Starlink is offering half-price internet near xAI data centers, but critics want the pollution fixed

Skye Jacobs

Posts: 2,162   +62
Staff
The takeaway: SpaceXAI is offering half-price Starlink service to people living near its Memphis data centers, while the company continues to face criticism over the generators used to power its AI operations. The promotion could lower connectivity costs for households without reliable fiber access, but it offers limited practical advantage where affordable high-speed cable or fiber service is already available.

With roughly 2,000 reported subscribers since the offer was announced in July, compared with more than 250,000 households across Memphis, the discount appears unlikely to ease broader concerns about the company's unpermitted power generation and its environmental impact.

The deal applies to residents of Memphis and Southaven, Mississippi. SpaceXAI is also waiving the upfront rental fee for Starlink's new V5 hardware kit, which can otherwise cost up to $349. In a post on X, SpaceXAI Memphis said thousands of people had signed up.

The discount cuts the price of Starlink's entry-level residential plan from $55 a month to $27.50. Its 200 Mbps plan falls from $85 to $42.50, and the Max plan drops from $130 to $65.

For some households, the deal could be useful. Residents in parts of Memphis and Southaven still lack fiber service, and some commenters in the r/memphis subreddit said the discounted satellite service could fill that gap. Others said it could serve as a backup connection for people who work from home or need internet service that is less dependent on local cable infrastructure.

The offer may be less appealing to households that already have access to fiber. AT&T and Xfinity plans often start at about $35 to $40 a month and can provide speeds of up to 300 Mbps. Starlink's lower price may help customers watching their bills, but its 100 Mbps entry plan would not necessarily be faster than an available fiber connection.

SpaceXAI is running the same Starlink promotion in Vermilion Parish, Louisiana, where SpaceX plans to build a $100 billion spaceport.

The timing has drawn attention because SpaceXAI's Memphis data-center operations remain under scrutiny over their power supply. The company has been criticized for installing turbines without permits to support the facilities' growing electricity needs.

SpaceX Is Offering Half-Off Starlink Residential Internet Service In The Memphis Area~~~Since we are all discussing cable and internet extremely high costs~~~May I ask if anyone is well versed in Xfinity's high speed internet vs Starlink? Pros & Cons? Please no politics or hate.
by u/Southernms in memphis

The Southern Environmental Law Center said the Starlink discount does not address residents' complaints about pollution. "Communities in Memphis and North Mississippi aren't asking for discounted internet service," SELC Senior Attorney Amanda Garcia told PCMag. "They're asking xAI to shut down its illegal, unpermitted power plant that continues to pump out staggering amounts of harmful pollution, including smog-forming nitrogen oxides, fine particulate matter, and hazardous chemicals like formaldehyde."

SpaceXAI has said it will remove all 69 unpermitted generators. However, the company expects the process to take about a year as it brings a 1.2-gigawatt power plant online. The new plant is intended to replace the temporary generation used to keep the data centers running.

The company's claim of 2,000 local subscribers is notable, but Memphis has more than 600,000 residents and more than 250,000 households, based on the census figures cited in the provided material. That means the promotion has attracted subscriptions from fewer than 1% of households in the city.

Permalink to story:

 
Starlink kinda sucks simply because you can't get around the latency issue. I have starlink because my job requires that I have Internet in remote places and starlink is better than not having Internet. But it actually sucks for anything other than checking email.or streaming. Know what gaming I do on starlink? I download single player games. I am thrilled to be able to do that, but I cant meaningfully play EvE or ESO on it.

Yes I use my companies starlink plan to stream and game on and if you think that's bad then you can send someone else to the middle of nowhere for weeks or months at a time.
 
Yes I use my companies starlink plan to stream and game on and if you think that's bad then you can send someone else to the middle of nowhere for weeks or months at a time.
Oh you're such a martyr. Thank you for going on random message boards and comments sections to raise awareness about your sacrifices. We really care. *roll eyes*
 
Oh you're such a martyr. Thank you for going on random message boards and comments sections to raise awareness about your sacrifices. We really care. *roll eyes*
We had a meeting about it recently and to sum it up "if you don't want to give people access to Internet then you aren't going to have people working in the middle of nowhere. If you want to send us to somewhere with no cell service you're going to have a difficult time staffing that job site if we don't have wifi.

I've also had an ongoing battle with starlink over the last 2 years and frankly, it actually does suck. It's better than no Internet but that's about it.
 
Interesting to see how quickly SpaceX is moving from (perceived) Good Guys to Bad Company.
Makes me wonder how long they'll last. Fck Around and Find Out is a very real phenomenon.

Semi-offtopic: I live in Amsterdam and recently got a fiber connection.
Before that happened I spent many years on cable Internet - while the 1Gbit up 100Mbit down connection was superduper reliable the ISP abused their monopoly by charging 65 euros/month.
My fresh fiber connection's 1Gbit up and down (the real number's about 1080-1090 Mbit) and costs me 12 (twelve!) euros/month. Noticeably better latency to boot.
High population density can be a good thing.
 
Interesting to see how quickly SpaceX is moving from (perceived) Good Guys to Bad Company.
Makes me wonder how long they'll last. Fck Around and Find Out is a very real phenomenon.

Semi-offtopic: I live in Amsterdam and recently got a fiber connection.
Before that happened I spent many years on cable Internet - while the 1Gbit up 100Mbit down connection was superduper reliable the ISP abused their monopoly by charging 65 euros/month.
My fresh fiber connection's 1Gbit up and down (the real number's about 1080-1090 Mbit) and costs me 12 (twelve!) euros/month. Noticeably better latency to boot.
High population density can be a good thing.
Lucky. The monopoly here costs me $140 for 1000/50
 
Back