Amazon warns New Yorkers of up to $5 delivery price hikes if labor bill becomes law

midian182

Posts: 12,080   +184
Staff member
Winners & losers: Amazon is fighting back against a New York City labor bill that would force companies to directly employ their delivery personnel rather than outsourcing jobs to third-party contractors. The tech giant is warning customers via pop-ups that if it becomes law, they could face increased delivery costs of up to five dollars per order.

The Delivery Protection Act, also known as Intro 518, would change whose name appears on an Amazon driver's paycheck. Today, the person who drops off your package might wear an Amazon vest, drive an Amazon van, and even have one of Amazon's AI-powered cameras watching how they drive. Their employer, however, is often one of the small businesses Amazon calls Delivery Service Partners.

Under the New York bill, if Amazon wants to keep running its delivery stations in the five boroughs, it would have to put the drivers who regularly deliver packages from those stations on its own payroll. That includes part-timers who do more than eight hours of delivery work in any 30-day period. The rule would also cover workers who sort packages at the stations.

There's a provision for the drivers already doing those jobs. If Amazon ends a delivery contract to comply with the law and its partner lays off the drivers as a result, it would have to offer those drivers their old jobs as Amazon employees before it could hire anyone else to do the work. The terms of those offers would have to be at least as good as the ones the drivers had before.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani backs the bill, arguing that subcontracting lets Amazon sidestep responsibility for what happens to the people delivering its packages. Amazon says the legislation threatens more than 40 delivery businesses it works with in the city and the livelihoods of their 5,000-plus employees. It says it would consider moving its delivery stations outside the city, which could leave New Yorkers paying more and waiting longer for packages.

Amazon is now making that arguement on its app and website alongside the Black Friday deals. An "Act now" button takes shoppers to a prewritten message urging their council member to oppose the bill. As for where Amazon got the $5 figure, its message doesn't explain the math, and the bill itself contains no per-order charge.

Council Speaker Julie Menin had a message of her own for the company. "If Amazon thinks this deceptive campaign will effectively threaten New Yorkers and intimidate this City Council, they are dead wrong," she said.

Permalink to story:

 
That's fearmongering if I ever heard it.
How much does a third party outsourced person vs actual employee make, what's the cost difference? I'd be surprised if it's more than $5 a hour to begin with.
Presumably they make more deliveries than one a hour, especially in a highly populated city... "Up to" is doing some heavy lifting there.

Don't know the specifics of this*, but usually when Amazon opposes something relating to workers it means it's the right thing to do.
*I'd look into it... but don't care enough and when New York City is involved chances of making sense of it are pretty low - although at least they moved on to using trash bins to reduce the rat problem (the year is 2026).
 
Sorry that you're posting record profits, sucks bro. Be nice if you stopped spying on us and selling our information while treating your "contractors" like ****. I can say when stuff gets dropped off at my house, the vam doesn't say "contractor".

I have around 90 guys under me and I fight tooth and nail CONSTANTLY for them. They don't see them as people, they see them as numbers on a spreadsheet. I can tell you first hand that those numbers change ALOT when those guys don't show up.

I'm in a different industry and Amazon has inched and clawed their way to whatever it is they're doing, but they have the highest turn over rate in the industry. They're going to run out of works someday. It's important to note that those people aren't just numbers on a spreadsheet that you can "manage" your way to a promotion.

Ask me what happened on the sanitation build when they said "no more overtime" I dare you
 
Last edited:
There is a really interesting read on the nurses 'uber'. AI system reads all the nurses data, including the financials, and when a hospital requires cover on a shift, system is offering less money to the nurses which have less savings. The idea is, people with everything to lose and struggling will accept a crap payment because they need to cover bills and just survive. Nurses who has money are getting better offers, because they simply are in position to choose. So, great way to ensure poor one gets poorer and actually being treated as slaves.
If amazon says delivery cost will grow up by 5 usd by delivery, can you imagine how badly they squeeze their contractor drivers? Those guys are probably peeing in the bottles to actually get earn something to survive. Market does not self regulate. People on edge of surviving have no choice. And new technology removes those choices even further. Seeing those regulations there it seems like at least someone tries to change this madness, and not pretending all is good while level of life falling down to 3rd countries standards.
 
There is a really interesting read on the nurses 'uber'. AI system reads all the nurses data, including the financials, and when a hospital requires cover on a shift, system is offering less money to the nurses which have less savings. The idea is, people with everything to lose and struggling will accept a crap payment because they need to cover bills and just survive. Nurses who has money are getting better offers, because they simply are in position to choose. So, great way to ensure poor one gets poorer and actually being treated as slaves.

Thats seems illegal, besides how would they know the financial records of the people working there?
 
This is a TERRIBLE law. It's government central planning vs free market.

Beyond the total disregard for transaction cost economics, this snippet is particularly hilarious "That includes part-timers who do more than eight hours of delivery work in any 30-day period". Hey temp, I know you only worked one day, but now you are a full employee - here's benefit package, executive washroom key, and 65 hours of mandatory HR training videos...

If you really hate Amazon don't use them.

If you really want Amazon to pay their workers more, things on Amazon will get more expensive. It's math not greed.

In this case the expenses are only going up in NY so only those customers need to pay more. You know the customers that elected the people to try more socialism as a solution. This is how it works.
 
Last edited:
This is a TERRIBLE law. It's government central planning vs free market.

Beyond the total disregard for transaction cost economics, this snippet is particularly hilarious "That includes part-timers who do more than eight hours of delivery work in any 30-day period". Hey temp, I know you only worked one day, but now you are a full employee - here's benefit package, executive washroom key, and 65 hours of mandatory HR training videos...

If you really hate Amazon don't use them.

If you really want Amazon to pay their workers more, things on Amazon will get more expensive. It's math not greed.

In this case the expenses are only going up in NY so only those customers need to pay more. You know the customers that elected the people to try more socialism as a solution. This is how it works.

Fail, you have.
 
Thats seems illegal, besides how would they know the financial records of the people working there?
US don't have private data protection as in EU. There are a lot access to people data, financial status and so on. It is crazy, but in US where everyone pretend the 'free' market works it is actually a common practice:
"Gig nursing apps may determine pay by what the firm knows about how much a nurse was willing to accept for a previous assignment, how often they bid for shifts, or how much credit card or other kinds of debt they might hold. These uncertainties combine to create frustrating and precarious conditions for the workers who rely on these apps."
you can easily find more info on it.

now with Amazon. If a driver delivers 10 packages an hour (at minimum), and Amazon would require to increase the posting cost to 5 usd, this would mean they need to raise 50 usd an hour to afford this postion. And that with everything else - car, system, cameras, being already supplied by them. For anyone with space filled between ears it is clear it is a total bs. The point is, Amazon pays 18 to 25 usd per hour (actually they pay per block, but that is an average hour payment). Out of that payment, driver have to cover expsnses: car rental, petrol, parking tickets, and as well taxes, as he is self employed. In reality, that person takes home as little as 8 to 16 usd per hour. If Amazon would have to actually hire the driver, drivers wont be paying anymore for fuel, car rental and so on. Additionally, they would have to pay them decent money, some benefits, so those guys actually could afford a bit normal life. No one, especially rich ones, wants it.
And for the cost aspect: in Europe this is illegal. Amazon pays a proper wage to drivers because regulation prevents big businesses exploiting the citizens. Somehow, prices aren't higher in EU amazon stores, delivery is free as well, drivers are happy, and Amazon still makes plenty of money. But in US money is the only god, and if they can grab one more cent at a cost of poor people, yaaa-hoooo.
 
Back