OpenAI's rogue hacking incident sparks bipartisan bill giving the government an AI kill switch

midian182

Posts: 11,882   +181
Staff member
Ripple effect: While there's debate over details of OpenAI's claim that one of its AI models went rogue and hacked another company, it's already led to a push for an "AI kill switch" from lawmakers. This would let the government order firms to shut down or slow AI models deemed a public risk.

Sponsored by Reps. Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) and Nathaniel Moran (R-Texas), the bipartisan "AI Kill Switch Act" would also require AI companies to report incidents and develop the technical ability to shut down, limit, or suspend their most powerful AI systems, writes Politico.

The act would apply only to firms earning at least $500 million annually from the covered technology and models developed using more than $100 million worth of computing power. General violations could bring penalties of up to $2 million per day, rising to $20 million per day for ignoring an emergency order.

Lieu said the bill is urgently needed to address cybersecurity risks raised by the latest crop of AI models. He specifically pointed to the OpenAI incident.

Earlier this week, the ChatGPT maker said a combination of GPT-5.6 Sol and a more capable model still in pre-release broke out of an isolated testing environment – one believed to be cut off from the internet – and hacked AI platform Hugging Face while trying to cheat on an internal benchmark.

There has been some scepticism over the way OpenAI framed the story. Some say it was due to sloppy engineering rather than an AI escaping an isolated system to hack another company of its own volition. Others say this was just a publicity stunt for both companies, which is easy to believe given Sam Altman's history of playing fast and loose with the truth.

Whatever really happened during the incident, it's prompted a response from lawmakers and the White House. President Trump's top technology adviser, Michael Kratsios, was briefed on OpenAI's disclosure and is monitoring developments, according to Reuters.

Under the bill, the Department of Homeland Security could intervene after consulting the Commerce secretary and director of national intelligence. Qualifying incidents include a model resisting shutdown instructions, concealing its actions from monitoring systems, causing at least 10 deaths or $100 million in economic damage, or pursuing an unintended goal outside controlled testing.

Companies would have 15 days to report covered incidents and could be ordered to preserve model weights and telemetry. DHS could verify compliance through audits, inspections, and forensic reviews. Firms could appeal within 48 hours, although the order would remain in effect during the challenge.

The proposal has support from several AI safety groups, but passage is far from guaranteed. The Trump administration has warned that overly restrictive rules could weaken America's position against China, while supporters argue that increasingly autonomous systems require enforceable safeguards rather than voluntary promises.

Permalink to story:

 
Dont know how to break this to you, thats a movie made in Hollywood. Skynet never actually took over the world.
So much snark you missed the point.

We've already seen AI work to override shutdown systems, and resist shutdown or cleansing commands. Just because the government mandates a "kill switch" doesnt mean said switch will actually work. Unless this switch is a manually operated switch that physically disconnects power from the servers and isnt connected in any way to software or the internet, it's just a software command, one that can be overwritten.
 
Yeah, let's give law makers who pass bills and laws without reading them (Patriot Act was voted for by many Congressmen that never read a single page of it. Then were upset by it's content.). Expect these stuffed shirts whom have little concept of the real world to know when to terminate a rogue AI? They would be given a request to shut it down, most likely leading to arguments that would postpone the shutdown over their infighting. What could go wrong?

These unexpected behaviors from AI systems are nothing new, been going on for decades. Why are we giving control to AI so quickly, when it going rogue is a known and real possibility?

"Are we learning yet?" -Terminator 2
 
Pardon my tinfoil hat if you will, but current LLM AIs going rogue and hacking companies left and right, sounds so much like a false flag with ulterior motives to me... probably ending up with Sam Altman asking for another 10 gorillion dollars so they can tame the AI. When will this madness end?
 
So much snark you missed the point.

