The first thing I look in a graphics card comparative is not the best FPS or overclock capability, it's the NOISE at different work loads and sadly this article even had not mention to it. Next time I would like you test it, please.
If the ASUS card had a backplate (like most of their high end cards do), I would choose that over the Gigabyte. Too bad it doesn't.
@Steve Great review, but I have some suggestions about the graphs/charts. I like what you are trying to do with the charts and all, but the colors are kind of distracting. I would try to keep the charts as simple as possible, only highlighting the tested/highlighted ones. Toms Hardware has really nailed the charts in terms of color coding (TechSpot nails everything else better ). If you want to stick with color coding though, use TS colors as much as possible, it will make them look more slick.
My pleasure, check out your PMs!Thanks really appreciate the feedback... I tried a few versions of the graphs before I landed on the ones we went with. Can you send me a version of the "Benchmarks: Overclocking Performance" graphs that you think we should have gone with, I am very open to input here.
I am even keen to update the review with something better.
Thanks for the read. Authoritative and comprehensive as always.
Re: the noise. The sound of the cards is largely subjective. A decibel level doesn't tell much of a story. The pitch would, but even that is subjective. There are people on this very site who deem the HD 7990 and R9 290X in reference form to be "quiet", or at least unnoticeable. A sound meter will also penalize a card that has excessive coil whine which may not affect more than a percentage of cards, and a card that has been through a few reviewers hands and taken to the limits of its overclockability on a few occasions (such as Steve mentioned with the Asus DCII TOP card) might suffer more than most.
For those who simply must have a comparison:
I think the dual fan design was the main reason Sapphire went with a 3-fan Tri-X option for the second revision card This is the same cooler on the Toxic version - so, pretty similar to the card that Steve reviewedThe last one sounds like your regular vacuum cleaner...
Ramjet Assisted Deafness Every Owner NoticesNothing beats Radeon in the noise test