I'm all for updating the comparison in 1 or 2 years (on both the console and PC sides, because both will have changed), but what's wrong with comparing what exists today?
People seem overly bent out of shape in that thread, perhaps because they're trying to defend an existing decision. I took it in the spirit intended -- if you already have a PC, how much of an upgrade does the PS5 potentially bring you, today? That obviously depends on the games you play and the way you configure them, but I see nothing wrong with the limited data presented. More titles under more configurations would be great next steps for those interested.
For those of us who have not yet found our current gen GPU upgrade, I also found the anti-marketing message calming. There was lots of argument over whether the match should be say a 1070 vs a 2070, but I didn't see anyone claiming it was a 3070. For many of us with decent gear from prior generations, we may not be missing out yet.
The reality is, buy it if you really need it
Example, I play very few games and none of them really requires the latest and greatest GPU. So the Series X and my old GTX970 are more than enough for me.
Another point, the fact that both the PS5 and Series X comes with SSD's and do take advantage of them, is a valid excuse for many to upgrade right away. In my case, I had a One X and the loading times on old games went up exponentially, which didnt really happen with just swapping the laptop drive that came with for a SSD.
The complaints on those comments are indeed valid, that video was simply to get likes and eyeballs, but it was flawed.
Then again, that dude has for a while now, posted many videos which paint AMD on a negative way, so take that as you wish.
Personally, I stopped following him.
Lastly, going back to my first sentence, buy what you need.
Unless you went for a 4k monitor or tv (which places you in a minority, according to the Steam survey) and the game you want doesnt run, then yes, go wild.
As far as I can tell, the only game right now that demands that much is Cyberpunk and thats assuming that nvidia marketing got you by the short hairs with the RT nonsense.
I call RT nonsense because the reality is, we are easily 2 generations away from having capable hardware that can run that crap at 4K and be reasonable priced (FU Nvidia for insulting us by asking 1500 for that stupid gpu)
For many of us with decent gear from prior generations, we may not be missing out yet.
Doesnt apply to you? then move on and enjoy what you have.