Musk goes full Musk after X gets hit with a €120 million EU fine

midian182

Posts: 11,624   +176
Staff member
Winners & losers: Elon Musk and X are no strangers to public outbursts. Their latest involves the entire European Union, which Musk has called on to be abolished after it fined his company 120 million euros, (around $140 million) for violating the Digital Services Act (DSA). X has responded to the fine by shutting down the EU's ad account.

The EU penalized X on Friday following a two-year investigation into whether it had violated the DSA, which was introduced in 2022. It marks the first time a company has been fined for violating this law.

The DSA makes online platforms more accountable for illegal content, transparency, user safety, and how they use algorithms. It forces big platforms to moderate harmful content faster, explain recommendation systems, reduce risks like misinformation, and give users more control over what they see.

In X's case, the breaches are related to the "deceptive" design of its blue checkmark, the lack of transparency of its advertising repository, and the failure to provide access to public data for researchers.

In his typical style when dealing with something he doesn't like, Musk replied to the EU's post about the fine with the word "Bullshit."

Not content with that remark, Musk followed up a day later with a message that was longer than his single expletive. "The EU should be abolished and sovereignty returned to individual countries, so that governments can better represent their people," he wrote. The world's richest person has also retweeted a lot of anti-EU posts over the last few days.

Following this flurry of anger, Nikita Bier, X's head of product, accused the Commission of using an exploit to artificially boost the reach of its post announcing the fine.

Bier wrote that the "irony" of the EU's announcement is that the agency logged into its dormant ad account, which had not been used since 2021, to take advantage of an exploit in the Ad Composer. The commission allegedly used this to post a link that deceives users into thinking it's a video, thereby artificially increasing the reach. Bier later wrote that the exploit had never been abused this way and was now patched.

In addition to calling out the commission for its alleged behavior, X has revoked the European Commission's ad account, meaning it can no longer buy and track ads on the platform – though it may not care much if it hadn't used the service for four years.

Others have spoken out against the fine. Secretary of State Marco Rubio called it an "attack on all American tech platforms and the American people by foreign governments," in a post.

"Today's excessive €120M fine is the result of EU regulatory overreach targeting American innovation," said Andrew Puzder, the US ambassador to the EU.

"The Trump Administration has been clear: we oppose censorship and will challenge burdensome regulations that target US companies abroad. We expect the EU to engage in fair, open, & reciprocal trade – & nothing less."

X now has 60 days to inform the Commission of how it plans to address the blue checkmark issue. It also has 90 days to submit a plan to resolve the issues with its ads repository and access to its public data for researchers.

Permalink to story:

 
Both Musk and Rubio are greatly overestimating the importance of X for the EU (or for anywhere else in the world besides the US, for that matter). If X left Europe entirely, european people would be happy about it.

Hell, go a step further, make X US-only. That way Musk doesn't have to worry about those pesky laws and fines other countries impose on him, and he can focus on X's main purpose (foreign bots pretending to be american conservatives to cause divisiveness and destabilise the US), while other countries no longer have to tolerate this valueless social media, everybody wins!
 
I’m just trying to imagine the comission gathered around a computer, logging into that dormant account, to exploit a bug in X.

It’s easy to forget the EU is not a single person dictating rules and regulations. These people go trough endless meetings and argue endlessly about every single detail in such tenacity that a normal person would die of frustration or boredom.

And that’s how we get things like the cucumber directive.
 
I’m just trying to imagine the comission gathered around a computer, logging into that dormant account, to exploit a bug in X.

It’s easy to forget the EU is not a single person dictating rules and regulations. These people go trough endless meetings and argue endlessly about every single detail in such tenacity that a normal person would die of frustration or boredom.

And that’s how we get things like the cucumber directive.
Omg the EU tried to have a QA rule about produce that ended up being a bit silly? How do those people survive with their public health care and cucumber standards!

The American way of deregulating everything until it's completely corrupt or non-functional is definitely better.
 
I can see no one read the article and this is just a Musk hate circle jerk thread. We deserve to be killed off by AI. Let's give up all our rights because it's in vogue to hate Musk

"Let's take a widely hated public figure, do something illegal and the general public will hate that person so much they won't care that their rights are being taken away. Once we set a precident we can then do the illegal stuff we're doing to the public figure to everyone!"
 
I can see no one read the article and this is just a Musk hate circle jerk thread. We deserve to be killed off by AI. Let's give up all our rights because it's in vogue to hate Musk
The only one here who missed the point is you. This has been in the news for days. Rich man gets fine. Rich man mad. Rich man lash out. End of story.

The part about the EU commission using an exploit on X to make its post more visible is kinda funny, but not of any real substance.
 
The only one here who missed the point is you. This has been in the news for days. Rich man gets fine. Rich man mad. Rich man lash out. End of story.

The part about the EU commission using an exploit on X to make its post more visible is kids funny, but not of any real substance.
It's funny because they breached X's Terms of Service and then fined them for what they did when they breached their ToS
 
I can see no one read the article and this is just a Musk hate circle jerk thread. We deserve to be killed off by AI. Let's give up all our rights because it's in vogue to hate Musk

"Let's take a widely hated public figure, do something illegal and the general public will hate that person so much they won't care that their rights are being taken away. Once we set a precident we can then do the illegal stuff we're doing to the public figure to everyone!"

Reddit is frothing at the mouth right now, it’s just one giant circle-j3rk because that’s the cool thing to do.
 
It's funny because they breached X's Terms of Service and then fined them for what they did when they breached their ToS
It is funny, and just makes X look that much dumber. EU proved X can fix the exploit in a heartbeat when it's used in a way they don't like.

EU making X look like it's run by a bunch of stupid people trying to selectively boost their narrative is indeed a bit funny.


Something tells me that's not how you wanted to spin this...
 
Reddit is frothing at the mouth right now, it’s just one giant circle-j3rk because that’s the cool thing to do.
Is this supposed to be a defence of Musk? People on reddit poking fun at Musk... What is your point?

Do you guys ever get tired of being so disingenuous?
 
It is funny, and just makes X look that much dumber. EU proved X can fix the exploit in a heartbeat when it's used in a way they don't like.

EU making X look like it's run by a bunch of stupid people trying to selectively boost their narrative is indeed a bit funny.


Something tells me that's not how you wanted to spin this...
Right, I'm trying to spin things when I point out that the EU is using social engineering to make the public okay by having their rights taken away.
 
Is this supposed to be a defence of Musk? People on reddit poking fun at Musk... What is your point?

Do you guys ever get tired of being so disingenuous?
I enjoy my objective viewpoint and judging those who believe they’re righteously clinging to their (often incorrect) viewpoints like they owe them money.

And then you throw in group think and herd logic, and you come up with the cesspool that is Reddit. 😉

Nothing disingenuous about it, it’s simply reality. Identity politics is very easy to spot, and entertaining everytime.
 
Back