AI music company claims copyright over musician's own recording, gets her YouTube video removed

midian182

Posts: 12,071   +184
Staff member
WTF?! There are worse things AI can do to music streaming services than fill them with slop tracks. Take, for example, the recent case of an AI content company founded last year that claimed ownership of a musician's own five-year-old recording.

As reported by 404 Media, writer and musician Samantha Shokin recorded a 50-second version of Bulgarian folk song Bre Petrunko during the pandemic, initially uploading it to SoundCloud before posting it on YouTube. The track didn't attract much attention at first, but it had reached around 125,000 views after four years.

Last summer, after noticing an increase in comments on the video, Shokin discovered that DJs were sampling her voice and using it in dozens of songs.

"The first thing that comes to mind is, 'Oh my god, someone stole my voice and didn't credit me,'" she said.

Shokin later realized that the DJs had purchased a pack of samples from a company called Loopmasters, and her track was part of its "Folk Legends" set.

After she contacted the distributor, it apologized, assured her it was unaware of what had happened, and arranged royalties.

"I didn't love the way that it came about, but whatever, they tried to make right of the situation," she said.

Then, in October, her original YouTube video disappeared following a copyright complaint from a company called Media Nov Records. Shokin filed two counter-notifications, arguing that the video should stay up or not be demonetized, but they failed, and her attempts to contact the company went unanswered.

Media Nov Records is described as a "distribution company" that helps artists get their tracks onto digital platforms, but 404 Media notes that a lot of its website is focused on management and copyright protection.

"Our comprehensive rights management system leverages cutting-edge technology and legal expertise to ensure you receive the royalties you deserve," it reads. There's also mention of automated DMCA takedowns, YouTube content ID management, and AI-powered content recognition.

Media Nov told 404 Media it operates 500 channels. The outlet found AI imagery and repetitive electronic music across those it examined. Corporate records placed the company's founding last year, despite its website claiming roots in 1996.

Media Nov responded after 404 Media contacted it, initially saying it would investigate the claim and correct any error. It then contacted Shokin, requesting original audio files, recording evidence, publication dates, and other documentation proving ownership. The company blamed its failure to answer earlier messages from Shokin and Loopmasters on its spam folder.

It also brought Bulgarian composer Philip Koutev into the dispute. "Regarding 'Bre Petrunko,' we would like to clarify that the musical composition and arrangement rights associated with Philip Koutev's work must be distinguished from the rights in any individual sound recording. Media Nov Records also holds certain rights relating to the relevant musical content," the company told Shokin in an email.

Koutev popularized an arrangement of the traditional folk song in 1963. However, Media Nov did not answer when 404 Media asked which work in its catalog had triggered the complaint against Shokin.

Minutes after requesting proof of ownership, Media Nov emailed both Shokin and the publication to withdraw its removal request. Its bizarre explanation was that the video had "not generated revenue or received views," despite having accumulated around 125,000 views.

The company nevertheless maintained that it was not surrendering any rights, adding: "We intend to initiate appropriate legal proceedings regarding the underlying copyright dispute."

Around 24 hours later, Shokin's video returned. YouTube confirmed it had restored the recording because the claimant withdrew its complaint.

"It's ironic that they're in the copyright business," Shokin said. "It's not the arrangement that's in question. It's the voice and performance [...] they clearly have no clue what they're talking about."

AI music has already brought plenty of problems beyond questionable copyright claims. Platforms are being overwhelmed with fully AI-generated tracks, many of which are fraudulent. Australia is banning them from the charts, and despite Spotify deleting millions of these tracks, it is introducing an AI remixing tool for users next year.

Permalink to story:

 
YouTube is so incredibly mismanaged.. I've seen:
- Enderman (350k subscribers) randomly getting linked to an unrelated banned account and thus banning his - nothing was done until Twitter outrage (contacting YouTube themselves is useless)
- Davie504 get copyright struck over the sound of silence, by literally playing... silence.
- Videos get banned for the AI mishearing a word and mistaking it for something else
- People frequently get demonetized for 'harmful content' for utterly harmless things, or simply reacting to other content that can be monetized (rules for thee, but not for me)
- Several creators abusing the rights system to get videos taken down for 'unfair' use because they did not agree with the content of the video of another creator (even though it was clearly fair use)
- People get their income stolen because someone else claims to have the rights on it, by the time it's undone (if it is) - the money is gone.

Those last two literally have whole industries built around them.
The bots with an 'interesting' avatar stealing an upvoted comment and then bot upvote spamming their own until it takes over have been a problem for ages as well.

There's also several huge creators (LTT for example) that have indicated that their YouTube contact often gives an answer that they can't do much about how things are done because the AI runs things and that's just how it goes.

As much as I use YouTube still (with adblock, because holy heck it's unusable without and their behavior does not make me want to reward them with paying for premium)... boy, do I miss the old days when humans ran the thing. Less ads, better content, better content suggestions* and creators could actually contact humans to get things changed.

*I randomly watch Fox News and MSNBC just to confuse algorithm in an attempt to get news that covers both sides of the story (although to be fair I get most of it from TLDR/DW News/France 24 and some independent creators.
Music it randomly sometimes suggest an absolute gem but have to wade through AI slop whilst using "Don't recommend this channel anymore" an awful lot.

Creators seem to getting increasingly tired of the system as well, like Jill Bearup
 
Last edited:
The copyright industry in general is a horrible leech on creativity. Things that were okay for hundreds of years are no longer okay because of the copyright industry and it's very confusing for people who are trying to make music. For example I released an album of electronic music in 2019 that had a remix on it of a very old song called Popcorn which was the original techno song. I did this because I wanted to honor the original techno song. However, recently the entire album was pulled because the song is an interpolation of an old song by Gershwin Kingsley. Apparently when you cover a song and make significant modifications to the melody it's considered an interpolation and you need to get permission before you can post that. So they pulled my entire album even though only one of the songs was a problem. I'm still trying to get it restored and I'm going back and forth with the rights holder to see if they will actually let me post it.

But the thing that annoys me the most is that there are hundreds of these kinds of remixes and covers on YouTube. For over 100 years people have taken old music and updated it to a new version with new instrumentation and slightly different melody and it has not been a problem until the "copyright industry" came around.

I feel like we need to revisit the idea of copyright and establish some boundaries. I'm really tired of artists claiming that people are plagiarizing their music based on a similar melody. I'm tired of the double standard about covering old music. Apparently if you're a rich, well-known musician you can do it, but if you're nobody, you can't.

After finding out that interpolations are a problem, I've had to scrap about 10 video game remixes I was working on. At least until I can get permission to post them. Extremely frustrating when I'm just trying to pay homage to things that influenced me growing up.
 
Anybody who listens to AI generated music out of choice should be sent on a rocket to Mars with Donald Trump and all his Tech Bro toadies.
Today's tools are good enough that most people wouldn't know they were listening to AI generated music. Often the only way to tell is to use an audio forensic tool that looks for the unique fingerprinting embedded in AI tracks by a lot of vendors. It is what Spotify is using to try to weed out AI generated music.
 
YT is an absolute MESS! The whole "copyrighted material" controls are absurd. Many times I've posted video only to have it blocked because it can hear just 5-10 seconds of a part of a song way off in the background from a radio playing.
 
Back