I think your PC gaming use case is just very different from mine
I mostly play single-player games, RPGs, immersive sims, and souls-likes. I have an RTX 3080-powered rig hooked up to a 55-in TV with a La Z boy in front. More than pixel-perfect aim, I’m looking for something that’s fine for Doom Eternal at Nightmare (which is the SC). My priority here is immersion. I’ve got a G402 and a Keychron K6 mechanical keyboard, but I mostly use them for work, and they serve me well enough the one time a year I jump into a multiplayer game. For 3rd person A-RPGs like Dark Souls 3 and Nioh, the capacitative D-Pad and the paddles are a boon. The paddles are the two extra buttons Nioh 2’s default config is missing so having the SC makes for a radically better experience. Would I use this for multiplayer? A bit of casual Destiny 2 here and there sure. Is it good for the single player campaigns in twitch shooters? Absolutely. Would I use it for regular multiplayer? No, but again, not what I use it for.