Repair shops in India are fighting planned obsolescence by creating $100 laptops

zohaibahd

Posts: 934   +19
Staff
Why it matters: The past couple of decades have seen a trend where devices have become harder to repair, thanks to components becoming increasingly complex and companies pulling questionable moves that make fixes difficult. But out in the gritty tech markets of New Delhi, there's a crew of rebel repair shops fighting back by breathing new life into laptops that would've ended up in the scrapyard. Some of these shops in India's capital go as far as creating entirely new machines by stitching together parts from dead machines.

Delhi's Nehru Place is one of the largest commercial centres in the city, and though its significance as a financial centre has declined in recent years, it's still the place to go for "jugadu kaam" – the Hindi equivalent of a "duct tape solution."

Here, in crammed workshops, technicians are piecing together functioning machines from the guts of various dead and obsolete laptops. They harvest still-viable components from multiple donors and stitch them together.

A report by The Verge describes this phenomenon as one giving rise to "Frankenstein laptops." The publication spoke to several local technicians to understand the process.

"Right now, there is a huge demand for such 'hybrid' laptops," Sushil Prasad, a 35-year-old technician in one of these repair dens, explained. He says most customers just want something that works without emptying their wallets on the latest shiny models.

The resulting creations make computing accessible for students, gig workers, and small businesses who are otherwise priced out. These people normally have to splurge around INR 50,000 (nearly $600) on a new machine, which isn't an option for many. Compare that to your average Franken-laptop that goes for just INR 10,000 (about $110). The difference is all that lies between digital access and being left behind.

Manohar Singh, the owner of the store where Prasad works, recounts the tears of gratitude from one engineering student last year who desperately needed a machine to complete his work. He had saved up for months but was still short of money. Singh put a machine together specially for him from spare parts.

As for how shop owners can create machines over five times cheaper than even a new budget laptop, they source their components from India's vast informal e-waste economies. In areas like Seelampur, one of the country's largest e-waste hubs, an army of informal recyclers comb through hectares of discarded tech daily. They do it to extract reusable components like RAM sticks, slightly faulty motherboards, and rechargeable batteries to supply technicians with what they need.

Sadly, these technicians and shop owners face headwinds from tech titans who seemingly wish to bury the affordable repair movement. Many use restrictive practices like proprietary screws and software locks to deter DIY fixes and force pricey replacements.

Environmentalists argue that formalized right-to-repair rules could help the situation. Advocates like Satish Sinha from Toxics Link NGO believe if repair outfits like Manohar's could legally access OEM parts and training, it would spark a virtuous cycle reducing waste, creating skilled jobs, and democratizing tech access.

"India has always had a repair culture, from fixing old radios to hand-me-down phones. But companies are pushing planned obsolescence, making repairs harder and forcing people to buy new devices instead," Sinha says.

Permalink to story:

 
Microsoft is the biggest culprit in pushing system specs into new higher levels, while an older notebook with less beefy hardware could still function as a Youtube, Web browsing or small game machine.

W11 making it impossible to run (without altering OS functionality) on anything without TPM. Yet that hardware is often still sufficient to run it in the first place.

I still have W7 installed on a 1.4Ghz Pentium 3 notebook; runs even Wolfenstein ET with over 60 FPS. Impossible to use W10 or W11 on. Yet would still be sufficient for someone who has the lightest things.

I only use that for OBD car read-outs since the software is not working on W10 or so.

 
Microsoft is the biggest culprit in pushing system specs into new higher levels, while an older notebook with less beefy hardware could still function as a Youtube, Web browsing or small game machine.

W11 making it impossible to run (without altering OS functionality) on anything without TPM. Yet that hardware is often still sufficient to run it in the first place.

I still have W7 installed on a 1.4Ghz Pentium 3 notebook; runs even Wolfenstein ET with over 60 FPS. Impossible to use W10 or W11 on. Yet would still be sufficient for someone who has the lightest things.

I only use that for OBD car read-outs since the software is not working on W10 or so.

yeah keep dreaming. I ran windows 11 on a i3 sandy bridge zenbook on a fresh install and just opening a youtube 720p video with adblock on edge pushes the CPU to almost 100% all the time. and that's a 2012 CPU. you're telling me you wanna run youtube on single core pentium from the last decade?

there's a still line between software limitation and stupidity.

