Samsung cracks the AI puzzle with Galaxy S25, finally

Bob O'Donnell

Posts: 136   +2
Staff member
Editor's take: After years of half-filled promises and underwhelming realities, it looks like Samsung has finally succeeded in bringing the kind of seamless experience that we all hoped AI, digital assistants, and agents would or could bring to our mobile devices. Well, to be fair, it's Samsung in conjunction with Google (along with some help from Qualcomm) that's making the magic happen inside the just-launched Galaxy S25.

From the outside, Samsung's new S25 mobile phone is simply the latest iteration of the company's long-running line of premium Android smartphones powered by Qualcomm's latest generation Snapdragon processor. It's also got a pleasant, rounded-edge design, better cameras, a fresh set of color options, and a few cool new features – all the things you'd expect from a next-generation device.

But what really stands out on the Galaxy S25 – based on some of the demos and brief hands-on time we've had with the device – is the fact that it has digital assistant capabilities that actually work. Plus, it offers options for learning individual preferences that go well beyond what's been available on other devices.

In other words, it brings the remarkable breadth, impressive accuracy, and highly individualized personalization promises of modern LLM-enabled AI to life in an always-on, always-connected, always-with-us mobile device.

Part of this is due to the new level of partnership between Samsung and Google that suggests a deeper level of cooperation and co-design than has existed before. For example, in the past, it often felt like Samsung tried to replicate the software functionality that Google already offered in Android. With the Galaxy S25, however, the companies are working to bring the best of both worlds together to enable the best possible user experience.

The most notable example is the default action of automatically launching Google's Gemini personal assistant with a long push on the S25. Yes, you can enable that option on Google's latest Pixel phones, but it's not on by default, and Samsung sells a significantly larger number of phones than Google. That means most people will experience this for the first time on a new S25 – or previous generations of Galaxy smartphones when Samsung provides upgrades to them.

Our experience with Gemini – both voice-based and text input-based – so far has been extremely impressive, offering a huge range of options for requesting information, getting suggestions, and even participating in long conversations on virtually any topic imaginable via Gemini Live. In addition, Google announced that future extensions of Gemini – Screen Share and Live Video, which add new multimodal intelligence capabilities that can understand what's currently on your phone's screen and what the phone's camera is seeing – will be coming to S25 first.

But it's not just the Gemini integration that makes the S25 impressive. Samsung has also integrated Bixby as well as several other custom AI models it created for on-device data personalization options. Samsung smartly recognized that Gemini can offer a much more comprehensive set of cloud-based personal assistant features than Bixby, but Bixby has the advantage of running directly on the device and having access to both the actions we perform on devices as well as things like device settings.

As a result, Bixby and these other on-device models can start to learn the types of actions we regularly perform, data we search for, etc., and it can store all that information securely on the device through the use of Samsung's Knox device security framework.

Best of all, Gemini and Samsung's onboard models can work together in some pretty compelling ways. For example, we can ask Gemini for information about an upcoming event and have it put on our personal calendar.

This public information to private calendar integration is possible because Samsung worked with Google to allow data to be passed from Gemini to several of Samsung's own apps, which have access to the data stored on the phone. While this might seem like a small step, it's hugely important because it's one of the first times the ability to combine these two "data worlds" has been enabled. More importantly, it means the experience is as completely seamless and intuitive as it needs to be for regular people to actually use these kinds of capabilities.

At present, these integrations are limited to Samsung native apps, Google's suite of apps, as well as Spotify and WhatsApp, but apparently, a number of integrations with popular third-party apps are in the works.

In addition, eventually, we'll be able to do things like push the side button to call up Gemini, request a change to the phone's settings, and have Bixby perform the operation. In the meantime, the two can work side-by-side, and we can launch either of them by voice using the appropriate keyword if we don't want to use the hardware button. Regardless, hiding the workings of multiple models behind a simple, unified user interface of Samsung's OneUI 7 is exactly what makes the combined design efforts on the S25 so intriguing.

One of the other important advantages of having Bixby run on the device – with help from the NPU on the Snapdragon 8 Elite Mobile Platform – is the ability to discover and store information about our personal preferences and routines on the phone. The new Snapdragon SoC, by the way, will now be built into every S25 worldwide – the sign of increased collaboration between Samsung and Qualcomm as well – and instead of just offering slightly higher speeds, includes new custom circuitry to help with the camera processing and other AI features on the S25.

