How about commenting what I wrote, not what You Think I wrote?
I'll give it a try
Like I said, you're forgetting many things. 5800X3D is 8 core, not 4 core. 7700K did not have CPU attached NVMe (like AM4 had). There was no good productivity CPU available for LGA1151, there is for AM4 etcetc. You just cannot directly compare there two CPU's.
That"s very evident if you actually read and try to understand my comments. Perhaps that's too much to ask...
So we take a 5800x, underclock it, and add a bunch of cache to make it better at games... and sacrifice a few % in productivity...
The actual "stats" of the 7700 were/are obviously different - we're talking several years ago and PCs have evolved (but not your AMD slant - we'll get to that later). But his point - that the Intel was the better gaming CPU while getting beaten in productivity is certainly valid for this conversation.
That we are even comparing the 12900 and 5800X3D, however, is patently absurd. The 12900 is double the price! Assuming price wasn't a concern though, only a complete AMD fanboy (ie: HardReset) would be purchasing the 5800. The 12900 performs almost exactly the same in games, while absolutely destroying it in every other benchmark.
And while we use 1080P benchmarks to see the THEORETICAL performance differences between CPUs, remember that at higher resolutions, the difference in ACTUAL gaming performance between almost ANY CPU is virtually identical - almost all modern games are GPU bound, not CPU bound.
Since most of us (obviously not HardReset) live in the real world, and cost IS a concern, the CPU to get - and this has been mentioned MANY times - would be the 12700 (or even the 12500) as they will be virtually identical in ACTUAL gaming performance, will thrash the 5800 in productivity, and are far cheaper.
The only people the 5800X3D make sense for are those who already have an AM4 motherboard and need an upgrade - and MUST have the best GAMING CPU AMD offers. Right now, the 5900X is selling for CHEAPER than the 58003DX - while it's not quite as fast at games, it is WAY better in productivity and would be the better buy.