PSA: A popular thermal paste is destroying CPUs and heatsinks

DragonSlayer101

Posts: 956   +13
Staff
WTF?! Thermal paste improves heat transfer between a CPU and its heatsink, helping prevent overheating that can throttle performance or damage hardware. While some products perform as advertised, others can be largely ineffective. A new investigation now suggests that one popular thermal paste may actually destroy processors and render them unusable.

According to PC hardware expert and IgorsLab founder Igor Wallossek, the SGT-4 thermal paste sold by the South Korean company Amech contains an unstable, reactive compound that is damaging CPUs and coolers by corroding their metal surfaces. The resulting corrosion causes pitting and can permanently fuse the processor to the heatsink.

The thermal interface material reportedly emits a highly unpleasant odor, which Igor describes as putrid and vinegar-like. The paste also fails to meet its thermal rating because the pitting creates additional air gaps on the CPU and heatsink surfaces, reducing heat transfer efficiency.

Wallossek's analysis revealed that SGT-4 uses PMDS as its base, but instead of standard silicone, it incorporates an acetoxy-crosslinked RTV silicone. He believes the additive is methyltriacetoxysilane – a highly reactive compound that releases acetic acid when exposed to moisture, causing copper oxidation and producing the vinegar-like odor.

Partial cross-linking also causes the paste to harden over time, becoming sticky and bonding the processor to the heatsink so tightly that it requires "an immense separating force" to separate the two surfaces.

Wallossek believes that the methyltriacetoxysilane increases the grease's adhesiveness, but the company likely did not test the product thoroughly before releasing it to the market.

Complaints about Amech's SGT-4 have appeared on the South Korean public forum Quasar Zone, where users reported similar issues and metallurgy experts corroborated Wallossek's findings. However, Amech dismissed the reports as baseless, insisting that the product contains no hazardous substances and complies with all regulatory standards.

Amech representatives also dismissed Wallossek's allegations as unfounded and directed personal attacks at others who raised complaints. Instead of addressing the actual claims, they cited European environmental certificates, which bear no relevance to the corrosion issue.

Little is known about Amech beyond the fact that it is a relatively new brand. The company has no official website, no professional email domain, and no confirmed business address, raising further questions about its legitimacy. As for the SGT-4, it remains unclear whether engineers in South Korea developed the product or if it is a rebranded Chinese item.

Despite these concerns, Amech's SGT-4 remains widely available on Amazon and Newegg, where it holds a relatively high rating that could lull buyers into a false sense of security. If you are searching for an effective and safe thermal paste, consider proven products such as Thermal Grizzly Kryonaut, Arctic MX-6, or Noctua NT-H2, all of which provide excellent performance without risking CPU damage.

Permalink to story:

 
Well, the plan is to use PTM7950 (as it seems much better than paste). So no chance of buying crappy paste here...
 
Just a tip, to deal with heatsinks fused to CPUs because the thermal paste turned into concrete or superglue, just boot the machine and run a CPU stress test for a few minutes. This might loosen the paste, it has worked for me in a few occasions. Never happened in my own builds because I don't use random no name thermal paste, but I've seen it happen quite a few times when dealing with friends, relatives and clients builds. Not even the cheapest $10/100g jar thermal paste I've used has ever turned out like this, I don't know where they even find this kind of slop that passes as thermal paste.
 
Arctic MX-4 (or MX-6 if you are feeling fancy). I've used it for decades, never had an issue. It's not stupid-expensive and 'just works'.

Just to add: buy it from the Artic Store on Amazon, NOT from random sellers as Amazon is the wild west these days and half the stuff on there is counterfeit - and definitely avoid the Ebays or AliExpress's etc!
 
Just a tip, to deal with heatsinks fused to CPUs because the thermal paste turned into concrete or superglue, just boot the machine and run a CPU stress test for a few minutes. This might loosen the paste, it has worked for me in a few occasions. Never happened in my own builds because I don't use random no name thermal paste, but I've seen it happen quite a few times when dealing with friends, relatives and clients builds. Not even the cheapest $10/100g jar thermal paste I've used has ever turned out like this, I don't know where they even find this kind of slop that passes as thermal paste.
Its a tip for anyone’s paste, not only cheap one. I use dow 5888, and it also needed some heating up before I waterblock/am4 cpu removal
 
"PSA: A popular thermal paste is destroying CPUs and heatsinks Beware while buying cheap thermal pastes from unknown brands"

If it's popular then it isn't unknown. How about "Only use tested and proven thermal paste."
 
I just stick to Arctic Silver 5. I've been using it for the last two decades without a problem on any CPU installs or cleaning and repasting GPUs.
I mean, I understand why you would stick to a proven good method but come on man, Arctic Silver 5 is so 2003.

There are cheaper, better performing pastes out there, that don't have a danger for capacitance. It is time to move on.

(Coming from a long-time Arctic Silver 5 user)
 
I have switched to Thermal Grizzly's KryoSheet for everything except my RTX 4090 and I plan to do it soon. I now never have to repaste anything ever again.
 
Like anything else in your built PC...whatever you cheap out on, is what will doom it.
Power supply, thermal paste...anything else.
 
I've been using graphene pads for years now and they work better than pastes and leave the surfaces in pristine condition when removed. They are also reusable if you are extremely careful.
 
It probably is popular with first time builders going by prices alone. Experienced builders stick to a handful of proven brands.

Exactly my thoughts! I've been using a couple brands for the last 30 years or so. If it works, no need to change, and price alone does not make for a great product. Some learn this the hard way...
 
Things not to skimp out on, the CPU, the RAM, the motherboard, the thermal paste and CPU cooler, and the power supply. Everything else you can go pretty cheap, except maybe throw in the new power cable for your crazy expensive Nvidia GPU. Many pastes will stick hard after a long time of use, but I've not seen anything corode components like that.
 
That's why I only use Artic's MX-4 & MX-6 exclusively. Haven't had any issues using their thermal paste since I started building PCs since 2007.
 
I think this brand it's representatives and all associates should be utterly ashamed of themselves and their incompetence, do they understand how PR works? Seems like the answer is no. An investigation should be done into who was directing personal attacks at customers. It's pretty unbelievable of you to come at the people who are providing your paycheck. I guess you'll have to think about that as you watch your stocks sink. Too bad I guess
 
I think this brand it's representatives and all associates should be utterly ashamed of themselves and their incompetence, do they understand how PR works? Seems like the answer is no. An investigation should be done into who was directing personal attacks at customers. It's pretty unbelievable of you to come at the people who are providing your paycheck. I guess you'll have to think about that as you watch your stocks sink. Too bad I guess
These aren't real companies, they will sell until they get a bunch of bad reviews and the sales tank. Once the sales tank, they simply rebrand, open a new virtual store, and sale the same garbage and just repeating the cycle. There are a lot of those companies on Amazon so I am careful of which products I buy. It better maybe spend a little more money for something that is know to be of good quality than to cheap out and be disappointed.
 
Back