YouTubers The Fine Brothers abandon attempt to trademark 'React' after barrage of criticism


Posts: 6,286   +53
Staff member

For those who don’t know, the Fine Brothers are the creators of an immensely popular YouTube channel that produces, amongst other things, ‘reaction’ videos. These consist of filming the reactions of certain groups of people, usually children or the elderly, as they are shown some toy, show, object, video or craze (elders react to twerking, for example). But the brothers’ popularity took a dive one week ago when they announced their intention to file a trademark claim on the word 'react'. Now, after enduring a week of Martin Shkreli-level internet anger, the pair have conceded that maybe the trademark thing was a bad idea, and they have rescinded all trademarks and applications relating to the word ‘react.’

The Fine Brothers’ React World initiative was supposed to be a program for licensing out their company’s reaction video format and related brands in return for a share of any revenue. "This is not only a huge step for our company, but for the entire global media industry,” they proudly stated. Unfortunately for the real-life brothers, the rest of the internet didn’t share their enthusiasm. Especially as several other YouTube channels complained that they’d received takedown notices from a company related to the Fine Bros over their own, original ‘react’ videos.

Once the brothers’ plans were revealed, their channel began hemorrhaging subscribers at a rate of around 10,000 per hour. The React World announcement video managed to gain 240,000 dislikes and the pair received a barrage of abuse and jokes from fellow YouTubers. The clueless pair then released a second video stating that it was all just a matter of “confusion” and poor communication, and tried to justify why the program would be beneficial for everyone. This did, of course, make things even worse.

While the Fine Brothers’ didn’t want to trademark all uses of the word ‘react,’ the filing still covered "programs and webisodes via the Internet in the field of observing and interviewing various groups of people." The pair had already successfully filed claims on the phrases “teens react” and “elders react” in 2012, which the Brothers said would now also be rescinded.

“We’re here to apologize,” the pair wrote in a Medium post. “We have decided to do the following: 1. Rescind all of our “React” trademarks and applications. 2. Discontinue the React World program. 3. Release all past Content ID claims.”

Despite the waves of criticism, the Fine Brothers Entertainment YouTube channel still has almost 14 million subscribers. But the incident, much like Sony’s attempt to trademark ‘Let’s Play,’ will be something the internet is unlikely to forget in a hurry.

Check out the video below to see YouTube channel Mega64's response to the Fine Brothers' original announcement.

Permalink to story.



Posts: 2,496   +2,026
TechSpot Elite
Yup, I never heard of them. I'm glad that they didn't get to trade mark the word 'react'. I mean look how long it took to end the stupid copyright of the Happy Birthday song.

alabama man

Posts: 563   +355
How can someone be so stupid and out of touch with real world? Hope they die before another great idea to cash on others. Or better yet get some bad health problem that requires expensive drugs so they can see how fun it is to pay extra just because someone is greedy.


Posts: 2,073   +860
What a pair of "Fine" arse holes, don't know who they are, never watched any of they're "react" videos, but now I'm certainly going to avoid them. It's beyond stupid to try and trademark a single word, it's a word, you should not be allowed to own it and restrict others from using it in the name of profit.


Posts: 982   +339
I don't see how they thought they could trademark a genre of video, not even a name with the word in it but the word "React" entirely. They do react videos but they were not the first (not even close to first) nor will they be the last to make react videos. React videos have been a part of YouTube (and the internet) almost since the beginning, of streaming videos on the net that is.


Posts: 175   +46
The irony is that their react videos are most often based on getting people's reaction from copyrighted material and products. They have react videos for music, movies, TV shows, video games, technology, etc.
  • Like
Reactions: Gopal Bhat