Tesla knew some of its headlights were twice as bright as legally allowed, now it's recalling 20,000 vehicles

midian182

Posts: 11,935   +183
Staff member
What just happened? If you've ever been dazzled by the headlights of some Tesla vehicles and wondered why they're so bright, here's the reason: The EV giant is recalling over 20,000 vehicles with low-beam headlights exceeding the maximum legal limit – in some cases, the lights were twice as bright as allowed. It's an issue that Tesla has been aware of since spring 2024, but it's only doing something about it now.

The affected vehicles consists of 1,614 Model 3 sedans built between July 24, 2017, and December 2, 2023, and 18,735 Model Y crossovers manufactured between February 11, 2020, and December 24, 2023.

The NHTSA recall report notes that low-beam output exceeding the maximum permitted intensity may reduce visibility for the driver and other road users, increasing the risk of a crash.

As Electrek explains, the problem involves certain headlights supplied by Marelli Automotive Lighting. Measurements found that light output in the upper corners of the low-beam pattern exceeded limits imposed by Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 108. Some produced more than double the maximum intensity.

Tesla discovered the issue in March 2024 while preparing a separate Canadian recall. However, it argued that the noncompliance was inconsequential to safety and petitioned NHTSA to let it avoid notifying owners or providing a remedy.

The automaker said it was unaware of any complaints, crashes, or injuries linked to the headlights. The NHTSA, however, disagreed, warning that the excess light could cause glare, particularly during rain, fog, or snow. The agency denied Tesla's petition last month, leading to the recall.

Unlike many Tesla recalls, it's unlikely that this one could be addressed through a quick over-the-air software update. The company says a remedy is still under development. Owner notification letters are expected to be mailed in phases beginning September 15.

Tesla says compliant headlights from another supplier entered Model 3 production in July 2020. Model Y production adopted replacement units in December 2022 at Fremont and August 2023 at Austin. Some later vehicles are included because they received affected lamps during servicing.

Tesla is no stranger to recalls, of course. Last year, it recalled more than 46,000 Cybertrucks over exterior panels that could detach while driving. The Cybertruck had already accumulated eight recalls since deliveries began, covering problems including stuck accelerator pedals and faulty electric inverters. But that hasn't stopped NASA from using the EV to help astronauts escape if something goes wrong during a rocket launch.

Permalink to story:

 
Oh, so now they care about headlights being "too bright"?

Also, why wouldn't this just be another software update? Of all the things that are controlled electronically, one would think the headlights are just a quick settings to lower brightness...
 
Oh, so now they care about headlights being "too bright"?

Also, why wouldn't this just be another software update? Of all the things that are controlled electronically, one would think the headlights are just a quick settings to lower brightness...
They always cared about too bright, because, obviously, you blind the other drivers.

Everyone knows this, except Tesla zealots that love every bit of fart Musk pumps out of himself.
 
Typical of Tesla and fElon (and other lovely American automakers): It's not a problem until NHSTA twists our arms and tells us it is.
 
Typical of Tesla and fElon (and other lovely American automakers): It's not a problem until NHSTA twists our arms and tells us it is.
I agree. It represents 0.2% of their vehicles produced. That said, it is not the entire headlight but only the "upper corner". Also, Tesla was the one who initiated the recall (although they didn't discover the issue), but NHTSA expanded it to all vehicles with those headlights. It's really a nonissue for Tesla to fix. And those lucky few Model 3 and Y owners will get a part replaced for free for them.
 
I use to think those halogen headlights were bright until those #@$% LED headlights came along.
Especially on those huge pickup trucks or "raised" vehicles. It's like a flipping sun gun shining into your front window, or when they are behind you, your rearview mirror. I swear you could hold your hand up in front of your face and see the bones in your fingers! :cool:
 
As someone who's had bullet fragments and later a piece of wire extracted from the same eye (with sanding required to remove rust 'cause it had been there for a day or three), followed by sun-damaged vision requiring cataract surgery for both eyes, I'll say this:

LED headlights are non-blinding IF the light has been properly installed and aligned. Yes, headlights require alignment, just like wheels. The issue arises - mostly - from those who have replaced factory headlights with after-market "upgrades", and done so without checking post-install alignment. The "cool" factor overrides spending money for proper installation.

Find two vehicles, one with LED and one without. On level ground, at night, look in your rearview and see if there's a difference. Even the big trucks, if properly aimed, aren't really an issue. Factory-installed LED Projector-headlights are focused. Though it does help to have Day-Night mirrors, expecially for those who don't grasp the difference between low and high beam ...
 
Last edited:
Why is TechSpot writing about headlights? This has nothing to do with technology. It’s just electronics lol.
I agree, it appears Techspot is joining the likes of ArsTechnica and jumping on the Musk/Trump hate train and publishing any article that involves them.
 
I use to think those halogen headlights were bright until those #@$% LED headlights came along.
Especially on those huge pickup trucks or "raised" vehicles. It's like a flipping sun gun shining into your front window, or when they are behind you, your rearview mirror. I swear you could hold your hand up in front of your face and see the bones in your fingers! :cool:

All the headlights are too bright if you look directly at them. They should be pointed down and to the right but most people don't know how to adjust them. Also, on older cars with no projector lenses, people got the LED aftermarket lights that were much brighter. These are the blinding headlights that you see on the roads. It doesn't come from a manufacturer like that.

This recall is for the older pre-matrix headlights. On my Tesla MYP, the matrix headlights are great. The headlights and high beams turn on automatically and they selectively turn off just the parts they need to turn off so they don't blind other cars.
 
Back