Federal judge calls Flock search unconstitutional, as AOC and Bernie Sanders introduce bill to ban license plate readers

Daniel Sims

Posts: 2,656   +80
Staff
The big picture: While a federal judge's finding that an Oklahoma police officer's Flock database search was unconstitutional doesn't change legal precedent, it signals a shift in how the law views networked surveillance cameras. As communities across the US turn against the AI-powered devices, lawmakers have begun calling for new restrictions, and in some cases a federal ban.

Oklahoma federal judge Sara Hill described automatic license plate readers (ALPRs) as a form of indiscriminate mass surveillance, comparing them to dragnet-style searches. Her ruling suggests that networked cameras like those sold by Flock and Axon differ fundamentally from other police surveillance tools, with consequences for the law and for citizens' expectations of privacy.

In May, Tulsa County Deputy Sheriff Freddie Alaniz, parked along the side of a highway, saw a vehicle with a California license plate pass by and followed it solely because it bore out-of-state plates. After running the plate through Flock's AI-powered nationwide database, he pulled the car over, supposedly for changing lanes without a turn signal.

While questioning the driver, Melisa Kyle, Alaniz reviewed more than 50 instances in which Flock's cameras had detected her vehicle traveling across the country, and searched it on suspicion of drug trafficking. Although he found roughly 91 pounds of meth in Kyle's SUV, the court threw out the evidence, ruling that the Flock search lacked probable cause and a warrant.

Arguably the most important detail is that Hill declared the search a Fourth Amendment violation, breaking with prior rulings involving ALPRs.

Other judges have likened Flock cameras to other police surveillance methods and noted that drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy on public roads. Hill, however, found that Flock's nationwide database puts it in a different category, giving officers a vast trove of data to search without a warrant on theoretically anyone traveling across state lines.

ALPRs, which use AI to automatically sort license plates from passing vehicles into a searchable database (sometimes inaccurately), have drawn fierce pushback across the nation. As officials question their impact on privacy and dozens of officers are caught using them for stalking, many communities are attempting to remove Flock cameras, and don't always succeed.

As surveillance companies weigh expanding into mobile drones, lawmakers are pushing back. Late last month, Florida Republican Rep. Greg Steube introduced a bill requiring warrants to use ALPRs.

Meanwhile, senators Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley, and representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez recently introduced the Ban Flock Act, which would bar federal agencies from using ALPRs and cut off federal funding for them.

Permalink to story:

 
“While questioning the driver, Melisa Kyle, Alaniz reviewed more than 50 instances in which Flock's cameras had detected her vehicle traveling across the country, and searched it on suspicion of drug trafficking. Although he found roughly 91 pounds of meth in Kyle's SUV, the court threw out the evidence, ruling that the Flock search lacked probable cause and a warrant.”

So, the system did exactly what it said it would, the officer did his job (pattern recognition, welcome to probable cause 101) and this is a bad thing?

This exact situation is something Bill or Hillary Clinton (and almost all of society) would have been all over the media championing such a victory on drugs and crime 20, 25 years ago.

And now enough ignorance has been thrown into the mix, we’re throwing the baby out with the bath water.

GJ, can’t wait to see crime rates increase for absolutely zero good reason.
 
I support license plate readers.
There is no right to drive.
Driving is a privilege.
Those without insurance, inspection clearance or drivers licenses shouldn't be on our roads.
The license readers let the cops know immediately who to go after.

NEXT: I want the gun detectors from Total Recall.
 
I support license plate readers.
There is no right to drive.
Driving is a privilege.
Those without insurance, inspection clearance or drivers licenses shouldn't be on our roads.
The license readers let the cops know immediately who to go after.

NEXT: I want the gun detectors from Total Recall.
Unless there are sufficient systems to monitor usage and punish bad actors, holding departments accountable for screwups, such mass surveillance will only come back to haunt us.

How many innocent people have we seen get arrested because these Flock systems misread a plate? How badly were their lives disturbed, how much money did they have to spend to get themselves out of those situations? Because we know the police were never held accountable or made to pay for damages.

Add onto the fact that those who oppose these systems were labeled terroists by the company and by law enforcement personnel. We've gone far beyond useful toll into trying to shame people into accepting mass surveillance. A system that refuses to hold bad apples accountable does not need mass surveillance powers.
 
I read the original document and the officer used a K-9 unit to establish probable cause and finally search the vehicle. The article here fails to omit that.

Before the officer had probably cause though, the judge objected to almost everything in the investigation during the traffic stop that led the officer to using Flock to search for the license plate (as well as using Flock itself). This ruling would stop officers from even being able to use a K-9 unit and effectively eliminate any tool state troopers have in catching drug trafficking. This case is almost exactly like the following video:

This ruling is certainly going to be overturned lol. The judge heard the defendant's story, couldn't understand the trained narcotics officer's reason for investigation, and thought the defendant should've been free to go without any further investigation (despite the defendant willingly sticking around to answer questions).
 
Last edited:
So the police officer found a drug trafficker, with an amount that can severely damage or kill thousands of people, and that's bad ????????

If this violated the rights of the drug trafficker, how about the rights of the thousands of victims?
Damn right. In fact I would say a felon trafficking narcotics should have zero rights
until court.

Bill to ban license plate readers?

How about roll back the entire Patriot Act?!

Allowing unfettered total surveillance on US citizens except this one way is a meaningless political theatre to distract from the real problem.
A lot of people don't have a clue just that would stop the spying our government is doing in its tracks. Get us back to a time when spying and tracking citizens would only be permitted with strong proof there is a crime.

Law enforcement has to get a warrant to listen in on phone calls and that looks like nothing now with what they are getting away with.
 
So the police officer found a drug trafficker, with an amount that can severely damage or kill thousands of people, and that's bad ????????

