While the foundational EA Sports College Football experience remains high-quality and slowly improving, a lack of much meaningful new content in CFB 27, headlined by the barebones Mascot Mashup, highlights how this franchise has already shown signs of stagnation, even if only in its third year back.
Our editors hand-pick these games based on a broad criteria: similar games that cater to the same player base, or games that share similar themes, gameplay mechanics, or artistic styles.
Then, there’s arguably the most ridiculous, embarrassing, anti-consumer implementation of microtransactions I’ve ever seen in a sports game. EA should genuinely be ashamed about it. I like CFB 27; I just don’t trust where the road leads if EA doesn’t reverse course, and soon.
The gameplay feels smooth with fun new additions that make defense more competitive and offense more skill-based. The feeling of College Football remains the focus. EA Sports added more detail to so many areas, including the presentation, strategy of the game, and in-game action. An entry with so much promise comes to a crushing halt with outside-of-gameplay choices and small bugs that halt the fun or use microtransactions to fill in gaps. Another example of a sports game needing just a bit more time than granted to have to make a game good and then adding microtransactions for no reason.
This season ain’t gonna knock anybody’s socks off, and both Dynasty and Road to Glory have leaned hard into spreadsheet management this year, but smart on-field additions to an already good game make College Football 27 worth suiting up for once again.
Nevertheless, the off-the-field issues, namely, shallow progression systems and the transformative inclusion of microtransactions in practically every mode, were disappointing. CFB27 made some fantastic key plays down the stretch in its junior season, but the team will need to make more improvements in the offseason if it wants to hoist that championship trophy next year.
On gameplay alone, EA SPORTS College Football 27 is perfect. One could make the argument for one of the best sports games, let alone football. While it's not as fast and loose as College Football 25, which many will hold onto as the best, College Football 27 teeters on that late PS2 era depth of football. However, thanks to technology, this blows that era out of the water.
If you’re the kind of player who doesn’t care about min-maxing their coach and player, or who simply takes to games like this to play the matchups of the week, then College Football 27 is an unquestionable, categorical must-buy. If you spend all your time in Dynasty or Road to Glory, grinding to turn around a program or make the ideal prospect with an eye to eventually import them into Madden 27, then there’s going to be soul-searching about whether it’s worth it to you to pump more money into the game.
While the foundational EA Sports College Football experience remains high-quality and slowly improving, a lack of much meaningful new content in CFB 27, headlined by the barebones Mascot Mashup, highlights how this franchise has already shown signs of stagnation, even if only in its third year back.
EA Sports College Football 27 is yet another iteration in the franchise, but with lots of simulation improvements in tow. The PC port is a welcome addition even with its quirks, and Dynasty players will have quite a lot of fun having to deal with a lot more expectations as they build their school to become the best in the league.
It's a mode built on good ideas surrounded by bad execution, propped up by a gameplay engine that deserves better than what's being asked of it. EA clearly knows what players want — real high school games, honest recruiting, an AI that doesn't actively sabotage you — and just as clearly keeps choosing not to deliver it.
EACF 27 is more than worth the purchase, if you love football and video games. No college football game offers a better combination of stunning visuals, top-notch presentation, customization and gameplay.