Originally posted by Phantasm66
Why?
Why should you avoid using RMA drives as important backup devices, you ask? Well, allow me to share my experiences.
1.) I bought a Western Digital 6.4gb (retail).. It just happened to be missing an IDE pin (for some odd reason), so it didn't work properly. I RMAed it and when I got the RMA back, it worked for 3 months and died. I RMAed that one, the new one died in 3 weeks (!). I RMAed again, the next one died in a few months as well. I then sent it to PCguide.com to be a test subject because I didn't want to waste my breath on the phone.
2.) I bought a 13gb Western Digital (OEM). Sadly, it died in 1 year. I sent it back (Oh my god!) and recieved the RMA drive. It died around 2 months after I got it. I RMAed it again.. It died 1 week afterward!! I then RMAed it again and sold the RMA to a friend for 20 bucks. It died on him 6 months afterward!! hehe! :dead:
3.) My friend bought a Maxtor 30gb. It died about 1 year after he had it. He has RMAed it a totaly of 4 times, and every single time the drive has died in less than 3 months, usually only a few weeks of operation.
4.) Need I go on?
I have had simliar experiences with other people's computers that I've "fixed". There's been at least 2 instances I remember that the RMAed drive died prematurely. This time with an IBM and another Western Digital.
As a matter of fact, I have never seen (in person) an RMA drive that still exists to this day (With the exception of 1 which is a fairly recent IBM 30gb). I know they are out there... Perhaps you have some.. But in person, I've never seen it.
And that is why I do not trust RMAed drives. This is too much to be a coincidence.