Can you elaborate?
im not doubting your experience, because I do hear it a lot, even from a close friend who went AMD due to availability after being Nvidia for a long time.
I cant really argue the point either, because I have always been AMD for the last 10 years (mind you thats only 2 pcs and about 3 GPUs in that time)
ive had a HD5850, r9 280X, Rx580. ive also had some friends go from intel and nvidia over to all AMD and not have any complaints at all. and in my limited experience, I've not had issues with my AMD cards in regards to bugginess or driver problems. (again, im not saying they dont exist).
but yeah, just interested is all.
Well, I can attest to the fact that the RX 5000 series has had some SERIOUS hiccups. Now, I think that it's probably the fault of AIB partners because, as Steve Walton and Steve Burke both pointed out, they were unable to re-create the issues that people had been experiencing with their RX 5700 XT cards.
The thing is, the cards that they get for testing are ALWAYS the top-end fancy-pants, RGB-loving cards like Steve's beloved PowerColor RX 5700 XT Red Devil. These aren't exactly a good representation of what most people buy because who's going to spend an extra $200 just for a glowing Red Devil logo in their PC and maybe a 7fps increase? I mean, sure, it is beautifully done and some people do buy them but they are the exception rather than the rule. I always get the cheapest versions of cards that I can because the performance differences between the different variants tends to be insignificant. Also, I don't OC my video cards so I'm not concerned about them running above stock speeds.
The reason for my theory about Steve's inability to reproduce the problems that people have had is that I had ordered an XFX RX 5700 XT Triple-Dissipation (which was a whopping $90CAD cheaper than the standard going price on the ASRock and Gigabyte cards). Since I'd never had a problem with XFX cards before (I ran twin XFX HD4870s in crossfire for years with perfect stability), I didn't care how cheap it was. It was a Radeon RX 5700 XT made by a recognised brand, a brand that I'd used before with no issues and that was good enough for me.
However, that thing was SO unstable that I took it out and slotted one of my (Sapphire) R9 Furies back in. I didn't even bother changing the driver (because they use the same one) and immediately, all of my problems ceased. Clearly, the problem was the card itself because if it were the driver, swapping my R9 Fury back in wouldn't have immediately restored full system stability like it did. So, I sent my Triple-Dissipation card in to XFX for RMA.
Fortunately, the R9 Fury is still usable for most games (it even ran GODFALL decently! LOL) so it's not like I was really suffering while I waited. In fact, when the replacement card arrived, I waited until the weekend to put it in my rig because my case is gigantic and heavy. It's an old-school heavy-gauge steel monolithic full tower and it's a pain in the butt to work on. The upside is that you could theoretically run a server out of it.
So, the Triple-Dissipation card had been triggering a buzzing green screen accompanied by a system power reset. Now, I've seen driver issues cause in-game artifacts and I've seen them cause entire games to crash to the desktop, but never a system power reset. This little conundrum was puzzling me out of my mind because there's no way that my PSU was the problem:
As you can see, I don't cheap out when it comes to power supplies.
It was XFX who actually (unintentionally) gave me my theory. This is because instead sending me another Triple-Dissipation card, they sent me a THICC III. When installing the THICC III, I noticed that while the Triple-Dissipation's power connectors were 8+6:
The THICC III's power connectors were the full 8+8:
Since the system power resets didn't occur with the THICC III, I formulated a hypothesis. The reason why the reviewers couldn't replicate the issue was that their cards were all the fancy, high-end cards (like the Red Devil) which would all have had the full 8+8 connectors. Since the 8+8 doesn't cause the system power reset issue, none of the reviewers would have experienced it. Since most people tend to buy the least expensive versions of a card (and especially OEMs), literally tonnes of people would've had this problem.
The issue that persists is the need to use
Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) before installing a new driver set. It's not a huge deal because I just have to disable my internet connection in device manager and either run DDU in safe mode or run it twice in normal mode. Then I re-enable by internet connection and install the new driver package normally. It's a hassle in the way that it shouldn't be necessary but it's a piece of cake to do. For people who aren't tech-savvy however, this would be an absolute
nightmare.
I believe that this is what Sausagemeat may have been referring to.