Updated DMCA legalizes jailbreaking, DVD ripping and more

Matthew

Posts: 5,269   +103
In a landmark decision, the US Library of Congress has added several critical exemptions to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), legalizing cell phone jailbreaking and more. The changes come at the behest of the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) and will protect "jailbreakers, unlockers, and vidders" from being sued over non-infringing fair use activities. The exemptions include the following:

Read the whole story
 

princeton

Posts: 1,674   +1
"Permission for cell phone owners to break access controls on their phones in order to switch wireless carriers or "jailbreak" their device."

Does that mean apple can't brick the phones that try to update when jailbroken?
 

PanicX

Posts: 648   +1
Permission to break technical protections on video games to investigate or correct security flaws.
I expect this one will be the catchall defense for any pirate groups out there. There will probably some backlash about it.

Permission to enable an e-book's read-aloud function or use a screen reader with the e-book, even when built-in access controls prevent this.
Was this a problem? I can't see any reason why someone would intentionally disable a book reader. It's like a slap in the face to those with eye site problems.
 

insect

Posts: 349   +132
I think the real stick in the mud will come when "a professor" copies a DVD/Blu-Ray "for educational purposes" at home over and over and over... without making a penny (thus non-commercial). Or when a "film student" uploads movie clips to YouTube with "commentary" (could just be 10-secs at the end with "I liked it").

We all know how much the MPAA like to control their cash-cows.
 

Jane55

Posts: 18   +0
aha, just for personal use and no-commercial use, and you own the DVD, most of all under 'fair use', then that's ok...
 

Puiu

Posts: 3,886   +2,395
This is one of the best news i've heard in years! I've always supported non-commercial use of owned dvd's and other things like that.
"powerful art form" - very true! +1 respect from me
 

nazartp

Posts: 178   +13
insect, if you read the ruling it is about use of short portions of the work, not the movies as a whole. Uploading the full movie and commenting on it or copying the entire DVD would still be illegal.
 

TomSEA

Posts: 3,238   +1,834
"Permission to break technical protections on video games to investigate or correct security flaws."

LOL...what a crack-up (pun intended). Well, there's the new pat excuse to hack - and ultimately steal - games.
 

kyosuke

Posts: 47   +0
But does this mean that I can Jailbreak and still be under warranty?

I don't get the e-book thing but whatever, We are no longer "Pirates"

:D So Now people can say "I'm not file-sharing I am sharing my work with my friends". If asked what the person changed to the movie, you watch the whole thing and when the ending credits are about to roll it ends, perfect editing.
 
G

Guest

Book publishers claimed they have audio book rights, so they can sell an electronic version but wanted the ability to not allow text to speech to work. This allows you to have text to speech of a ebook you buy despite the book publishers objection.
 

kyosuke

Posts: 47   +0
lol I just realized that the DMCA are probably iPhone 4 users and figured this would be their way to get back at Apple and AT&T.

They were also sick of Movie companies and Movie stars complaining about the >1% drop on DVD sales due to "Pirating"

even better they probably live in NY and with the new MTA increase they are trying to save money for everybody
 

Wendig0

Posts: 1,153   +145
This ruling is freakin great! Now people that buy iPhones will actually OWN what they paid for!
 

Relic

Posts: 1,372   +17
One step closer to catching up with the 21st century.

TomSEA said:
Well, there's the new pat excuse to hack - and ultimately steal - games.
Not really it's still copyright infringement and illegal in the US, they have a paragraph addressing it. Just gives permission to owners of games to break intrusive DRM.
 

DokkRokken

Posts: 266   +1
I'd consider Ubisoft's intrusive system of DRM to be a security issue. I'm no pirate, but I think plenty of people should rightfully 'investigate' the flaws of Assassin's Creed 2 in order to get a gaming experience that is on their terms, instead of UbiSoft's.
 

Archean

Posts: 5,631   +91
At last this may make some skunkheads at apple realize that they need not to suppress people's freedoms with regard to devices 'they actually purchase/and own', and letting them customize/or modify them as they wish.
 

dividebyzero

Posts: 4,840   +1,264
No suppression of freedom...
and no warranty either.

Apple’s spokesperson has said that Jailbreaking can be harmful for the idevices as they can spread viruses and make devices unstable and degrade the quality of their products. So, users still won’t be getting any warranty on the jailbroken iPhone
[Source]