European game dev unions publish a manifesto calling on studios to ditch generative AI

Daniel Sims

Posts: 2,650   +80
Staff
What just happened? Use of generative AI in game development is now widespread and controversial. As tech giants promote the productivity gains the technology supposedly offers, developers and users debate its usefulness, impact, and ethics. Several European game development unions have recently come out flatly against GenAI, summarizing every major criticism of the technology, including its environmental impact, accusations of stolen material, its cognitive effects on workers and employers, and more.

Unions representing game developers in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Spain, and Italy recently published a lengthy manifesto calling on companies to abandon or at least carefully monitor GenAI use. The document cites numerous studies on the technology's negative impacts in different sectors of the workforce.

Interestingly, the manifesto's section on using human input to train AI without consent is its smallest, but the unions stress that this doesn't diminish its importance. The AI industry has previously admitted that the technology can't exist without copyright infringement, and a Microsoft executive even called it the largest labor theft in human history.

The manifesto also alleges that many workers are being implicitly and explicitly forced to use GenAI, which shouldn't be necessary if it always saves time and increases productivity. Instead, the unions cite studies saying that the technology makes tasks more monotonous and causes skills to atrophy.

Bosses can also experience cognitive surrender from excessive GenAI use, which impacts how they interact with employees. Furthermore, workers claim that GenAI often performs tasks traditionally assigned to junior employees, eliminating job openings and stemming the flow of new talent.

The unions accuse GenAI vendors of obfuscating the technology's costs to employers in a scheme to eventually monopolize knowledge and skills. As workers train AI that starts out cheap, employers might find themselves locked into more expensive contracts after the AI replaces workers and captures institutional knowledge previously held by workers.

In conclusion, the manifesto primarily recommends avoiding GenAI. However, if a developer chooses to use it or finds no alternative, it should work with employees to define clear regulations.

The worldwide percentage of developers using GenAI remains unclear, but the available information indicates it is high. For example, 86% of respondents to a Japanese survey in September admitted to using the technology in some capacity. An earlier survey indicated that more than half of developers believe GenAI is harming the industry.

GenAI use already sparked strong union action in 2024, when the Screen Actors Guild fought for clear guidelines regarding the technology. The dispute also involved video game voice actors, with dozens of titles eventually accepting AI usage agreements.

Permalink to story:

 
"The manifesto also alleges that many workers are being implicitly and explicitly forced to use GenAI"

Well there is the problem, forcing people to do something they don't like or enjoy doing never works out. Give people the tools and let them decide for themselves if it helps or not. Forcing stuff upon people has never worked.

"As workers train AI that starts out cheap, employers might find themselves locked into more expensive contracts after the AI replaces workers and captures institutional knowledge previously held by workers."

Thats the problem with these TECH companies, Greed always gets the best of them. Always starts low prices and then slowly increases it until its unaffordable.
 
How to shoot yourself in the foot...

GenAI is way to broad a term. Creating gameworlds has been 'AI' for ages, no one is going to create entire worlds in an open world game by hand. So arguably that's something we've been doing for ages already.
They like those barren sterile looks of worlds / homes? Hope they do because filling them with random clutter generatively and then making manual adjustments after if needed saves a ton of work.

They want to take away effective tools from individuals/smaller studios to create works of art they couldn't have achieved 5 years ago?

Now I hate the AI slop games that are flooding Steam etc as much as the next guy but that's where curating should come into play, not blanket banning an entire concept.

Not to mention it's useless anyway, if they think it's going to affect what they do in the US/China they're mistaken. Literally advocating for wanting to fight with one arm tied behind their back.

Even they could push it through, good luck distinguishing between what's a smart algorithm and what is AI.
 
Last edited:
Sadly with A.I is practically the proverbial "Pandora's Box"....there's no closing it, there's no way around it...there's only regulation that can help mitigate it.
 
If farmers abandoned their tracktors we could all pick up hoes and go dig a ditch. Imagine all the labour that would enable. We could end unemployment in one night if we turn electricity off. That makes all the sense, right?
 
For software companies, ditching AI is roughly equivalent to closing the company.

Even now, it's possible a single person to be a 'studio'.
It's still quite costly as a personal hobby, and the result does not always meet expectations - but in two years everyone who wants will be able to make their own games at 1% of today's cost.
 
If farmers abandoned their tracktors we could all pick up hoes and go dig a ditch. Imagine all the labor that would enable. We could end unemployment in one night if we turn electricity off. That makes all the sense, right?
I think in case with farmers it is more like borrowing from neighbors' fields rather than abandoning heavy machinery. I mean, it yields a lot more crops and stopping it would greatly reduce farmers' income. Nobody is asking small creators permission to use their work. And in no time, many of those small creators might not be able to earn the living as more people switch to easier more convenient way to get the same from AI. I do not care much if China built an entire industry around stealing from American AI companies. But millions of small people who will most likely start losing money should not be thrown away because someone invented an elegant way to borrow without making it look like theft to the majority of the people.
 
Back