Sony wins $2.6 billion PlayStation Store pricing lawsuit, but digital game prices could still rise

midian182

Posts: 12,074   +184
Staff member
What just happened? The long-running billion-dollar lawsuit Sony has been fighting in the UK over allegations it used its "monopoly position" to inflate the price of digital games has gone Sony's way, though an appeal is still possible. London's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claim in its entirety on Tuesday, finding that the claimants had failed to prove Sony violated competition law.

Consumer rights campaigner Alex Neill filed the lawsuit way back in August 2022 on behalf of an estimated nine million UK PlayStation users. At the time, the claim was worth up to £5 billion, or around $5.9 billion. Sony tried to have the case thrown out, calling it "flawed from start to finish," but the tribunal allowed it to proceed in November 2023, when the figure being reported was $7.9 billion.

By the time the two sides went to trial in March, the number of players covered had grown to around 12.2 million, while the amount Neill was seeking had fallen. The final claim was for a still enormous £1.49 billion in damages, rising to £1.97 billion ($2.6 billion) with interest.

Neill's argument will sound familiar to anyone who's ever found a boxed PlayStation game going cheap while the digital version was still full price. Retailers can undercut each other on discs, but if you want to download a game or buy DLC, Sony sets the price on the PlayStation Store. Neill argued that Sony's 30% cut pushed up prices and that players would have paid around 20% less if rival stores had been allowed onto the console.

The tribunal disagreed that buying a PlayStation effectively locked players into paying whatever Sony wanted. It added that someone weighing up a PlayStation against an Xbox or a Nintendo console could take the price of games into account before buying the hardware. And for anyone with a disc drive, that cheaper boxed copy was itself a reason for Sony to keep its digital prices competitive.

There was also the question of how much Sony actually makes from a PlayStation. The company sells consoles at thin margins or even at a loss, counting on game sales to make that money back. Looking at the business as a whole, the tribunal found no evidence that Sony's profits were excessive.

Neill says she's considering whether to appeal. The tribunal will hear any application for permission to do so during the week of December 14.

Sony will stop releasing new PlayStation games on disc in January 2028, though publishers can still reorder discs for existing titles. The tribunal said the change fell outside the period covered by the lawsuit, but it also noted that losing competition from retailers selling boxed copies could give Sony room to raise digital prices.

A July price comparison gives PlayStation owners an idea of what they stand to lose. Dutch site Tweakers tracked 16 PS5 games and found that Final Fantasy VII Rebirth was cheaper on disc than on the Dutch PlayStation Store around 90% of the time. Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart, meanwhile, still cost €80 on Sony's store five years after launch. A new boxed copy was going for around €40

Permalink to story:

 
Their used to be benefits to console gaming like cheaper barrier to entry, consistent experience and used games was an easy way to keep costs down. Now, Sony is just making a PC with a locked down ecosystem. They are vastly overplaying their hand on market dominance
 
The PS5 is just basically the default go-to machine for non-tech users to buy when their children want to play Roblox and Fortnite.

I guess Sony wants more profit for the few other games they sell themselves.
Digital-only, no competition, this is their way to go.
 
With the physical distribution Sony had the same control over the price as with the digital one, so not sure what's the issue with it. Sellers of physical games just sell it without any gain after some time to make space for new ones. And buying the games digitally for full price makes little sense, sales are every few months often beating physical, unless game is ancient and shops want to get rid of the stock.
At the same time, if reduction of the physical option is enough to sue, or high prices and lack of competition, all the consoles plus steam could be sued for same.
 
Maximal profits at the expense of the consumers while the service degrades… there’s even a book about it, what was it called … 🤔
 
Back