Leveraging what Samsung is calling the Personal Data Engine, the onboard Samsung models are able to see what activities occur on our phone screen – regardless of the app we're running – and then train the onboard model to learn the kinds of information we're requesting, the types of activities we do on a regular basis, etc.

From that, using what the company referred to as knowledge graph technology, it can eventually start to make recommendations or automatically program routines and perform them on our behalf (all with our permission, that is). Importantly, all of this knowledge graph data stays on the device and never goes to the cloud. The Personal Data Engine (PDE) is also what powers the new Now Brief and Now Bar functions, which serve up information based on our preferences and the information gleaned from the knowledge graph.

It's this level of customization that has the potential to turn on-device AI into something that evolves from a clever parlor trick into an indispensable personal digital assistant. Of course, it also has the potential to create an incredible privacy and security nightmare. Data of this type could provide the most detailed dossier about what any individual does online that we've probably ever seen – a huge magnet ("honeypot") for the bad guys.

Thankfully, Samsung recognized that and embedded the PDE data into its hardware-based, on-device Knox Vault security solution, which has now been upgraded to offer post-quantum levels of cryptography. Because of these potential security concerns, Samsung allows us, of course, to turn off the data tracking features if we don't want to leverage them. It's an issue that any kind of AI-powered personalization device or service is going to face.

Collectively, Samsung is calling all of these various AI-related capabilities Galaxy AI – a phrase that has expanded to cover the company's own AI models, the extensions that integrate Gemini with Bixby, the AI features built into several of its apps, and the personalization enabled by the Personal Data Engine. Trying to make sense of it all isn't particularly easy, nor is it anything that the vast majority of consumers will ever really care to understand. But it's the combination of these Galaxy AI features along with the clean integration of Google's Gemini in the S25 that makes this such a compelling offering.

To be clear, there's still a great deal more work to be done at a model integration and app ecosystem level, but at last, it seems the promise of AI on devices is finally coming to life.

Bob O'Donnell is the founder and chief analyst of TECHnalysis Research, LLC a technology consulting firm that provides strategic consulting and market research services to the technology industry and professional financial community. You can follow him on Twitter

Permalink to story:

 
I might argue that this is actually easy to explain to the common person:

Imagine a Russian nesting doll. The outermost layer of the doll, you can see the face and talk to it. Everything you tell the outside doll is whispered to the nested dolls using API calls. One of the inner dolls, probably the innermost one, is going to package your conversation in a special way that sidesteps all privacy terminology and on-device privacy promises and send the details of your conversations to both Samsung and Google. Both Samsung and Google will sell that information for profit. The outermost doll is programmed to never know, for legal reasons.

Magic!
 
AI hasn't reached the point where I actually see myself using it regularly.
One AI feature I do appreciate is the AI scanning my photo album for the over 30,000 photos I have and being able to recognize text, people and locations to make searching through them easier.
Give me an AI feature that makes me money through investing small amounts through automated day trading.
 
AI isn't really AI - just algorithms designed to take the information put into them and spit back results based on the task or request of the user. Or designed to show you results based on your user information to make it look "intelligent".

My S8 phone keeps tabs on my app use and shows suggested apps during my use of the phone to try and make it easier for me to pick those apps (that I use more often) over needing to scroll through my phone screens to find what I need. A phone going on 7.5 years old and it's been doing "AI" work.
 
Please, please, please, make a phone that can connect to a monitor and act as my PC, and mobile device. I want a portable PC in the palm of my hand that can also play my entire game library. I know it’s a big ask, but whichever company does this first will be the next big thing.
 
AI hasn't reached the point where I actually see myself using it regularly.
One AI feature I do appreciate is the AI scanning my photo album for the over 30,000 photos I have and being able to recognize text, people and locations to make searching through them easier.
Give me an AI feature that makes me money through investing small amounts through automated day trading.
We are probably using it now in places we don't even know that they integrated AI.

@techspot where's the AI overlord here?
 
