Get the 3.5 inch, Also let me warn you and all those with external hard drives.
It's a fact and Ive done my research. External drives are not safe, nor a safe way to backup your stuff.
The way externals work, they eventually start losing data, or it wont let you access files. Eventually youll get burned. If I were you, Get a internal drive ,, which is different mechanism and will live 20 years maybe.
Ditch the external. Its better to have your second hard drive or whatever be internal ,,, your second disk will be backup, and once in a while you will burn your stuff on DVD , Which is a non movable device, unlike a spinning hard drive. Once on DVD that is the best backup you can do, and make sure to keep the discs safe in a case or something.
To further this thread, Another awesome way of backup or realiability is flash drives, since once again their not movable components, your data will remain safe forever, unless you drop it,, LOL ,, GL,,,,
The external will be the biggest headache for you so get a faster internal ,, GL,,,