Chkdsk takes 10 hours to complete on 500GB Seagate drive

By bamim2
Jul 28, 2011
Post New Reply
  1. I'm running Windows XP Pro with SP3 & current updates. I have a Seagate 500GB SATA hard drive that has been replaced 2 times now. I bought a brand new Seagate drive. It had problems so I had it replaced under the Seagate warranty & they sent me a refurbished drive. That drive went bad & I had that one replaced with another refurb drive & so forth. I'm on my 3rd drive in this system. I use it in my recording studio Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) to record audio & MIDI.

    It seems to run fine for a while, then it starts making crackling & popping noises, so I defrag it, then I run "chkdsk c: /f /r" & let that run when my system reboots. Right now, it has been running for more than 7 hours & it's only 35% of the way through stage 4 of 5, so I'm not sure how much longer it's going to take to complete. I've run chkdsk before on previous drives in this system & it can take up to 10 hours to complete.

    I've tried swapping out the cables & changing the SATA ports & power connectors & none of that seems to help. Sometimes my system will just crash & I come in in the morning to find my system sitting at a boot prompt & telling me it can't find the boot drive. I go into the BIOS & have to reset the boot drive setup or sometimes I have to power the system off, open it up & pull the power & SATA cables off & reseat them.

    Before I sent the Seagate drive back to Seagate the last time, I cloned the drive to a Hitachi & ran that in my system for the 2 weeks it took to get my drive back. The Hitachi seemed to have no problems at all, but that was only 2 weeks of running.

    Since the Seagate is refurbished & under warranty I would like to keep using that drive, BUT I don't want to lose my data & it's been a HUGE waste of my time to keep replacing the drive & cloning it & so forth.

    Does anyone have any ideas of what else I can try to troubleshoot the problems I'm having with this drive? I'd like to see if I can get some firm answer on if it's the system that it's in that's causing problem or if it truly just the crappy Seagate drive.

    When it gets done running chkdsk (IF it ever gets done), I think I'll clone it again to make sure I have a recent copy of the drive, then I'll try running SeaTools on it to see if that will fix it.

    Does anyone have suggestions on free software that I can use that might be able to fix problems that chkdsk misses or even something that does the same thing as chkdsk only does it more quickly & efficiently?

    Does anyone know if it's dangerous to cancel chkdsk before it's finished? Will that mess up my drive or leave something partially fixed? I know it's not a good idea to cancel defrag before it's complete. Does anyone know if there's anything like, "If it takes longer that x amount of hours it's not really doing any good" or something?
  2. jobeard

    jobeard TS Ambassador Posts: 11,128   +982

    OUCH! that's the wrong sequence;

    a) fix all errors eg chkdsk c: /f /r

    [ b) delete temps with cleanmgr ]

    c) now run defrag

    running defrag w/o first getting the filesystem fixed (chkdsk c: /f /r), you can scramble good data into bad blocks!
  3. bamim2

    bamim2 TS Rookie Topic Starter

    Now that you bring that up, I see that it makes perfect sense. CRaP! That is really the wrong way for me to do things. Thanks. That may even be the reason I've been having issues like this.

    As an update, The F@#$king thing is STILL running ChkDsk too! It's only at about 90% complete with Stage 4 of 5.

    IYO, if it ever DOES finish, should I reboot it & then run defrag on it again? or that pointless now?

Similar Topics

Add your comment to this article

You need to be a member to leave a comment. Join thousands of tech enthusiasts and participate.
TechSpot Account You may also...