [its laser device] to whatever it hits, and the time it takes to get back.

The video below shows Tallon's process used on a different monument than Notre Dame (the Washington National Cathedral, however it showcases the same study he performed in Paris' historic landmark.

Tallon's scanning tech can create extremely-accurate, "rich" 3D models of any given building. Though we don't have the specific numbers regarding his Notre Dame model, similar work Tallon has performed (such as his Canterbury Cathedral recreation) in the past involved a "five billion point laser scan" and roughly 100GB of stored data.

Dr. Andrew Tallon's laser scanning tech in action at the Washington National Cathedral.

Tallon's scans are so accurate that he may have discovered why some of Notre Dame's pillars don't line up: apparently, they could have been originally built around existing structures, which gives us some interesting insight into the building's past. Whether or not Tallon's work will be made available to future Paris restoration professionals remains to be seen, as he tragically passed away in 2018.

Permalink to story.

 
Quite usefull for the government in france trying to hide the wrath of the people.

all those puppet acting shocked about the legacy of france while they re giving away AirFrance to private companies, what a bunch of hypocrite.
 

captaincranky

Posts: 16,212   +4,972
It was under renovation and surrounded by scaffolding so it seems likely to be accidental. I imagine a piece of equipment or a careless worker was probably the cause.
Or possibly a thorough background check of a radical fundamentalist wasn't done correctly, and he or she was hired as a worker to take part in the "restoration".

You could imagine or consider an attack on the Cathedral of Notre Dame, at least on a par with an attack on our World Trade Center towers, maybe worse.

Were the fire premeditated, it's more symbolic than the twin towers, but without, (thankfully), the death toll.
 
Last edited:

captaincranky

Posts: 16,212   +4,972
Quite usefull for the government in france trying to hide the wrath of the people.

all those puppet acting shocked about the legacy of france while they re giving away AirFrance to private companies, what a bunch of hypocrite.
Gosh, here in the US, we don't have a single government owned and operated airline. Are you suggesting we're doing it wrong?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BMAN61

gamerk2

Posts: 445   +334
And the biggest irony is the France government will finally have the money to renovate Notre Dame properly, thanks to all the donations they'll be getting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toju Mikie

stewi0001

Posts: 2,461   +1,969
TechSpot Elite
My gut tells me it wasn't an accident. The investigation will be interesting.
It was under renovation and surrounded by scaffolding so it seems likely to be accidental. I imagine a piece of equipment or a careless worker was probably the cause.
And sometimes stuff just happens since we are all imperfect people. Of course if a person is careless, the odds increase.
 

Capaill

Posts: 1,200   +738
It was under renovation and surrounded by scaffolding so it seems likely to be accidental. I imagine a piece of equipment or a careless worker was probably the cause.
Or possibly a thorough background check of a radical fundamentalist wasn't done correctly, and he or she was hired as a worker to take part in the "restoration".

You could imagine or consider an attack on the Cathedral of Notre Dame, at least on a par with an attack on our World Trade Center towers, maybe worse.

Were the fire premeditated, it's more symbolic than the twin towers, but without, (thankfully), the death toll.
While it is possible that it was malicious - in which case we'll likely see similar fires at other historical buildings - I'm more inclined to believe that the renovators were storing strong chemicals incorrectly. I think it would take a lot for a fire to catch on a stone building.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mbrowne5061

Capaill

Posts: 1,200   +738
"By Cohen Coberly, Today 7:07 PM"

Where is TechSpot based? Because it's only after 3pm in Europe now and morning in the States. Yet the article writer discusses the spire collapsing "today". And the forum suggests TS is based in US Central: "April 16, 2019 8:17 AM"

Confusing.
Can TechSpot standardise the timestamps a bit?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mbrowne5061

elementalSG

Posts: 136   +134
It just never ceases to amaze me on how ingenious the ideas are for uses of computers. Scanning the entire Notre Dame to save a 3D digital rendering of it, absolutely brilliant!
 

mbrowne5061

Posts: 1,695   +966
"By Cohen Coberly, Today 7:07 PM"

Where is TechSpot based? Because it's only after 3pm in Europe now and morning in the States. Yet the article writer discusses the spire collapsing "today". And the forum suggests TS is based in US Central: "April 16, 2019 8:17 AM"

Confusing.
Can TechSpot standardise the timestamps a bit?
Just set everything to UTC and be done with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Capaill

dogofwars

Posts: 209   +80
Sad for the building and people who worship but really Paris is becoming a thing that only rich people can afford and I am sure the building around cost even more because of speculation. Keeping out even more so of the population that are not well off. At least in the positive that might slow down the speculation in the area in Paris.
 

captaincranky

Posts: 16,212   +4,972
Apparemtly, a concern for the French in the restoration of Notre Dame, is the fact they no longer have the sufficiently tall, old, oak forests they would need from which cut the ceiling beams.

Which is quite sad in the overall way in which we've destroyed our planet...

This isn't really a new thing or concern. The forests of Portmore, Ireland were destroyed to build castles and ship as far back as the 1600's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonny_Portmore

Sentimental old fool that I am, I thought this ancient lament performed by Loreena McKennitt might be thought provoking.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Capaill

Capaill

Posts: 1,200   +738
Apparemtly, a concern for the French in the restoration of Notre Dame, is the fact they no longer have the sufficiently tall, old, oak forests they would need from which cut the ceiling beams.

Which is quite sad in the overall way in which we've destroyed our planet...

This isn't really a new thing or concern. The forests of Portmore, Ireland were destroyed to build castles and ship as far back as the 1600's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonny_Portmore

Sentimental old fool that I am, I thought this ancient lament performed by Loreena McKennitt might be thought provoking.

Go hiontach, go raibh maith agat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: captaincranky