Scientists propose firing moon dust into space to solve climate crisis

midian182

Posts: 9,738   +121
Staff member
WTF?! In what sounds like the plot from a sci-fi movie, researchers have proposed a potential solution to the climate crisis: create a shield around the earth by blasting dust mined from the moon into space using a rail gun.

The wild concept was put forward by a group of astrophysicists in a study published Wednesday in PLOS Climate. Benjamin Bromley, Sameer Khan, and Scott Kenyon theorized that a solar shield could be created to deflect the sun's rays from Earth.

Coal and sea salt were considered as materials that could be used in the shield, helping to dim the sun by as much as 2%, or around six days of sunlight per year, thereby lowering the Earth's temperature. But lunar dust turned out to be the ideal candidate as it is just the right size and composition for efficiently scattering sunlight away from our planet, said Bromley.

Another advantage of moon dust is that it would take much less energy to launch it from the lunar surface compared to earth-based launches, though it would still require an estimated 22 billion pounds of dust to be mined and loaded into a ballistic device such as a rail gun and fired. This would need to be performed regularly to maintain the shield as the dust would slowly disperse. An abrupt halt in the cooling of the earth could caused "termination shock," in which the planet rapidly heats up, writes The Guardian.

"Once dust is released, its only impact is to shade Earth. It will not otherwise interact with our planet again," the team wrote.

Such a project would be a logistical nightmare and incredibly expensive, of course, and might also require a new space station being placed in the L1 Lagrange point, a position between Earth and the sun, to "redirect packets of dust on to orbits that could provide shade for as long as possible." This would act as "fine-tuned dimmer switch, leaving our planet untouched," said Bromley.

The proposal isn't the first time someone has suggested using a physical object in space to address global warming. A 1,250-mile glass shield, trillions of spacecraft sporting umbrella-like shields, blasting dust off an asteroid, a raft of thin-film silicon bubbles, and space mirrors are some of the other space-based suggestions. There was also the space shield in the magnificently awful Highlander 2.

Both the researchers behind the proposal and other scientists have warned that the main priority in addressing climate change is a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions.

"Nothing should distract us from reducing greenhouse gas emissions here on Earth," said Bromley. "Our strategy may just be a moonshot, but we should explore all possibilities, in case we need more time to do the work here at home."

Permalink to story.

 
"Scientists" you say? Yeah I am going to press X for doubt on that one: 10 to 1 says those scientists either didn't just say that as a solution, work directly for an oil company or one of their many think tanks, or likely both.

Just start build some railroads and use trains ok? Just using trains and really investing heavily on infrastructure to get everybody to stop using cars or planes all of the time for no good reason 90% of the time would already solve things 1000x faster but instead the only other news is how oil companies are pushing to increase their spending and production even more every year.
 
Or maybe just switch to hydrogen as our main fuel until battery tech becomes good enough to replace petroleum. Simpler and far more cost-effective, can utilize over 90% of current internal combustion engine parts and can be made quite safe.
 
Just using trains and really investing heavily on infrastructure to get everybody to stop using cars or planes all of the time for no good reason 90% of the time would already solve things 1000x faster
It's truly amazing how little the climate zealots actually understand about what they preach. Globally, all CO2 emissions from transportation is only 22% of the total ... and much of that comes from commercial trucking, not "people using cars or planes all the time." Eliminate every car and jet on the planet overnight, and 85% of emissions still remain.

Or maybe just switch to hydrogen as our main fuel
Hydrogen isn't an energy source; it's an energy carrier. Currently, our only economical means of producing hydrogen comes from catalyzing it from natural gas.
 
Last edited:
It's truly amazing how little the climate zealots actually understand about what they preach. Globally, all CO2 emissions from transportation is only 22% of the total ... and much of that comes from commercial trucking, not "people using cars or planes all the time." Eliminate every car and jet on the planet overnight, and 85% of emissions still remain.
He did say "build more trains" in order to stop the reliance on inefficient trucking transport. But then again, Fossil fuel zealots would ignore that part.
 
He did say "build more trains" in order to stop the reliance on inefficient trucking transport. But then again, Fossil fuel zealots would ignore that part.
I'm surprised I have to spell this out, but you can't build a rail track and loading depot to every business in the world, and even if you could, you still have the nearly 80% of emissions remaining that have nothing to do with transportation whatsoever.

Sounds like a good way to reduce the population.
How do you believe dust orbiting in space would kill large numbers of people?
 
In the 70's the "environmentalist" said all of the smog/pollution was blocking sunlight, leading to a new ice age.
Now, they claim "global warming" and by blocking sunlight it will reduce global temperatures.
They start screwing around with something like this, it will lead to disaster.
 
Before the idea will be implemented, they should start building a cosmic vacuum cleaner too, kinda working in.... vacuum, for the moment it will be cold enough on Earth.
 
Instead of dealing with the root cause of our problems we're just going to throw dust at the problem. This is like when BP's big plan to plug the oil leak off the US coast was tp drop garbage onto it and hope for the best.
 
The Star Trek writers do more mathematical calculations than these "scientists". The total surface area of the Earth is 510 million km^2, let's assume that we are dealing with the same surface area even if we are several kilometers above the ground. To have enough shade to reverse the effect, we need at least 5% of that area to be covered 100% with dust - sand. That means we need to cover 25 million km^2 with dust-sand. That's more than the total area of the US and Europe combined. We don't have that much sand easily accessible from anywhere.

How much mass does this sand have? By rough estimates it has thousands times more mass than the total mass of all humans. It’s like we'd have to send everyone on Earth into space thousands of times.

And that's not counting the energy required to mine and move the sand, or the fact that the area above the surface is not just 510 million km^2, but much more. The radius of the earth is 6370 m and that gives a surface area of the sphere of 510 million km^2, when we go to geostationary orbit it is 35786 m above the earth, which is a sphere with a radius of 35786+6370= 42156 m. Which has a surface area of 2230 million km^2, which is more than 4 times the total surface area of the Earth...

So let's just admit that it's just a conjecture, impossible to be implemented with today's technology and energy.
 
I really think they have a chance to succeed ..... at fooling fools once again "for their own good".

As seen recently during covid, ukraine and others, the strategy would be a colossal cost of trillions per year during as long as possible until the next solution to a created problem.
 
Myself sitting on the debate side lines, can models effectively predict or model clouds or ocean circulation and their effect on on temps. No? I’ll just go back to the side lines then.
 
Are our lives one big experiment to these cronies? Yes, yes they are! Politicians are eager to control us and cronies are eager to sell them dust from the moon. Here is moon dust it will fix all your problems. This is what playing God looks like.
 
Back