If this violated the rights of the drug trafficker, how about the rights of the thousands of victims?
It's the slippery slope of power abuse. Next thing you know, they will track your vehicle just because they don't like your comments on social media, or Techspot. Or any other reason at their disposal. They will find something out of you, and anyone of us.
 
What a joke. 91 pounds of evidence thrown out. Hard to understand. After all, evidence is evidence. I wonder how many people will be imbibing that **** any day now?
 
What a joke. 91 pounds of evidence thrown out. Hard to understand. After all, evidence is evidence. I wonder how many people will be imbibing that **** any day now?

Legal process technicalities are a criminals best friend!
 
People worried about license plate scans when literally everyone including WalMart is using facial recognition.
And smartphones (which the Feds have live, unfiltered access to), and any modern vehicle, and any smart fridge, smart devices anywhere, cameras in most large metropolitan areas in public, internet connected cameras anywhere.. I could go on.

But yeah, let’s hyper focus on a targeted approach to apprehend criminals and ignore the ongoing, perpetual surveillance we’ve been under since before the turn of the century.

Makes perfect sense if you’re an unrealistic sensationalist who hops on the nearest bandwagon with little common sense.
 
So the police officer found a drug trafficker, with an amount that can severely damage or kill thousands of people, and that's bad ????????

If this violated the rights of the drug trafficker, how about the rights of the thousands of victims?
FYI...

You have the right to knowingly put anything you want into your own body.

Food, Food you're allergic to, tobacco products, solids and liquids that are not food but are not poisonous, alcoholic beverages, poisons for entertainment, poisons for suicide, the list is endless.

Feel free to knowingly inject yourself with lead propelled by gunpowder.

People buying his products are not victims.
 
FYI...

You have the right to knowingly put anything you want into your own body.

Food, Food you're allergic to, tobacco products, solids and liquids that are not food but are not poisonous, alcoholic beverages, poisons for entertainment, poisons for suicide, the list is endless.

Feel free to knowingly inject yourself with lead propelled by gunpowder.

People buying his products are not victims.

Disclaimer: I use recreational drugs.

The problem is that there is a big moral difference between someone selling a known quantity of a known substance to an informed adult, and someone selling fentanyl as heroin, selling unpredictable pills, selling to children, deliberately encouraging an addicted person to take more, or knowingly supplying someone who is clearly in immediate danger.

I’ve dealt with a lot of dealers over roughly 40 years, and in my experience most don’t “push” drugs onto you. You go to them because you want something. That doesn’t mean every dealer is trustworthy, though. If you don’t know the person well, you absolutely have to worry about what is actually in the product. And yes, I’ve come across the occasional arsehole over the years, I just don’t go back to them.

There have also been places around me offering free drug testing, which I think is a very sensible harm-reduction measure. If people are going to take drugs anyway, removing ways for them to find out what they are actually taking doesn’t stop drug use — it just makes it more dangerous.

Laws can discourage some people, but they clearly don’t stop everyone. If the goal is genuinely to reduce harm, then giving people accurate information about what they are putting into their bodies seems far more useful than pretending prohibition removes the risk.
 
I think there is a reasonable middle ground here.

Flock itself is not automatically the problem. License plate readers can be extremely useful for stolen vehicles, missing persons, violent suspects, and other legitimate investigations. I do not think the answer is necessarily to ban the technology outright.

Where I start to have a problem is when that technology becomes a shortcut around normal constitutional protections.

In this case, the drug dog alert could ultimately provide probable cause to search the vehicle. But the important question is what justified continuing the detention long enough to get to that point. If the traffic stop was already finished, police still needed a legitimate reason to keep the driver there. That is where the Flock history became important.

I have some personal perspective on this. Years ago I drove from Florida to Texas on I-10 and was pulled over three times. My truck was searched and nothing was found. Each time, the fact that I had Florida plates seemed to make me more interesting to law enforcement.

That does not mean police should be prevented from doing their jobs. But a license plate, a state of origin, or a travel pattern should not by itself turn someone into a drug suspect.

My concern with Flock is not that a camera saw a car on a public road. It is the ability to type in a plate and instantly reconstruct weeks of a person's movements without a warrant. That is a very different level of surveillance than an officer simply seeing a vehicle drive past.

So I land somewhere in the middle.

Keep the technology. Use it for real investigations, emergencies, stolen vehicles, and active suspects. But if police want to dig backward through someone's travel history over days or weeks, there should be a higher legal threshold, and in many cases a warrant.

That protects legitimate police work without turning every driver's movements into an open database that can be searched simply because an officer has a hunch.

The fact that drugs were eventually found does not erase the constitutional question. The rules have to be based on what police knew before the search, not what they found afterward.

At least the drugs were taken off the street. That is a win by itself!
 
Up front: skip the privacy debate. I’m white middle class born and raised American and don’t give the slightest about public privacy. I use a plugin called I don’t care about cookies to just auto accept all cookies and skip the nonsense banner. I like targeted advertising for the ability to support sites I use for products I’ll actually buy. I don’t care if you film me, in the park, naked, whatever. I simply don’t care.


That out of the way, zero-contact policing is in service in over 100 countries to some degree, from local to national.
It works. Cameras capture the violation, a trained officer reviews it, and a ticket is sent to the owner of the car (the car owner or responsible for crime committed by people they authorised to use their car). It ends any claims of racism. It ends false pretext.

In this case it did exactly what it was supposed to do. I found a criminal. Who stopped the care for an unrelated infraction. The dog found drugs. The car was searched. Drugs were found

Not only will this be overturned, if I were the police chief facing this kind of judicial abuse, I’d file a recourse grieving against the judge. Get them deflocked (wink) for blatant… be it abuse or ignorance, they have no business being on the bench.
 
Back