The Netherlands has fined Apple five times over app store payments

Daniel Sims

Posts: 1,363   +43
Staff
Why it matters: Since last year, regulators in different countries have tried to stop Apple from forcing all app payments through the App Store. Over the past month, the Netherlands has taken perhaps the furthest steps in reigning in the tech titan through weekly fines. It remains to be seen if the financial hits even register for Apple.

This week the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) fined Apple 5 million euros (almost $5.7 million) for continuing to effectively block apps from using third-party payment methods. It is the fifth €5 million fine in as many weeks, bringing the total so far to 25 million (around $28 million).

Last year, the Dutch antitrust regulator ordered Apple to let the country's dating apps use alternate payment methods, ultimately setting the deadline for the middle of last month. Apple technically complied but required app operators to release entirely new apps to use new payment methods. Apple would also still take a 27 percent cut from payments through non-Apple systems on the apps instead of the usual 30.

The ACM determined this put an unreasonable burden on developers. In response, the ACM has fined Apple 5 million euros a week every week since mid-January. The maximum fine it can levy is €50 million.

Last August, South Korea became the first country to pass a law forcing Apple (and Google) to allow third-party app payments. After a September ruling on Epic’s case against Apple in the US, the Cupertino giant can no longer stop developers from linking to external payment methods.

The US District Court said Apple’s control of its App Store doesn’t represent a monopoly—yet. The Netherlands agreed in that respect but did charge Apple with abusing a dominant market position.

Permalink to story.

 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"
 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"


But how do the 3 seashells work?
 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"

You mean, the Demolition Man movie, not Dredd. (psycros beat me by 1 min)
 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"

Judge Dredd with Stalone was bad. The only entertaining aspect of that movie was Rob Schneider.

As already pointed out you're thinking about Demolition Man - which I think is a great movie.

Lenina Huxley : Okay. Let's go blow this guy.

John Spartan : [Annoyed] Away. Blow this guy *away*!

Lenina Huxley : Whatever.
 
Apple is doing everything they can to keep their steep 30% cut on app purchases?? Shocker!
 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"
Fyi in case three people haven’t told you yet, it was actually Demolition Man. You’re welcome!
 
If they want Apple to make the change, then just enforce it rather than slapping them with fines. What is 50 million to Apple? It just sounds like a quick way to top up the coffer of the nation after all the pandemic spending. The problem for Apple is that if they allow it in a country, chances of them defending themselves to prevent third party payment elsewhere is going to be weakened. Since they earn so much from the store, it is in their interest to try and stall this change for as long as they can. Unless every nation decided to impose hefty fine on them for the practice, these pockets of fines is not going to stop them.
 
You guys ever seen the Judge Dredd movie? The old one with Stalone when he starts cursing like a sailor just to get a ton of fines to be used as toiler paper?

That's kind of the situation we have with Apple and these "fines"

Everyone beat me to it - never seen the movie - but I read 2000AD comics . This just didn't seem right . Judge Dredd is the Law - plus he straighter than Eliot Ness . He will arrest his own mum if need be .
 
If they want Apple to make the change, then just enforce it rather than slapping them with fines. What is 50 million to Apple? It just sounds like a quick way to top up the coffer of the nation after all the pandemic spending. The problem for Apple is that if they allow it in a country, chances of them defending themselves to prevent third party payment elsewhere is going to be weakened. Since they earn so much from the store, it is in their interest to try and stall this change for as long as they can. Unless every nation decided to impose hefty fine on them for the practice, these pockets of fines is not going to stop them.
And HOW do they enforce it if not through fines? Arrest a bunch of local Apple employees?
 
Back