Reviewers Liked

  • Meaningfully explores the Silent Hill lore
  • Stress and tension of avoiding and fighting monsters
  • Excellently captures the Scottish setting
  • Rewards multiple playthroughs
  • First-person switch is genius
  • Brilliant sound design

Reviewers Didn't Like

  • One obtuse puzzle that spoiled the flow
  • A Scottish main character would have been nice
  • Breakable weapons are always divisive
  • Enemy AI a bit too sensitive
  • Minor technical issues
  • Wearingly stealth heavy