Reviewers Liked

  • Technically impressive
  • Visually striking
  • Combat is a good midpoint between AC's styles
  • New content, equipment, loot system, etc
  • Still a fantastic and entertaining core story
  • The beautiful and vibrant open world of the West Indies is still a blast

Reviewers Didn't Like

  • Feels archaic in many core design choices
  • Very much the original game with a new coat of paint
  • Minor control issues and quirks
  • Constantly nagging Animus stuff
  • Black Flag's intriguing modern day framing is ditched for a more confusing sci-fi foray against a controlling AI