Apple Watch Series 4 review round-up: Universally loved

Shawn Knight

Posts: 12,409   +121
Staff member

Apple’s new batch of iPhones received the lion’s share of attention at last week’s media event but they weren’t the only new hardware on display at the Steve Jobs Theater that day. Cupertino also unveiled the Apple Watch Series 4, a bigger yet thinner version of Apple’s popular smartwatch.

Two days out from launch, Apple has lifted the review embargo, allowing early testers to share findings regarding their usage over the past week. Here's what they have to say.

We start the round-up with an unboxing and review video from Justine Ezarik from iJustine.

Dieter Bohn with The Verge likes the added screen real estate:

Things look different when the screen turns on. The screen on the Series 4 is just incredibly good. Apple says it’s 30 percent bigger, which is one of those specs that’s easy to just sort of pass over when you read it. But 30 percent is a lot, and you absolutely notice it right away.

It’s still OLED so the blacks are truly black and blend into the watchface glass. But if you pick a full-screen watchface, you’ll see that the screen also goes closer to the edges of the Watch than before, including the rounded corners.

The overall effect makes the square display on my Series 3 look dumpy and cramped by comparison — even though, until last week, it was arguably the best smartwatch screen on the market. As John Gruber writes, “The Series 4 displays take up so much more of the face of the watches that the new 40mm watch’s display is larger than the display on the old 42mm models — the new small watch has a larger display than the old large watch.”

Edward C. Baig with USA Today talks hardware improvements:

The new watch feels zippier, too; there’s an updated processor. The speaker is considerably louder as well, a benefit when you’re listening to Siri or communicating via the new Walkie-Talkie app that arrived with watchOS 5. The Walkie-Talkie app – each person presses an onscreen button on their respective watch screens to talk – might come in handy when it is better to convey something by voice rather than text.

Phone calls are louder, too – though, frankly, I still struggled to hear my wife during a call in my car and struggled as well during another call when I was indoors.

(Image courtesy iMore)

Brian Heater with TechCrunch on the watch’s thickness and battery life:

Apple also managed to make the new watch thinner than its predecessors. The benefit there is obvious when it comes to making a product designed to be worn on the body. And the slightly larger case size means Apple was able to accomplish this without having an impact on battery life.

It’s an interesting choice, given that much of the competition has zeroed in on battery life with recent upgrades, including, notably, the new Galaxy Watch, which Samsung rates at “several days.” With good reason — battery has long been one of the biggest issues with smartwatches.

As with earlier versions, Apple rates the Series 4’s battery at “all day,” which certainly lines up with my own testing. Even so, I would happily trade a millimeter or two of thickness for some additional mAhs. As it stands, you should be able to get through a day’s use without worrying about finding a charger, but the peace of mind of more battery life is always welcome.

David Phelan with The Independent dishes on the digital crown:

The crown is a useful way to interact with the Watch, rotating to let you scroll up and down lists, pressing in to confirm a selection, for instance.

But there's now haptic feedback in the Watch. That's the little vibration which is delicate enough to feel like a gentle press. So, as you wind through a series of elements, like songs in a playlist, for instance, you feel a gentle acknowledgement as each song passes. It's intensely subtle and makes a genuine difference to how intimate and personal the Watch is to use. Listen closely and you can even hear the feedback, sounding like nothing so much as the noise a regular watch makes when it's being wound.

(Image Vjeran Pavic, The Verge)

Wired's Scott Rosenfield on sensors and software:

Besides health tracking, the watch's new optical heart rate sensor should make a difference in capturing exercise data, which I tested while hiking, running, and lifting. In all instances, it performed comparably to the Series 3—good for most endurance training efforts. Optical heart rate sensors can get tripped up by cold weather and jostling, which I tested by hiking at elevation. The Series 4 captured the workout without issue.

On the software side, watchOS 5 continues to refine the watch's UI. Regardless of which Apple Watch you own, you're going to want to update the software. (The latest update is available on the Series 1 and onward.) The new software offers grouped notifications, automatic workout detection, podcasts, and a Walkie-Talkie app, all of which make the watch more pleasant to use. I found myself unexpectedly excited for automatic workout detection—if you didn't measure it, did it really happen?—and runners will love the new rolling mile measurement, cadence, and target pace notifications.

Peter Wells with The Sydney Morning Herald summarizes it as follows:

Apple is now competing with itself, and the Series 4 is leaps ahead again. The hardware is fast enough that no interaction has lag, be it flicking your wrist to turn on the screen, or tapping a complication to launch an app.

Eleven years after the release of the iPhone, Apple’s most important product offers only incremental improvements with each new update. This seems to disappoint pundits, who demand giant leaps in technology with every release. But those wanting year over year drastic improvement need only look at the Apple Watch, which shows no signs of slowing down.

(Image courtesy iMore)

Rene Ritchie with iMore argues that Apple Watch is the most important product the company has ever made:

Apple Watch is the most important product Apple has ever made. That's not hyperbole. It's certainly not fan-service. And you'd have to be literally the worst, burned-out, buzzed-up back-pager with an XS Max-sized stick up the apps to even consider calling it bull$#!+.

Because Apple Watch saves lives. And it does it over and over again.

By staying connected to you and keeping you connected, even in times of crisis and emergency; by encouraging you to stay active, regularly, reliably, quantifiable; and by alerting you to potentially life-threatening conditions and situations before they threaten your life, Apple Watch has been consistently, repeatedly, legitimately saving lives.

Now, sure, phones save lives. Tablets. PCs. Helicopters. Ultrasounds. A lot of technology, old and new, medical and general saves live. Absolutely. But Apple Watch is uniquely positioned, literally, to do so in dedicated and persistent ways.

Lead image via Vjeran Pavic, The Verge

Permalink to story.



Posts: 3,836   +1,183
I would really like to dig into the smartwatches thing, I found the galaxy watches and the Fossil ones awesome looking while having all the perks, however... the fact that they won't last through more than a day with a single charge is a no-go for me.


Posts: 2,448   +1,717
I would really like to dig into the smartwatches thing, I found the galaxy watches and the Fossil ones awesome looking while having all the perks, however... the fact that they won't last through more than a day with a single charge is a no-go for me.
Depending on how you use it, I'm getting about 2 1/2 days on my G3 Frontier, but I also don't wear it when I get home after work, or wear it to bed. I turn it off. So it's getting that 2 1/2 days, being used only about 12 hours per day.

Squid Surprise

Posts: 3,226   +2,110
Until the battery isn't an issue, I'd never consider it.... actually got one as a present last year for my birthday and exchanged it for credit towards the iPhone X...

I have a watch that is self-winding... no battery, and it will last forever - or at least until I break it :)

Until the battery is "self-charging", I'll pass.
  • Like
Reactions: m4a4