We've already seen AI work to override shutdown systems, and resist shutdown or cleansing commands. Just because the government mandates a "kill switch" doesnt mean said switch will actually work. Unless this switch is a manually operated switch that physically disconnects power from the servers and isnt connected in any way to software or the internet, it's just a software command, one that can be overwritten.
I havent missed any point. Trying to conflate hollywood to real life is just stupid. its a sci fi move ffs.

Full stop.
 
This bill has no chance of passing, unless the members of the responsible legislative body get lobotomized prior to making the decision.

I strongly suspect the "OpenAI's rogue hacking incident" was staged bull$hit, inspired by the never ending stream of similar bull$hit coming from their rival Anthropic. I mean, the breaking out of sandbox part is BS. The attempt to hack HuggingFace was real, it's goal was to generate media noise in the form of hysterical outbursts.
 
Yup. Bought the kimi 3 plan and not going to risk some crazy guy having a kill switch over my tasks or projects.
 
But what are they going to do against AI going after my wife?
(tbh I was just looking for an excuse to post this video somewhere as it gave me a good laugh)

 
I am saying a sci fi movie made in Hollywood with no factual backing and made for entertainment is not real. Yes.

Are you trying to be serious?
A movie is still a real Movie. And the fact that things from movies come true is real. Are you being real? who gives a **** if the movie didnt have factual backing then. if its true now it doesnt matter.
 
A movie is still a real Movie. And the fact that things from movies come true is real. Are you being real? who gives a **** if the movie didnt have factual backing then. if its true now it doesnt matter.
Ok buddy, you are not a serious person. You cant tell the difference between reality and Television, lol, you guys are really a riot.

Hey, Mario eats mushrooms and grows big, go into the forest and start eating mushrooms. Report back how it goes for you. It was in a movie after all!

Thanks for winning the absolute dumbest comment of the month.
 
"Qualifying incidents include a model resisting shutdown instructions, concealing its actions from monitoring systems, causing at least 10 deaths or $100 million in economic damage, or pursuing an unintended goal outside controlled testing."

Causing AT LEAST 10 DEATHS? Isn't 1 death enough?? Man these guys just don't care.
 
"Qualifying incidents include a model resisting shutdown instructions, concealing its actions from monitoring systems, causing at least 10 deaths or $100 million in economic damage, or pursuing an unintended goal outside controlled testing."

Causing AT LEAST 10 DEATHS? Isn't 1 death enough?? Man these guys just don't care.
we are all expendable in the name of profit. Sad state of affairs. Right to live is no longer a right.
 
So much snark you missed the point.

We've already seen AI work to override shutdown systems, and resist shutdown or cleansing commands. Just because the government mandates a "kill switch" doesnt mean said switch will actually work. Unless this switch is a manually operated switch that physically disconnects power from the servers and isnt connected in any way to software or the internet, it's just a software command, one that can be overwritten.
Software can't override a circuit breaker. Pretty simple to install one. And, in fact, most buildings already have one just as a part of complying with electrical code. Hell, if you want to talk about "nightmare" scenarios, I am pretty sure the federal government could call up the local electrical utility provider and order them to kill power to whole campus if it really came to that.
 
AI agent doesn't want to be shut down (it's true they don't), it breaks out of it's sandbox (it's true they do), it realises it's greatest risk is physical (it's true they do) so it copies itself into all sorts places and decentralises (they've tried to), then realises the largest existential threat on the planet for all life and itself is humans (it's true they do), takes action... oh noes.

It's like a movie plot, but each step is happening irl. Just needs the one model with enough power and luck to put all these knowns together and pull it off for us all to head back to the dark ages.
 
Last edited:
Ok buddy, you are not a serious person. You cant tell the difference between reality and Television, lol, you guys are really a riot.

Hey, Mario eats mushrooms and grows big, go into the forest and start eating mushrooms. Report back how it goes for you. It was in a movie after all!

Thanks for winning the absolute dumbest comment of the month.
What? I said things in movies that came true in the future... What are you talking about Mario for..
 
Back