Gas stations accused of using AI to inflate fuel prices in class-action lawsuit

midian182

Posts: 11,726   +177
Staff member
Winners & losers: Once again, AI is blamed for something else besides failing to cure cancer. A class-action lawsuit in California accuses gas-station operators of using the tech to increase prices at the pump by as much as 30 cents a gallon in some areas.

The class action claims the defendants, which include BP, Circle K, Marathon Petroleum, 7-Eleven, Walmart, and Albertsons, violated California's main antitrust law, the Cartwright Act, writes Reuters.

The suit also claims the alleged conduct violates Assembly Bill 325, a state law designed to address algorithmic price fixing that took effect at the start of 2026.

According to AAA, California residents pay the highest gas prices in the US, at $5.56 per gallon, considerably higher than the $3.92 national average.

The complaint adds that Kalibrate's AI-powered price-optimizing tools have been used to push gas prices to levels reaching $7 per gallon. That's not far off the UK's equivalent average of around $8.10.

Kalibrate is also named as a defendant in the Sacramento federal court case. The lawsuit alleges its tool used data from competing gas stations to help coordinate higher prices, and seeks unspecified damages for California drivers who allegedly overpaid.

The defendants operate over 1,700 gas stations in California, with each extra penny added to the price of gas costing drivers in the state an extra $134 million per year, according to the suit.

"While families struggle to afford the commute to work, defendants have conspired to put an end to competition, joining an AI-powered trust to ensure that no matter where a driver turns, the price for gasoline is artificially high," the complaint said.

There has been plenty of controversy over the use of AI to price goods and services. Back in March, it was reported that Walmart had secured two US patents this year covering automated markdowns and machine learning-based demand forecasting.

This isn't a new problem, either. In August 2025, Delta Air Lines was forced to deny using artificial intelligence to set ticket prices based on individual customer data, responding to concerns raised by several members of the US Senate. The airline issued its statement following criticism from lawmakers who alleged that Delta was exploring advanced pricing models designed to tailor fares to the maximum amount each customer might be willing to pay – a practice sometimes referred to as surveillance pricing.

The California case is the latest incident likely to increase anti-AI sentiment. From job losses and data center construction to an internet filled with slop, the technology isn't being hailed as the miracle that many executives expected. But while just 16% of Americans think AI will benefit society, chatbot use among US adults has climbed to an all-time high of 49%.

Permalink to story:

 
Another day, another gaslighting anti-AI article. Since gasoline first began being sold, stations have always looked at prices of nearby competitors and altered their own price accordingly; there is nothing illegal nor unethical about doing so, especially since more often than not, stations which do this try to undercut their competitors, if only by a few cents.

The complaint adds that Kalibrate's AI-powered price-optimizing tools have been used to push gas prices to levels reaching $7 per gallon
As the article notes, California prices today are $5.56/gal. The only time they neared $7 was in 2022, well before any AI software was being used. California gas averages much higher than the rest of the nation for several reasons, such as a far high gasoline tax and special demands on the types of blends which can be sold in the state.
 
This sounds more like something you'd tackle with a regular algorithm rather than AI.
Not saying AI wasn't used but price manipulation to maximise profit has happened in many sectors way before AI was a thing.
 
Once again, AI is blamed for something else besides failing to cure cancer.
OK, this a new low. You simply can't be more ridiculous.

This is the first time I hear AI was blamed for failing to cure cancer. You may as well blame it for failing to produce a perpetual motion machine, which would have brought the gas prices down to zero.

AI is the very last reason for the high prices of everything in California.
 
Another day, another gaslighting anti-AI article. Since gasoline first began being sold, stations have always looked at prices of nearby competitors and altered their own price accordingly; there is nothing illegal nor unethical about doing so, especially since more often than not, stations which do this try to undercut their competitors, if only by a few cents.

As the article notes, California prices today are $5.56/gal. The only time they neared $7 was in 2022, well before any AI software was being used. California gas averages much higher than the rest of the nation for several reasons, such as a far high gasoline tax and special demands on the types of blends which can be sold in the state.
You do know gas hit $7+ at some gas stations in Cali and hit $7 in some county in Cali in May. Avg. for the state then was like $6.20. It's now around $5.56.
 
I think the lawsuit centers on this: Kalibrate’s “AI-powered price-optimizing tools” were allegedly used by multiple gas stations to coordinate price increases above normal market-driven levels.

The claim appears to be that the algorithm did more than simply recommend prices. It effectively set them while factoring in nearby stations that used the same software, allowing prices to rise across a broader area rather than at a single location. The lawsuit argues that this amounted to unlawful price coordination.

If that is not what happened, then the article is misleading. It needs more substantive investigative reporting rather than a clickbait headline supported by minimal journalism. I hope that is not the case.
 
California gas tax: 71 cents per gallon
Federal gas tax: 18.4 cents per gallon
That's almost NINETY cents per gallon
Toss in their "special blends" that are suppose to reduce "pollution", limited refining
capacity and VOLLA! Gas in California is over 5-6 dollars per gallon.
 
Back