Think CAPTCHAs are frustrating? Try this new Doom version

midian182

Posts: 11,693   +177
Staff member
In brief: Being faced with a CAPTCHA is about as welcome as opening a Christmas present and finding it's a Humane Ai Pin. But a new variant offers a little more fun than clicking on boxes of specific items, though it's about 10 times more difficult: kill three demons on a secret level of Doom.

Completely Automated Public Turing tests to tell Computers and Humans Apart have been frustrating internet users for years. Preventing the likes of account-creating bots, spam, data-scaping, etc., is important, but it's hard to remember that fact when squinting at a squiggled word on the screen, or faced with the dilemma of whether that tiny bit of bicycle handle peeking into a square means you should select it.

There are fewer anger-inducing CAPTCHAs these days, such as dragging items to locations and listening to audio clips – we also saw a Doom minigame in 2021. Now, there's a new CAPTCHA version of the iconic FPS, which you can try out here. The idea is to kill at least three demons. Good luck with that – it took me a lot of attempts before I managed it.

As reported by TechCrunch, the latest Doom CAPTCHA is the work of Guillermo Rauch, CEO of Vercel, a frontend-as-a-service product. He used his company's AI site builder to create the program.

While it's a fun twist on classic CAPTCHAs, it shouldn't come as a surprise to learn that people have been complaining about the Doom variant's difficulty.

The reason why it's so hard is explained by commenter smitelli on Hacker News: this is actually the secret E1M9: Military Base level that players would normally encounter after E1M3. By this point in the game, you would have a shotgun, chaingun, rocket launcher, and probably some armor. So, starting with just a pistol and no protection means this is going to be a challenge, especially as the difficulty level is set to Nightmare.

There are also questions over just how well this program will work as a CAPTCHA, given that AI bots can be trained to play games like Doom. Still, it's better than clicking on traffic lights.

Permalink to story:

 
I just tried it and actually, it's not too bad. Since it requires any monster and not just demons, you can bait out the Zombiemen by shooting the pistol once or twice and they come looking for you, a veritable shooting fish in a barrel.

That being said, I kind of wish it didn't cut off after 3 kills and let you keep going if you like. XD
 
Captchas are annoying because web sites are pushing their problem of bots onto the user. It shouldn't be the user's problem.
 
Back