HDR10+ Advanced and Dolby Vision 2 could redefine motion smoothing for TVs

Skye Jacobs

Posts: 1,914   +58
Staff
Forward-looking: HDR is evolving to address one of the most polarizing aspects of modern televisions: motion smoothing. Traditionally, this feature – formally known as motion interpolation – aims to eliminate judder in films and TV shows shot at 24 or 25 frames per second when viewed on 60Hz or 120Hz panels. But motion smoothing has earned a negative reputation for producing the so-called "soap opera effect" and introducing visual distortions. In response, two emerging HDR formats – HDR10+ Advanced and Dolby Vision 2 – are introducing new systems that attempt to make motion interpolation more precise and artist-aligned.

These standards are pitching a radical shift: rather than leaving motion processing solely in the hands of the TV's algorithms, content creators may be given explicit control over how and when motion smoothing is applied, tailoring the effect scene by scene.

Samsung has recently outlined the technical ambitions behind HDR10+ Advanced. It includes six new features, most notably "Intelligent FRC," or frame rate conversion. The principle behind FRC remains consistent: a TV examines incoming frames and estimates the appearance of frames at a higher refresh rate, then inserts synthetic frames to bridge the gap between the source and panel refresh rates.

For instance, a 24p film shown on a 60Hz TV would, with motion smoothing, have interpolated frames added to play more fluidly at 60p. This approach is divisive – some viewers perceive the result as more lifelike, but critics highlight the artificial sheen it adds to cinema.

What distinguishes HDR10+ Advanced's Intelligent FRC from conventional approaches is a built-in framework that allows filmmakers or mastering engineers to control when and how much smoothing occurs granularly. Reports indicate the system can dynamically adjust interpolation strength not only based on creative direction but also on ambient room lighting.

Dolby, the developer behind the rival Dolby Vision standard, is implementing a parallel concept. Dolby Vision 2 introduces "Authentic Motion," described as a scene-by-scene motion management system driven by creative input rather than automated TV settings alone.

Demonstrations of Authentic Motion have shown that it supports up to 10 levels of smoothing in real time, shifting between them within a single sequence. In a test using Amazon Prime Video's series "Paris Has Fallen," the system was observed ramping up the smoothing effect for fast pans and quickly dialing it back for static moments.

Despite these advances, it remains unclear whether either standard can fundamentally resolve core objections to motion smoothing. The technology's critics – who include high-profile filmmakers – argue that even when selectively applied, interpolation may not fully overcome the inherent uncanny visual quality, nor the visual artifacts such as halos or ghosting that can occur when a TV miscalculates the transition between two very different frames.

Neither HDR10+ Advanced nor Dolby Vision 2 has published metrics or demonstrated real-world results that directly address artifact suppression, and current previews are mainly limited to controlled simulations rather than consumer-ready products.

Adoption rates and industry support present additional hurdles. HDR10+ was introduced in 2017 and is now supported by hundreds of films and several major streaming platforms, while Dolby Vision, active since 2014, is available across nearly 1,000 movie titles.

However, the workload for content producers to master footage with per-scene motion metadata for these new features is unknown and could be significantly greater than in current HDR pipelines.

Samsung expects to launch HDR10+ Advanced on its 2026 models, with Prime Video set to offer support. Dolby Vision 2, meanwhile, is not yet scheduled for release.

Image credit: PC Magazine

Permalink to story:

 
Here's an idea, just give me a TV with a display port so I can do all this fancy stuff on my PC instead of relying on the TV to do all of it. I have seen some TVs coming into the market with a USBc port that doubles as a display port
 
"Soap Opera" effect is a made up nonsense. It's like saying - I don't want to use a modern phone, it got too many pixels, and I'm used to counting individual pixels on my phone.

I watch plenty of old movies at 4K@60fps, and they feel like they have found a new life, in a very positive way. I do not understand why somebody is moaning about "losing authenticity" when going over 24fps. It's just bull crap IMO.
 
I always disable this garbage. I want my TV to simply show the pixels its being sent. I don't need it to guess at what they would look like at 60hz. I don't want it to insert or drop frames. I want to see every frame at the normal frame rate.

Don't upscale the frames. Downscale the refresh rate. That 60/120/240hz box should be able to switch itself down to 24hz just fine.

I spend a LOT of time working with video.
 
Don’t understand why the TV can’t just adjust its refresh rate to whatever the source video is…

I feel this would be a heck of a lot easier…
 
Here's an idea, just give me a TV with a display port so I can do all this fancy stuff on my PC instead of relying on the TV to do all of it. I have seen some TVs coming into the market with a USBc port that doubles as a display port
They aren't going to do that because of the HDCP protections those streams have on them. If someone gets an unencrypted stream on a PC they can record that stream and content holders are not going to allow their content to be so easily pirated.

TVs do all the processing because they are a closed loop system, the only thing the consumer sees is what is on the screen that is as close as they come to the stream

You idea is interesting but might require a dedicated receiver/processor box be in the loop instead of a PC to adhere to the HDCP protection restrictions.
 
They aren't going to do that because of the HDCP protections those streams have on them. If someone gets an unencrypted stream on a PC they can record that stream and content holders are not going to allow their content to be so easily pirated.

TVs do all the processing because they are a closed loop system, the only thing the consumer sees is what is on the screen that is as close as they come to the stream

You idea is interesting but might require a dedicated receiver/processor box be in the loop instead of a PC to adhere to the HDCP protection restrictions.
So this has become a very grey area over the last 2 years. To no surprise or anyone, it's mostly China that is release lots of very large and very high end TVs with display port on them. Unless they are out right banned in the US, and they currently are now. You can buy these things and get HDR features over display port on a 4k 144/165hz TV. The problem is they are $20,000 and only on super large models from TCL or Hisense. HDMi limits those things, display port does not. So it I ran HDR over DP to one of these TVs, there will not be any limitation on my Linux HDCP signal being displayed on these TVs.
 
Sports are basically the only thing that benefit from it. Trying to watch a tv show from the 90's or like original 1977 star wars with motion garbage soap opera makes me want to vomit. That mode is only for Dr. Office waiting room TVs where they leave all the defaults. Please, just give me the option to turn it on or off. No more force features that someone thinks is better cause it's new. That's the point, if person A thinks it looks good, then turn it on, if person B thinks it looks bad, give me the option to turn it off. Anyways, I hope this new tech can help resolve it. Reminds me of early days of DLSS, pure blurry crap, now it looks WAY better and actually serves a purpose.
 
So this has become a very grey area over the last 2 years. To no surprise or anyone, it's mostly China that is release lots of very large and very high end TVs with display port on them. Unless they are out right banned in the US, and they currently are now. You can buy these things and get HDR features over display port on a 4k 144/165hz TV. The problem is they are $20,000 and only on super large models from TCL or Hisense. HDMi limits those things, display port does not. So it I ran HDR over DP to one of these TVs, there will not be any limitation on my Linux HDCP signal being displayed on these TVs.
Let me know how that works out for you.
 
"Soap Opera" effect is a made up nonsense. It's like saying - I don't want to use a modern phone, it got too many pixels, and I'm used to counting individual pixels on my phone.

I watch plenty of old movies at 4K@60fps, and they feel like they have found a new life, in a very positive way. I do not understand why somebody is moaning about "losing authenticity" when going over 24fps. It's just bull crap IMO.
It looks like trash. Sorry.
 
Back