Facebook apologizes for saving your unpublished videos

Cal Jeffrey

Posts: 2,523   +574
Staff member

Last week, several users discovered Facebook had secretly kept videos they had recorded but never published to the platform. Shortly after releasing tools that allowed users to download their archived Facebook data, people began to discover videos they had never posted among their saved information.

The videos come from a time before the platform introduced Facebook Live. Back then you could post a video to a friend’s wall, and they could respond in kind — a sort of crude video messaging service.

To facilitate this users could allow Facebook access to their camera, record a video, and then post it directly to a friend's wall. If the video did not come out as desired, there was an option to delete it and start over. However, this “delete” function did not truly trash the recording. Instead, it was achieved to the server under the user’s profile.

"We discovered a bug that prevented draft videos from being deleted."

While the flubbed videos never appeared on the website, they were presumably accessible by any app that you granted access to your information. They may have even been publicly available with the right tools. New York Magazine outed Facebook’s saving of this information, and this week representatives have apologized and promised to delete the junk Flash-formatted videos.

“We investigated a report that some people were seeing their old draft videos when they accessed their information from our Download Your Information tool. We discovered a bug that prevented draft videos from being deleted. We are deleting them and apologize for the inconvenience. We appreciate New York Magazine for bringing the issue to our attention.”

As if that were not enough, users of the Facebook Android app have discovered detailed logs of calls and text messages sent to and from their phones. Facebook says the feature was “opt-in,” but whether the dialog asking for permission explicitly stated that this information was being collected is uncertain.

It appears the social media Goliath cannot find a way out from under the microscope. The Cambridge Analytica scandal seems to have opened a level of scrutiny as privacy is concerned that Facebook could not have anticipated.

Permalink to story.

 

Evernessince

Posts: 5,339   +5,813
This is as much of a fail by facebook as it is by android. Facebook is yet another app that's used android's lax security to mine a massive amount of user data.

If Google let's 3rd party apps collect this much data on it's users, how much information is their operating system collecting?

People may be outraged at Facebook right now but this carousel will just continue until data protection laws are put into place.
 

DaveBG

Posts: 509   +213
This is as much of a fail by facebook as it is by android. Facebook is yet another app that's used android's lax security to mine a massive amount of user data.

If Google let's 3rd party apps collect this much data on it's users, how much information is their operating system collecting?

People may be outraged at Facebook right now but this carousel will just continue until data protection laws are put into place.
That is why I use custom ROMs since my Galaxy S1. Recently I was shocked to see that people actually see adds on their phones these days??????????
 

Nobina

Posts: 2,624   +2,251
Im just wondering why all the publicity with Facebook?
Somehow people just now realised how invasive Facebook is and are losing their ****.

If Google let's 3rd party apps collect this much data on it's users, how much information is their operating system collecting?
Well Android doesn't need to collect much data. For that you have Google apps like Chrome, Maps, Gmail, YouTube and Drive. I'm sure most of Android devices have them and use them.
 

Theinsanegamer

Posts: 1,950   +2,342
Yes, a "bug". Just like the "bug" that let facebook access to your messages and phone calls.

Anyone who believes zucky here should be eligible for a darwin award.
 

jwdR1

Posts: 42   +29
Amazing how fast a feature becomes a 'bug'.

Also amazed how many are shocked and apalled at this. I dumped FB the second time they reset my privacy settings and havent been back.

Yea, I know, they still have my data archived even though I went through they're convoluted process to delete my account. :(
 

gusticles41

Posts: 503   +600
A bug goes unnoticed until discovered. I can't imagine all of the space used by these videos was going unnoticed.