That time when a Waymo robotaxi drove off with a passenger's luggage after the trunk failed to unlock at the airport

Skye Jacobs

Posts: 2,010   +58
Staff
Facepalm: Even with advanced autonomous vehicles, a small failure at the end of a ride can cause real problems. That's what happened to Di Jin, a Bay Area businessman whose Waymo trip to San Jose Mineta International Airport ended with the car driving off while his suitcase was still locked in the trunk. The issue surfaced only after the vehicle reached the terminal, when Jin attempted to retrieve his belongings.

"I pressed the trunk open button, tried to get my luggage, but it doesn't do anything, and it drives away immediately," Jin told NBC.

Waymo's robotaxis rely on a tightly integrated system of sensors, software controls, and passenger interfaces. Riders can access the trunk through the Waymo app, the vehicle's in-car display, or a physical button on the trunk itself. However, the incident appears to have stemmed from the vehicle transitioning out of the active ride state and departing before the passenger retrieved his luggage. In Jin's case, that transition appears to have completed before the trunk opened, effectively ending the interaction and sending the vehicle on its next task.

Once the car left the airport, recovering the luggage became complicated. Without a driver to handle lost items, Jin had to deal with the company directly. He contacted Waymo customer support but was told the vehicle had already been routed back to a depot and could not return.

Jin wound up boarding his flight without any of his belongings. "So I have no luggage, no clothes to change, and all my work notes are in my luggage," he said.

Later that day, Waymo confirmed via email that the suitcase had been located at one of its facilities. But the company's response showed the limits of a driverless service. Without a human driver responsible for lost items, the process shifts to centralized handling, leaving customers to navigate retrieval logistics themselves.

"While we would love to get this item back to you as quickly as possible, Waymo is unable to cover the cost of shipping labels or courier fees," a support team representative wrote.

Instead, Jin was offered two complimentary rides to pick up the luggage in person. He said that would require more than 2 hours of travel, making it impractical compared to simply having the item returned. "It sounds terrible," Jin said. "It doesn't make any sense at all, because it's not my mistake."

The incident points to a gap in how these systems handle the end of a trip, especially when something goes wrong. Much of the focus in self-driving technology has been on navigation, safety, and real-time decision-making on the road. Those systems have advanced rapidly, but edge cases – like what happens during passenger drop-off – depend on smaller interactions between software controls and user behavior, where failures are less visible but still disruptive.

In this instance, the issue wasn't how the vehicle drove, but how it handled the final seconds of the ride. A missed or delayed command was enough to trigger a chain of events that the system wasn't designed to easily correct.

For companies operating robotaxi fleets, incidents like this highlight a different kind of challenge. The technology may be capable of navigating urban environments, but reliability also depends on how well the system manages routine human interactions – especially those that occur just before a passenger walks away.

Update (May 6): Waymo contacted TechSpot to clarify that passengers can access vehicle trunks through the Waymo app, the in-car display, or a physical trunk button. The company also said it waived the rider's luggage shipping fee after the incident. The story has been updated to reflect these.

Permalink to story:

 
Tech is in its infancy... and it will be superior to humanity fairly soon... how many stories of "taxi driver drove off with my luggage" or "taxi driver drove me to the wrong destination" or "taxi driver assaulted me" have you heard? They're not popular in the media, but they happen FAR more often than an "AI driving off with your luggage".

The reason: we can FIX the AI. By next year (probably next week), this bug will be ironed out... humanity (and human nature), on the other hand, will remain the same.
 
A human driver would have accountability for driving off with someones luggage.
But when these companies replace people with AI the company can just blame it on a "bug" despite that AI was supposed to make everything better, easier, and cheaper.
There is plenty of accountability for an AI… we see it in the media all the time. I’d argue that there is far LESS accountability when a human makes a mistake. If you get a “bad” human driver, what recourse do you get other than to complain?

When an AI makes a mistake, it makes the news (hence this article) and gets addressed fairly quickly.
 
"....but was told the vehicle had already been routed back to a depot and could not return."

Amazing. Was the AI in that car taking a well deserved nap and couldn't return with the luggage to the airport?? Is Waymo so stupid they can't install a sensor to ensure that no luggage was left in the trunk??

"While we would love to get this item back to you as quickly as possible, Waymo is unable to cover the cost of shipping labels or courier fees," a support team representative wrote."

Are they broke or something?? Imagine if a company with human employees said something to that effect!

You can bet that a human driver would have been called by dispatch and told to return to airport with luggage before the flight had left. Problem solved. But the AI overlords, which are supposed to make things "better", can't??
Better, for whom?? Turns out it is not the consumer!

And what's even more amazing are some people here always finding an excuse for a company, AI or whatever, ready to defend, no matter what those companies do!

Poor Big Biz, has no friends to defend them except here. What a noble endeavor.
 
It's not just robo taxis. I once picked up one of my sons from university. He came out of the train station carrying a large backpack, opened the car and appeared to sit down behind me. I drove off telling him about everything that had happened while he'd been away. He was unusually quiet but I figured maybe he was just tired from the train ride. At the traffic lights I turned round to talk to him and found it was just his backpack in the car. I looked in the mirror and could see him in the distance running at full pelt down the road towards the traffic lights.

Fortunately he could see the funny side.
 
There is plenty of accountability for an AI… we see it in the media all the time. I’d argue that there is far LESS accountability when a human makes a mistake. If you get a “bad” human driver, what recourse do you get other than to complain?

When an AI makes a mistake, it makes the news (hence this article) and gets addressed fairly quickly.
A human driver would've turned around right away, or would've returned the luggage sooner after getting a call from the taxi company. As the article states, the passenger had to go through support themselves and wait until later that day for the company to find their luggage.
Only after articles like this the company has to have accountability for themselves, though I have yet to see AI companies having any accountability for rising electricity costs for residents in the area where datacenters are built.
 
A human driver would've turned around right away, or would've returned the luggage sooner after getting a call from the taxi company. As the article states, the passenger had to go through support themselves and wait until later that day for the company to find their luggage.
Only after articles like this the company has to have accountability for themselves, though I have yet to see AI companies having any accountability for rising electricity costs for residents in the area where datacenters are built.
Yeah… no… SOME humans might have turned around… others might have continued their routes and forgotten about it until quitting time - and if the passenger was lucky, they’d get their bag back in a few days…

Have you ever been on an airplane and lost your luggage before? I have… no AIs involved… and it happens so often that it never makes the news… last time it happened to me, my luggage took a nice tour of Denmark and Sweden before joining me in Toronto a week later… and my flight was from Italy…
 
I really hope they have the correct controls in place before an incident occurs where the vehicle drives off with someone's baby left inside.

Maybe add a "Ride Finished" button to the vehicle or app, that way it gives some control to the occupant of the vehicle to indicate when they are satisfied they have all their belongings. It would also give the company a chance to intervene if needed before the vehicle leaves.
 
Last edited:
I'm not going to say AI is better than a human driver. I'm also not going to say a human driver would be better than AI. What I am going to say, is that they should have shipped your luggage to you, free of charge, for their error. This is the kind of thing that makes us hate companies like Amazon, Google and Walmart.
 
Back