Last edited:
Please, please, please, make a phone that can connect to a monitor and act as my PC, and mobile device. I want a portable PC in the palm of my hand that can also play my entire game library. I know it’s a big ask, but whichever company does this first will be the next big thing.
I think they would if they could. For starters, hardware isn't there yet (if you are talking about PC games) unless you are alright with fully cloud gaming. Apple tried porting a couple of modern games to the latest Iphone. They work but at much lower graphics and resolution. I watched how they run, it is not that exciting.
If Apple's latest hardware can only do this, well the hardware isn't there yet.
I do not think it is about making this possible but rather making it comfortable enough for people to pay for it. Your phone will probably resemble handheld in size and with the same sad battery life to be able to run games comfortably
 
Reading between the lines, I see Google eventually dropping their Pixel phone division and putting all those eggs in the Samsung basket.
 
Please, please, please, make a phone that can connect to a monitor and act as my PC, and mobile device. I want a portable PC in the palm of my hand that can also play my entire game library. I know it’s a big ask, but whichever company does this first will be the next big thing.

That exists already pal.

Whenever I plug my S24 Ultra (or Tab S9) into my Dell docking station, Samsung Dex starts, and I have an android based Windows-like Operating System.

I can open browsers, move windows, manage printers, download torrent, and play games (but I dont' do this last one).

You'll want the new Dell docking station that has the two USB Type-C cables out of the right hand side, I have the older docking station too with the single cable, and the experience is hit & miss with that one.

My parents use it whenever they have to send an email... So it can't be all bad.

For me, I prefer Windows.
 
AI isn't really AI - just algorithms designed to take the information put into them and spit back results based on the task or request of the user. Or designed to show you results based on your user information to make it look "intelligent".

My S8 phone keeps tabs on my app use and shows suggested apps during my use of the phone to try and make it easier for me to pick those apps (that I use more often) over needing to scroll through my phone screens to find what I need. A phone going on 7.5 years old and it's been doing "AI" work.
Yes clearly based on the Turing test definition of AI and also the definition used by Asimov in the 1950s but we are dealing with the new generations of humans who redefine AI as you have described: in the aircraft industry the AIs are called "flight directors". Regardless on phones they are called "Assistants", but are no more intelligent than the programmers allow them to be.
 
Last edited:
I doubt very much is Google are going to upgrade Samsung phones before Pixel phones and as you say all of the "new to you" assistant feature that the S24 has are actually Android with a slightly different UI. Perhaps if you did a side-by-side comparison with the latest Pixel we could see the benefit of the phone rather the the benefit of the OS: which is identical from the AI assistant point of view.
 
I think they would if they could. For starters, hardware isn't there yet (if you are talking about PC games) unless you are alright with fully cloud gaming. Apple tried porting a couple of modern games to the latest Iphone. They work but at much lower graphics and resolution. I watched how they run, it is not that exciting.
If Apple's latest hardware can only do this, well the hardware isn't there yet.
I do not think it is about making this possible but rather making it comfortable enough for people to pay for it. Your phone will probably resemble handheld in size and with the same sad battery life to be able to run games comfortably
They can already do this to a large extent if you would be happy with Chrome OS of iPhone/iPad OS but there would be no cost saving and so no incentive for any consumer to purchase one. Even if they could run a proper OS like windows or IOS the cost of miniaturized heat removal would more than offset any benefit from having a single device vs two devices. In engineering terms: their is no such thing as a perpetual motion machine without considerable energy inefficiency - the more power you want at the work end the more heat removal you have to deal with at the machine end.
 
That exists already pal.

Whenever I plug my S24 Ultra (or Tab S9) into my Dell docking station, Samsung Dex starts, and I have an android based Windows-like Operating System.

I can open browsers, move windows, manage printers, download torrent, and play games (but I dont' do this last one).

You'll want the new Dell docking station that has the two USB Type-C cables out of the right hand side, I have the older docking station too with the single cable, and the experience is hit & miss with that one.

My parents use it whenever they have to send an email... So it can't be all bad.

For me, I prefer Windows.
Android is way too limited for me, I need a full blown OS, and a powerful chip like the upcoming Strix Halo. It’s years out, but it will change the game for sure.
 
AI hasn't reached the point where I actually see myself using it regularly.
One AI feature I do appreciate is the AI scanning my photo album for the over 30,000 photos I have and being able to recognize text, people and locations to make searching through them easier.
Give me an AI feature that makes me money through investing small amounts through automated day trading.

That's fair. It also took me awhile to start using it, but once I found a use case it is making my work and personal life better. For example, I hate drafting emails and AI makes it so much easier which saves me a ton of time.
 
Back