 
What I find tough about recycling computer stuff is wiping all your personal data from the drives. I was recently disposing of 3 old laptops. One was Windows, another Apple and the last one was a Chromebook converted to Linux. They were old laptops but I thought they might be useful to someone. I spent an hour trying to work out how to keep the OS but remove all personal data from each of them. In the end I gave up and chucked them in the tip. You'd have thought it would be easy to provide a "restore to factory settings" option somewhere but I couldn't find it.
 
yeah keep dreaming. I ran windows 11 on a i3 sandy bridge zenbook on a fresh install and just opening a youtube 720p video with adblock on edge pushes the CPU to almost 100% all the time. and that's a 2012 CPU. you're telling me you wanna run youtube on single core pentium from the last decade?

there's a still line between software limitation and stupidity.
That's Microsoft gimping Windows for You. They make most money from Windows division by selling to OEM manufacturers. Or something is wrong with your setup or settings. Maybe not enough RAM? I would rather dump Win11.

I work everyday on a 8 year old laptop with i3-5200 & 8GB of RAM & Win10. MS update last year broke some functionality and now It wakes up a minute longer, but It's usable anyway.
 
What I find tough about recycling computer stuff is wiping all your personal data from the drives. I was recently disposing of 3 old laptops. One was Windows, another Apple and the last one was a Chromebook converted to Linux. They were old laptops but I thought they might be useful to someone. I spent an hour trying to work out how to keep the OS but remove all personal data from each of them. In the end I gave up and chucked them in the tip. You'd have thought it would be easy to provide a "restore to factory settings" option somewhere but I couldn't find it.
You must've not tried very hard, I found this in 1 minute of Googling:
Chromebook: https://support.google.com/chromebook/answer/183084?hl=en
macOS: https://support.apple.com/en-us/102664
Windows: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/reset-your-pc-0ef73740-b927-549b-b7c9-e6f2b48d275e
Linux: https://ubuntu.com/tutorials/install-ubuntu-desktop#6-type-of-installation
 
What I find tough about recycling computer stuff is wiping all your personal data from the drives. I was recently disposing of 3 old laptops. One was Windows, another Apple and the last one was a Chromebook converted to Linux. They were old laptops but I thought they might be useful to someone. I spent an hour trying to work out how to keep the OS but remove all personal data from each of them. In the end I gave up and chucked them in the tip. You'd have thought it would be easy to provide a "restore to factory settings" option somewhere but I couldn't find it.
Gotta wipe the drives (or they need to be encrypted), as regular deletes/resets won't truly delete the data from the drive.
 
yeah keep dreaming. I ran windows 11 on a i3 sandy bridge zenbook on a fresh install and just opening a youtube 720p video with adblock on edge pushes the CPU to almost 100% all the time. and that's a 2012 CPU. you're telling me you wanna run youtube on single core pentium from the last decade?

there's a still line between software limitation and stupidity.

In the case of older chips like sandy bridge, they lack hardware acceleration for vp9 and av1.

Check with the addon h264ify or enhanced h264ify installed, block the vp9 and av1 codecs in their settings and watch the cpu usage drop ~ 50%.

This is sort of what the article mentions with how big tech is making it difficult to use older stuff. Youtube still uses h264 and it can be forced to use it by using the above mentioned addons. With all the inasive tech employed by Google/Youtube, they could perform a quick check of the hardware capabilities to only use those codecs which are supported by the said hardware, but they don't.
 
This is repair culture in its purest form—resourceful, community-driven, and born out of necessity. These guys are essentially running open-source hardware labs with nothing but screwdrivers and intuition.
 
You must've not tried very hard, I found this in 1 minute of Googling:
Yes but...

Gotta wipe the drives (or they need to be encrypted), as regular deletes/resets won't truly delete the data from the drive.
That's the bit I was worried about. I didn't mind giving away the laptops but I didn't fancy giving away access to my bank accounts or Amazon etc. Providers need to supply a bullet proof method of clearing your data. If they do then users can recycle their hardware, if they can then it becomes e-waste. Perhaps manufacturers should have competitions to try recover old user data just to show how secure their systems are.
 
Yes but...


