Damaged coral reefs can be saved with enticing underwater soundscape, study suggests

Alfonso Maruccia

Posts: 1,025   +301
Staff
In context: Coral reefs are underwater ecosystems built by colonies of coral polyps held together by calcium carbonate. They are rich in biodiversity and are sometimes referred to as the "rainforests of the sea." Despite occupying less than 0.1 percent of the global ocean area, reefs host at least a quarter of all known marine species.

Researchers aim to stimulate new growth in damaged coral reefs by "bathing" them in sound recordings taken from reefs teeming with life. A recently published study describes what could be a promising new method to restore healthy conditions to coral reefs, offering scientists the opportunity to save and repopulate one of the most vital marine ecosystems.

It is estimated that half of the world's coral reef habitats have disappeared since 1950. A lethal combination of global warming, overfishing, pollution, and disease outbreaks has contributed to this dire situation. Researchers are now trying to restore the damaged reefs by relocating artificially-raised coral colonies capable of withstanding today's warming ocean waters.

NadeÌÂge Aoki, a researcher at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts, is proposing a different approach to reef repopulation. Aoki and her colleagues built on previous research studies concerning coral larvae swimming towards reef soundscapes and developed their own sound contraption to test the new method.

The researchers deployed a system of underwater speakers off the coasts of the US Virgin Islands, in the Caribbean Sea, initiating an experiment involving three different coral reefs. They played sound effects simulating busy reef activity at only one reef, to test how the coral larvae they released in the seawater would respond.

After broadcasting the sounds of a healthy reef for three nights, Aoki and her colleagues discovered that coral larvae were, on average, 1.7 times more likely to settle at the site where the sound was played. Settlement rates decreased away from the underwater speaker system, indicating that the broadcast was indeed responsible for the larvae's increased activity levels.

Aoki stated that the study yielded interesting and promising results, but more research is needed to determine if other coral species can benefit from healthy reef soundscapes, and how the new settlements develop over time. The ultimate goal, Aoki emphasized, must be to ensure the survival of the new coral colonies.

Marine biologist Steve Simpson noted that he has been using reef sounds to attract fish larvae to coral reefs for 20 years. If we can preserve the dying coral reef ecosystem, Simpson believes, "we can save anything."

Permalink to story.

 
What a seriously flawed study. You're basing research on only 3 nights? Ridiculous! Where's the repeatability, multiple locations over not just 3 nights but several weeks, months, years. Did they try different sounds from different reefs around the world?
Either we are missing lots of information or this so called study is a joke which doesn't deserve funding.
 
What a seriously flawed study. You're basing research on only 3 nights? Ridiculous! Where's the repeatability, multiple locations over not just 3 nights but several weeks, months, years. Did they try different sounds from different reefs around the world?
Either we are missing lots of information or this so called study is a joke which doesn't deserve funding.

First, relax. Research has to start somewhere. Scientists don't have unlimited funding. Before you can get funding to do what you are describing, you often have to show small scale promise first, and these researchers did that. Before you attack the study you should at least read the paper that this article links to.

The paper is quite thorough in describing the experiment and qualifying the results. Some excerpts:

"The experiments were conducted at three shallow coral reef sites: Salt Pond (18.30806698° N, 64.70905197° W), Cocoloba (18.31528002° N, 64.76064996° W) and Tektite (18.309561998° N, 64.72218004° W)...

The benthic composition, local fish communities and ambient soundscapes of these sites have been studied for several years...

Playback treatments of ‘healthy’ reef sounds consisted of four 12-h soundscape recordings taken from Tektite reef in August 2013, a time prior to the recent disturbances within the National Park of hurricanes Irma and Maria in 2017 and the outbreak of stony coral tissue loss disease (SCTLD) in 2020...Each night of the experiment, one of the four 12-h soundscape recordings was randomly selected for playback. Files were synched to play at the same local time when they were recorded between 18.00 and 6.00. This 12-h overnight playback cycle was selected to allow the solar panels to recharge during the day and to ensure that the playback treatment would include crepuscular periods of fish chorusing...

Playback experiments took place between 30 June–3 July and 30 July–2 August 2022. We enriched the soundscape at (I) the degraded reef site (Salt Pond) and compared rates of P. astreoides settlement within cups with those of (ii) the unenriched degraded reef (Cocoloba), where a RAPS system was placed and powered on but played no sound, and (iii) the higher-quality reef (Tektite), where no enrichment device was placed. The two unenriched sites served as prospective negative and positive controls for the effect of natural soundscapes on settlement...

In July, in order to investigate the fine-scale temporal impact of acoustic enrichment on larval settlement, an additional eight cups, each containing 10 larvae, were placed at Salt Pond and Cocoloba (four at each site) at 1 m from the speaker. Two cups per site were progressively removed from this distance at 24 and 48 h and scored for settlement. As noted above, all other cups from all three sites were scored after 72 h, providing a comparison of settlement after one, two or three nights of sound enrichment or control."

And as to the results:

"These results provide, to our knowledge, the first field-based study showing a positive effect of acoustic enrichment on coral larval settlement...
While other studies have demonstrated variable settlement responses in coral larvae along naturally occurring gradients of sound [41,42], this is, to our knowledge, the first study to replicate these results using cues emitted by an introduced sound source...
This is also, to our knowledge, the first study to demonstrate increased settlement of invertebrate larvae placed at extended distances from a sound stimulus, up to 30 m away."
 
Coral Palooza lineup: Nine Inch Sails, Pearl Jam, Temple of the dog fish, Rage against the manatee, the bubbling lips, Corallica, Lady Glub Glub, Daft Plunk, Outclam... and counting.
 
Back