"Software is over": Developer uses AI to build free Adobe clones after frustration with cancellation fees

midian182

Posts: 12,080   +184
Staff member
Big quote: Adobe, a company that was once sued by the US government over its early cancelation fees, has seen plenty of customers abandon its products in favor of free alternatives. One developer has even used AI-powered reverse engineering to create a suite of tools intended to replicate Adobe's apps, leading him to declare that "software is over."

As Ars Technica reports, developer Brandon Thomas is taking on seven of Adobe's best-known applications through Artcraft. The project extend beyond Adobe's famous photo editing program to video production, vector graphics, page layouts, and PDF tools.

In his Reddit announcement, Thomas says he used Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5 to build the replacements in Rust. Photocraft imitates Photoshop, while Vectorcraft and Filmcraft take on Illustrator and Premiere. Lightcraft, Effectcraft, Designcraft, and Printcraft are the alternatives to Lightroom, After Effects, InDesign, and Acrobat Pro, respectively.

The apps are open source and free, with no subscription required. Users can download the source code, modify it, and contribute fixes. Thomas describes himself as a software industry veteran with 15 years of experience, including roughly a decade working with Rust. He also insists the project has team support and will not be abandoned after launch.

"We're going to reach 100% parity within a month," he said, which is an ambitious claim.

Thomas did seem to curb his enthusiasm in comments on Hacker News, though he still said reaching 99% parity would take months rather than years.

For now, the software remains at an early stage, and commenters have reported problems with basic functionality. They might look like Adobe's apps, but it doesn't sound like they're able to replace the long-established programs just yet.

Thomas says Adobe's cancelation fees helped motivate the project, which is understandable.

In June 2024, the US government sued Adobe over allegations that it concealed early termination charges and made subscriptions unnecessarily difficult to cancel. Customers ending certain annual plans early faced fees amounting to half their remaining payments. Adobe disputed the allegations, saying its terms were transparent and its cancelation process straightforward.

In March 2026, the company agreed to a $150 million settlement, comprising $75 million in civil penalties and $75 million in free services for customers. The agreement also required clearer fee disclosures and easier cancelation, though Adobe continued to deny any wrongdoing.

As for who pays to keep these seven free applications going. Thomas says Artcraft's separate business selling tokens for AI image and video models will help cover development costs. He's also asking users to report bugs and contribute improvements.

Read our feature: Decompilation on Steroids: Why AI Is Suddenly Cracking Open Old Software

There are also the potential legal implications. It's hard to imagine that Adobe will be overly pleased if the ArtCraft apps imitate its products a little too closely, though the company has done little to earn the public's sympathy.

Adobe users already have other options, of course. We previously dived into Photoshop alternatives including GIMP, Krita, and Photopea. Artcraft's pitch is that familiar Adobe-style tools could make switching easier, without the recurring bill and the cost of canceling early.

Thomas believes other developers will follow suit, predicting a future where free, near-identical open-source versions of popular paid apps will be widely available.

"Now you can just create 1:1 functional equivalents, clean room, that are highly performant and cross-platform. Nothing is stopping you," Thomas wrote. "We'll replace Google Search, we'll build our own smartphones, we'll build better infra. We'll remove all the ads and de-enshittify the entire tech world."

"Software is over," he declared, somewhat boldly.

Permalink to story:

 
"For now, the software remains at an early stage, and commenters have reported problems with basic functionality." Yup, that sums it up.

I have 20 years of software development experience and I wouldn't tackle these kind of apps. I'm not a fan of Adobe but I have seen enterprise software. And it's not the code that's the problem, it's all the approvals and interconnections. For instance in one app there's an integration with the Swiss border patrol. Crazy!
 
Reddit's top voted comment for this story is funny lol...

Claude 5.5 just copied the entire photoshop suite in one call. 2000 tool invocations. 100,000+ lines of code. 400 brand new files. It modularized everything. Broke up monoliths. Cleaned up spaghetti. None of it worked. But boy was it beautiful.
 
It’d be laudable if the alternatives weren’t already there.

A better option would be creating an alternative for the one Adobe product most ahead of the current alternatives.

Doing one thing extremely well usually beats doing many things mediocre.
 
A.I would eventually replace many types of software and their developers but until then those trying A.I based utilities are no better than guinea pigs....I guess no better than actual developers releasing buggy software.
 
All the big companies love AI. Now lets see for how long that love last when AI is used against them.

It will be specially interesting when it begins to affect Nvidia, Microslop, Google and the memory makers.
Memory makers are (relatively) safe.

Even if anybody manages to fit all of those LLMs into ¼ of memory AI uses now, it wont do them a harm.
 
100% parity within a month, then 99% in months not years. Hey, that’s a completely reasonable correction after about 36 hours of Hacker News comments.
 
None of these programs will ever achieve parity, because the fake "developers" don't even know how to use them like professionals in the first place. AI isn't real, and it can't learn. Scraping code isn't intelligence.

Adobe is a terrible company, but CS6 still stands supreme and has for over a decade. Nobody needed anything beyond that, and every CC version since was outright trash.

Krita is nice but clunky, GIMP is gimped, but of all of them it's Rebelle that's the BEST one, and it's also the absolute god-emperor for digital painting too! And it's only $99 with excellent support. It has effectively replaced all other painting programs, in the pro world. But you still need Photoshop itself for many things, and that likely won't ever change.

Photoshop Express on Android however is utter tripe! They haven't updated it in several years, and I still pay $11.99 a month for their "suite", which doesn't actually exist.
 
@JaredTheDragon
Since it's without adjustment layers, GIMP is useless.

Photoshop Elemants (for PC), is actually quite good. (Unless you insist on editing channels, as there's no swapping.)

"Affinity". once a paid, "Photoshop (almost) replacement, is now free. The trick there is any AI, (and theirs is supposed subpar), is a pay to play option.

"Dark Table", is ostensibly a "Lightroom equivalent. It's open source, but it has a (reportedly), steep learning curve. There are links that can help with that. Here's one:

Download for Windows: https://www.darktable.org/install/ It's also available for some Linux distros. A PDF manual is available as well:

I'd like to see Photoshop cloned, but integrated with one of the currently expensive, AI upscaling programs. (AFAIK, PS & PSE are still using the "bicubic" method.)
 
While I hate Adobe in many ways, Photoshop, After Effects and to a lesser degree Acrobat are irreplacable. Once they lose that core group of human programmers, productivity in these types of software will suffer greatly. Especially PS, there is no substitute, not even close. The world will suffer greatly when that ends lol.
 
Will be good for the Linux community getting bot-cranked feature-complete implementations of the suites and applications it's missing. AutoCAD next maybe?
 
I just torrent what I want, you can just take Photoshop for free, example: Adobe Photoshop 2026 v27.11 (x64) Pre-Cracked {CracksHash} But always scan the folder before you use it, sometimes the crack could be a virus or a false positive.
 
Will be good for the Linux community getting bot-cranked feature-complete implementations of the suites and applications it's missing. AutoCAD next maybe?

AutoCAD was already replaced by Rhino 3D, almost thirty years ago. I know only a handful of people in the arch/viz industry that use Autodesk slop, other than Maya of course which is still the reigning CGI champ. But Rhino has outpaced AutoCAD in every way, and I still use it daily. Been a few years since I touched Maya since Chief Architect emerged, but it's still a powerhouse and easily the most complex program ever made.
 
Back