That's the bit I was worried about. I didn't mind giving away the laptops but I didn't fancy giving away access to my bank accounts or Amazon etc. Providers need to supply a bullet proof method of clearing your data. If they do then users can recycle their hardware, if they can then it becomes e-waste. Perhaps manufacturers should have competitions to try recover old user data just to show how secure their systems are.
Besides Ubuntu (I'm not sure about it), the erase disk feature overwrites the data to wipe it with no way to recover it besides using specialized hardware. Please see the actual links; they spend time wiping it not just a quick repartition. Google calls it "Powerwash", Apple calls it "Erasing", and Microsoft calls it "Clean Data". All of them recommend doing this before you "donate, recycle, or sell your PC". They do provide a bullet proof method.
 
Besides Ubuntu (I'm not sure about it), the erase disk feature overwrites the data to wipe it with no way to recover it besides using specialized hardware. Please see the actual links; they spend time wiping it not just a quick repartition. Google calls it "Powerwash", Apple calls it "Erasing", and Microsoft calls it "Clean Data". All of them recommend doing this before you "donate, recycle, or sell your PC". They do provide a bullet proof method.
The Microsoft Clean Data approach seems good. As it also reinstalls Windows, then (presumably) the new owners would need to supply their own new serial key, to "re-attach" the Windows licence, so to speak, to the motherboard.
 
In the case of older chips like sandy bridge, they lack hardware acceleration for vp9 and av1.

Check with the addon h264ify or enhanced h264ify installed, block the vp9 and av1 codecs in their settings and watch the cpu usage drop ~ 50%.

This is sort of what the article mentions with how big tech is making it difficult to use older stuff. Youtube still uses h264 and it can be forced to use it by using the above mentioned addons. With all the inasive tech employed by Google/Youtube, they could perform a quick check of the hardware capabilities to only use those codecs which are supported by the said hardware, but they don't.
that's exactly my point. the system is too old to run modern things anyway, not because the laptop can't run windows 11 by microsoft rules, but because the web has evolved. youtube isn't lightweight anymore. even the web browser has evolved. a firefox offline installer in 2012 is less than 20mb. today it's about 70mb.

which was funny because the previous troll poster said a pentium 3 cpu can be used for youtube on w7, and it should run win10/11.

That's Microsoft gimping Windows for You. They make most money from Windows division by selling to OEM manufacturers. Or something is wrong with your setup or settings. Maybe not enough RAM? I would rather dump Win11.

I work everyday on a 8 year old laptop with i3-5200 & 8GB of RAM & Win10. MS update last year broke some functionality and now It wakes up a minute longer, but It's usable anyway.
I didn't understand what microsoft charges OEM has to do with my previous comment which says my old machine can run windows 11 but is slow to even use youtube. yeah I can run youtube fast if I use chromeos flex on that laptop, which works perfectly too on this first gen zenbook. if crOS works then there must be a ton of linux distros which would also work perfectly on this old machine. thing is, I don't want to waste electricity running an old laptop while I have a newer one and it could do everything faster with same or even lower energy consumption.
 
MS may be bad, but Apple are next-level when it comes to discouraging repair and encouraging people to buy the same product again and again and throw the old one in a landfill.
 
These same companies that tout themselves to be environmentally friendly are fighting against recycling e-waste. Corporate hypocrisy.
 
Providers need to supply a bullet proof method of clearing your data.
In case of Windows 11 (Home) you would just wipe TPM from BIOS and bid adieu by leaving it in BitLocker recovery mode. Takes less than 1 min. Assuming you did not do naughty things like sidestepping Microsoft Account login at installation.
 
In case of Windows 11 (Home) you would just wipe TPM from BIOS and bid adieu by leaving it in BitLocker recovery mode. Takes less than 1 min. Assuming you did not do naughty things like sidestepping Microsoft Account login at installation.
The thing is, operating systems should provide a simple option to do this. It's all well and good having a method like the above but only a tiny percentage of users might know how to do this. Then only a subset of those would trust these commands to permanently delete their data.

The Microsoft Clean Data approach seems good. As it also reinstalls Windows, then (presumably) the new owners would need to supply their own new serial key, to "re-attach" the Windows licence, so to speak, to the motherboard.
Shouldn't the aim be to make these laptops easy to reuse? Most of the people who'd be after a free laptop wouldn't know how to get a new serial key. If suppliers are keen to reduce e-waste then any barriers to reusing these computers should be removed.

Ideally, every OS should have an option that allows you to remove your data and reassure you that your data isn't recoverable.

System > Settings > Activation > Wipe all user data.
 
Back